AN: ok so this is my first ever fanfiction. Please don't hate on it :)

Disclaimer: I don't own the BTR boys but if anyone is willing to buy them for me I won't object lol

Summary: How could Lucy Stone ever choose between James Diamond and Carlos Garcia. Firstly both guys are great in their own ways and secondly she isn't into relationships- just one night stands so what will she do to make both her and the boys happy? Based of Big time rocker and rated M for a reason ;)!

James' POV

As I wait in the cabana for Lucy there isn't any doubt in my mind that she won't choose me. I mean come on I am James Diamond. There's no way she can't resist my charm, especially when my competition is Carlos. The boy has never had a girlfriend or even kissed a girl. Suddenly Lucy came into the cabana and walked up to me.

"James, I need you to know that i can't resist you anymore and that i choose you to me my new boyfriend."

Oh my god i am so happy. I knew she was going to choose me anyway but hearing it from her is so much better. I immediately lean in to kiss her but before our lips touch she holds her hand to my mouth.

"We don't kiss now. Meet me in my apartment in one hour."

"Should i bring anything?" I ask

"Bring some of your bandanas or something that i can be easily tied up in, and don't bother dressing up all fancy. You won't be wearing your clothes for that long anyway" She said seductively and winks at me.

I leave the cabana in complete shock and joy. I'm about to have hot, kinky sex with a rockstar! I head of back to 2J to get ready.

Lucy's POV

Now that James is my plan all that is left is Carlos. He is so adorable. I feel guilty that I'm using him for sex but I'm sure i won't feel guilty when he is pounding me. I walk into the next cabana where he is waiting for me.

Carlos' POV

I wait nervously in the cabana waiting for Lucy. I know she will pick James so i just want her to get the humiliation over with. She then enters the cabana.

"Carlos i choose you to be my new boyfriend."

"YES!" I cant believe it. She actually chose me not James. She's chosen the mighty El Hombre Del Flaming Space Rock Man over the pretty one.

"Do we kiss now?"

"Not now. Meet me in my apartment in 1 hour and 5 mins then we can do all we like"

"Do i bring anything?"

"Bring condoms. I wouldn't want to get pregnant at the tender age of 18."

And with that she left. I can't believe we are going to have sex. One problem, I don't have any condoms. I'll just steal some of James. He has so many i doubt he will care if he loses some.

Lucy's POV

Only 5 more mins until James is meant to arrive. I'm all ready. I have all the curtains drawn, I've got rock music on so people cant hear what we are doing and most importantly i'm wearing my sexy undies that consists of a Black lacy push-up bra, a black thong and black suspenders. Over the top im wearing a red lacy dress with a zip down the back. There is noway the boys will be able to resist me. Bang on time i hear a knock on my door, my signal that James is hear. I'm still not sure how this is going to go down but lets see what happens. I open the door and see James wearing a white vest top and gray jogging bottoms. He looks hot even when he isn't trying. I let him come in and he sits on the sofa.

"Do you want anything to drink? I have vodka, wine or cola." I ask him

"I'll have a vodka." he replies.

I walk over to the kitchen to pour his drink. i can feel his eyes checking out my arse but i don't care. That's all part of the plan. Make him wait. I go back over to him and hand him his drink.

"Lucy, i'm not gonna lie. You look so damn sexy in that dress. i just want to tear you out of it and tie you up to the bed with the bandanas i brought." He said.

"Lets see these bandanas of yours."

He takes out 5 bandanas, all purple.

"These will be perfect" I comment. With no warning he throws down the bandanas onto the coffee table and starts kissing me. I've never known anyone with such an amazing tongue. Its roaming all around my mouth finding my weak spots. i knew he was gonna be good but i didn't know he would be his good. next think i know there is a knock on my door. i pull away from James and get up.

"Cant you just leave it. We are in the middle of something here" James exclaims

"It might be important and trust me, we can continue when i come back." I leave waiting as i open the door to see Carlos. Things are about to get hot!

Carlos' POV

I arrive at Lucy's apartment right on time. I would say i'm prepared. Ive got 3 condoms in my back pocket, I'm wearing some on James' Cuda spray and I've done my hair all nice just for her. I've even left my helmet at home. She opens the door and is wearing the sexiest thing I've seen in my life. A sexy red number with black suspenders. I am so ready to fuck her. I walk into her apartment and to my surprise i see James there.

"James, what the fuck are you doing here?" I ask him

"I'm here to have kinky sex with my new girl friend. More to the point what are you doing here?"

A sense of anger overwhelms me. If Lucy has done this just to humiliate me she is a sick bitch.

"Lucy, what the hell is going on? You said i was your new boy friend. You even made me get condoms." I asked. I looked over at James and he had a similar expression of anger on confusion on his face.

"Look boys, you made me decide, but i couldn't. Number one both of you are both amazing in your own ways and number two i don't really do relationships. Just Fuck Buddies. And trust me what we are going to do is going to be much better with the 3 of us. We're going to have lots of fun."

Will continue later. Bye for now :)