Torn

by The Creatorz

It's so hard to decide between two young men who both have a heart throbbing crush on the most beautiful girl in the school, Lily Evans. Little does she know the reason James wants her so much is to keep her away from Severus Snape. He believes that he will only hurt her, seeing how he is after all, a Death Eater. Let's just say he will do anything to keep her from harm.

1. Chapter 1

"Aww, come on, Lily, won't you go to the Yule Ball with me?" James Potter pleaded to the most beautiful girl in the school, the girl with the fire red hair and emerald green eyes. Lily Evans.

"James," Lily said, stopping in her tracks as she walked down the hallway to catch up with Severus for studying. "I wouldn't go out with you even if you were the last person on Earth."

But the way she said it made him know she was only teasing him. And she let him know that she was by elbowing him in the side. The two laughed together.

"But seriously, will you go with me?"

The smile she had on her face dropped. "I'll think about it." And she continued to walk. James didn't follow. Was that a...maybe? Lily was honestly torn between two males though. She liked Severus and James both evenly, yet couldn't decide.