Title: Careless Whisper

Pairing: Faye/Diana (Fayana)

Rating: M/NC-17

Written by: Nanda_SC and ari_dushku

Disclaimer: The characters Faye Chamberlain and Diana Meade are not ours. We do not own, nor have any official association with The Secret Circle, The CW or any other profit making entity. No infringement is intended.

Summary: When Faye gets bored, things usually get messed up. But this time, she really screwed things up. Big time.

A/N: Slightly AU. Faye and Diana have been friends since kindergarten. Only Faye, Diana, Melissa and Cassie are witches. Adam, Nick and Jake are not part of the circle. Set in the present days, the girls are around 16. Diana and Adam were together for some time, but it was over once she realized she wanted more. Faye and Jake have had a thing in the past, but it's also over now.

A/N: There will be lots of angst, lots of fluff and lots of smut. Don't like, don't read it.

A/N: Reviews are very much appreciated!

A/N: This came basically from a RP, so it alternates between Faye's POV and Diana's POV.

I'm never gonna dance again

Cause guilty feet have got no rhythm

Though it's easy to pretend

I know you're not a fool

I should have known better than to cheat a friend

And waste the chance that I'd been given

So I'm never gonna dance again

The way I danced with you

Time can never mend

The careless whispers of a good friend

To the heart and mind

Ignorance is kind

And there's no comfort in the truth

Pain is all you'll find

(Careless Whisper - Seether)

{Part 1}

Faye Chamberlain was at home, on a Saturday night, doing nothing but restlessly flipping through some TV channels. She was dead bored. Not a single exciting news, nor a party, anything. She couldn't take it any longer. So she did the first thing that came to her mind. She decided to call Diana and see if the girl was up to doing one of her favorite pastimes these holidays: the oh-so-famous sleepovers at Diana's house. Sometimes they would sleep at Faye's as well, but somehow Diana's father being more absent and leaving them with the house for themselves made everything more fun.

Faye grabbed her cellphone, and obviously she had Diana's number on speed-dial. "Di?"

Diana was sitting by the window seat of her bedroom, holding carefully on her hands her Book of Shadows, studying cautiously the spells her family has been writing for generations, trying to learn as much as she could before beginning to practice. But suddenly she lost her focus, as her cellphone started ringing from its place at her study desk. She went to her desk, and after seeing that it was Faye's calling, she answered it in no time.

"Hey, Faye! Is everything okay?" the girl asked immediately wondering why the other girl was calling her for.

"I know you're not doing anything and neither am I, so what do you say you and me do nothing together?" said Faye, using all her inherent persuasion.

"Who says I'm not doing anything? I was looking a little deeper into my Book of Shadows. You know that it's important that we learn more before doing any spell…" Diana knew she was pretty much talking to herself. She knew Faye well enough to know now that the girl wasn't calling asking for permission to go to her place. She was letting Diana know that she was coming. Period.

After a sigh and an eye roll, Diana replied "The door is open. Just come on up."

"That's my girl. And I think it's even better that you're studying your 'precious' Book of Shadows" Faye stated in irony "we can study it together, test some things."

Faye already knew her statement would probably put Diana in lecture mode on, saying that they were not ready yet, and all the yada yada yada Faye have had enough of.
This was how the two of them worked. While Diana was words, Faye was action. Maybe this was why they got along so well.

As Diana was measuring the words she'd use to try and explain once again why they shouldn't be practicing any magic yet, she heard Faye saying "I'll be there in 15." hanging up afterward.

Faye was going to get there in 15 minutes, and Diana panicked. She was still in her pajamas.

While running through her room, cleaning up the invisible mess that somehow Diana saw through her pretty neat bedroom, she asked herself why she was this nervous about seeing Faye there in her room, right in front of her.

This was happening with some sort of frequency, although she couldn't recall when exactly this all started. It wasn't like it was Faye's first time there.
They were best friends since little girls and had a gazillion sleepovers as growing up. Their friendship was the sisterly kind, but Diana could feel things slowly changing lately, involuntarily, or not.

Pretty much every time Diana caught herself staring at Faye, she's been feeling butterflies in her stomach, she couldn't also quite figure why. Actually, it seemed kind of obvious why, but Diana Meade was an exemplar girl, who hasn't skipped a day at school, nor has ever hooked up with a random guy. She couldn't have these sorts of feelings for a girl, especially one who has been her friend forever.

While Diana was changing her comfortable clothes to a more casual one, Faye — who had climbed the stairs silently — showed up opening the bedroom door in a perfect timing, as if she knew she was occupying Diana's thoughts, startling the hell out of the girl "Faye! Gosh! At least shout from downstairs to let me know that you are coming up!" Said Diana, trying to catch her breath and calm her trembling heart, perhaps not only just for the scare

"Hi, Diana. Hmm, so you're changing? Looks like I arrived just in the right time." Faye was using her flirtatious tone, which she happened to use on basically everyone, but when she did with Diana it always seemed more fun, probably because it always made Diana uncomfortable and Faye thought it was adorable.

"Sorry if I scared you. Go on, get dressed. But you don't have to wear anything fancy, it's just me" Faye sat on the edge of the bed, her eyes never leaving Diana's body, scanning each of Diana's curves. Probably without even noticing, she arched an eyebrow in desire.

Diana felt her cheeks and ears burning red. Faye sat there on her bed, staring at her half naked, as she hold onto her shirt in front of her, trying foolish to cover herself.
It's Faye, for God sakes! Not some stranger you just met! She thought to herself. Your best friend since ever, whom you've even taken showers with, so, what's different now? That was probably the million dollar question, why was she ashamed of changing in front of Faye now?

"Do you mind?" Diana asked, referring to her wanting to change without Faye staring at her in that way. Diana felt even more foolish for asking Faye that.

"In fact, I do. I think you should try this one" Faye got up, headed to Diana's wardrobe, choosing a way more revealing shirt for her friend. She removed the shirt covering Diana's body and replaced it with the one she had chosen. "Yeah, blue definitely best matches your skin tone" Faye said, with her characteristic half-smile, throwing the shirt Diana had earlier chosen in a chair across the room, well aware that it would annoy the cleaning maniac owner of the room.

"Faye…!" Diana nearly freaked out and tried to protest when her shirt was ripped from her hands from the other girl in front of her. She almost didn't mind the small mess Faye began to cause in her room when she was there almost naked – not exaggerating at all.

Faye was such a hurricane, leaving chaos everywhere she went. Diana had already tried to somehow teach Faye to be more organized, but she was a lost case. Before she could get more embarrassed than she already was, Diana quickly put on the blouse that the other girl had selected for her. As she did so, she thought she was going crazy, she could swear she was feeling Faye's eyes burning into her skin.

Without knowing what to do now that she was dressed, and Faye was sitting on her bed staring at her casually, Diana said the first thing that came to her mind "So, did you come here to stare at me?"

"Geez, Diana. That time of the month much?" Faye stated innocently, like nothing had happened and taking the Book of Shadows beside Diana's pillow.

Diana ignored what Faye said about PMSing. She wasn't at the time of the month. She was just a lot jumpier than usual lately. Especially when the subject was the girl who was currently opening her Book of Shadows, taking her away from her thoughts.

"Besides staring at you, I came here to see what goodies we can find in your book" Faye added, already flipping through pages and getting ready for the tantrum Diana was about to throw, 'cause it always happened whenever Faye touched the book.

It's not that Diana would never let Faye touch it. It just always came with supervision and speeches about how cautious they should be and how dangerous the content of the book was. Again with the yada yada yada…

Yes, Diana was jealous of her book. Part of her thought that she was the only one allowed to touch/handle it, but the other part said that she could always share everything with Faye. Even when she handled her delicate book like it was any other book.

"Be Careful, Faye! The pages are going to fall off if you keep skipping them like that!" She said sitting by Faye's side on her bed, almost hitting the other girl's hand as a reprimand.

"Uuuh, and that would be terrible, 'cause unfortunately we don't live in the 21st century and a revolutionary liquid called glue has not yet been invented" Faye joked, shaking the book in front of Diana's face.

Diana rolled her eyes to the other girl's joke, and she almost had a heart attack when Faye started to shake her precious book. "Faye! Stop it! Give it to me!" Diana said while trying to get the book from Faye's hands, but the girl was pushing her away with an arm, stopping Diana from reaching it.

Then things started to fell off the book. First a dry leaf, then a raven feather. Diana's eyes grew wider and Faye immediately stopped shaking the book when some of Diana's notes fell too.

Faye was always joking around, but she knew how much this book mattered to Diana. Diana… They were so different from each other, but whenever she thought about the girl, her mind filled with good thoughts from all the wonderful moments they'd had together, ever since they were kids. Faye would never do anything to hurt Diana, she loved her and she loved their friendship.

"Oops…. Sorry? Okay, I will stop messing around. Come here, let's see if together we can find something interesting" Faye leaned in bed, getting closer to Diana.

Diana sighed both in relief and in defeat after Faye finally stopped mishandling her book. She knew that there was no way of discouraging Faye of the idea of both practicing magic that night, so she let Faye have her fun. The other girl held the book so they both could read, skipping the pages that seemed less interesting and/or less colorful.

Things were calm, until their arms slightly touched; breaking chills over both girl's skins. Diana's heart skipped a beat with that, and she hoped Faye wouldn't notice her flushed cheeks.

Faye's presence beside her was so strong that Diana could barely concentrate on the spells contained in the pages. Faye, on the other hand seemed more focused now, carefully reading the book. What is happening to me? She asked herself. But before Diana could get lost in her many questions as to why she was feeling this way towards Faye, her eyes caught the words 'Incantation Spell' on top of the page that Faye was so concentrated reading. Oh no… not that spell.

Faye could choose any other spell… but not that. Diana involuntarily became uneasy beside the other girl. She thought about quoting any other spell that she read on upcoming pages, to try and get Faye's attention off of that specific spell, but none came in mind.

Faye started showing enthusiasm with her finding, while Diana tried in vain to convince her that this spell wasn't right for the situation or time. "I just don't think it's right to mess with other people's feelings! This is definitely a spell to be avoided… Besides, it could bring bad consequences! You should know better about spells backfiring. Do I have to remind you about the talking god incident?" Diana didn't leave room for answers "Keep looking, I bet it has something more interesting!" Diana said in a rushed tone, obviously nervous, stumbling over words almost praying that Faye agreed with it at least this once, but deep down Diana knew there wasn't any hope of that happening…

"First of all, talking dog was awesome. I don't see why you didn't let me keep it. Second, more interesting than this? No way. What terrible consequences must we be cautious for this time? Having anyone we want, anytime we want, doing anything for us? Oh, yes, what terrible fate." Faye put her hand on her chest, as if offended by the idea, sarcasm dripping from her words.

Her words were suddenly cut off by her cellphone ringing. She quickly grabbed it in her pocket and started to read a new text message "Hmm, Melissa said there's gonna be a party tonight!" Faye jumped out of bed, extremely excited, doing a sexy little dance with the book in her hands "So in the same night I find out a party AND a seduction spell? I think I'll have to start believing in all the crap you say about destiny, Diana. Nothing proves fate better than this! Now all we need is to find an outfit for me, another one for you and a bottle of anointed oil that I-happen-to-know-not-that-I've-ever-looked-there that you have inside your ingredients' cabinet."

Oh no, this is not happening!Diana thought to herself. Everything they needed now was an out of control Faye bewitching all the guys from that party! Just by that scenario, Diana felt what some might call jealousy. But since when was she jealous of Faye being hit on by boys?

Until recently, she was only envious. Good friendly envy coming from a girl who wasn't that lucky with boys, who admired the wits of her friend who caught everyone's attention with her exotic beauty. Not that Diana was ugly, quite the contrary. Her beauty was unique, but she lacked what Faye had plenty of: Attitude.

"Faye, I don't think it's smart …" Diana continued trying to convince the other girl, who was up searching Diana's closet trying to find a killer look for them both. Sighing heavily, Diana thought that this was going to be a long, long night…

"Diana, it's a party. Not a 'Who's more prudent competition'." Faye came back from Diana's wardrobe with two outfits, one in each hand "'Cause even if it were, we all know you'd win before it even began", Faye said, setting the dresses on the bed. Both dresses were strapless. A black one — which Faye had left at Diana's since her birthday sleepover — and a dark purple one. Both were stunning dresses.

"You should wear this one. It looks gorgeous on you" Faye said honestly, remembering the last time she saw Diana wearing that dress and for a moment she felt desire burning her eyes. Faye was not the kind of person who would be intimidated by being attracted to a person of the same sex, but she would never endanger the friendship she had with Diana because of a silly attraction. After all, she now had a spell that would let her have anyone she wanted. "C'mon. We go there, we dance, we put this anointed oil in the drink of whoever we find interesting, make out for a while, and then we come back home. It's simple and easy."

Diana considered Faye's proposition for a while. The way things were, certainly leaving the house and going to a party would do her some good, unlike staying at home, locked in a room with Faye.

She analyzed the dresses that Faye had picked up for them, and she could feel her shyness appearing as she looked at the dress Faye had chosen for herself, but she chose not to protest. It was best to just follow Faye's orders when it came to this kind of thing. After all she was the one who knew all about fashion and boys.

Who knows? Maybe Diana could catch some guy's attention – without the need of using any spells whatsoever – and forget about this turmoil of feelings that Faye was causing her.

While Diana got out of bed and walked towards the bathroom to change, she couldn't help but pay attention to Faye, who was beginning to undress right before her eyes. If there was a girl more beautiful than Faye in the face of the Earth, Diana was unaware of her existence.

Before letting her eyes wander through the other girl's curves, Diana went straight to the bathroom and locked herself there until that heat that started from nowhere — burning from the inside out — ceased. It was official, she was crazy. She was going mad over her best friend. Now what?

Faye analyzed Diana's confused expression as she entered the bathroom. She had seen expressions like that one before. She had used all her charms to earn expressions like that one. Maybe this… thing … I'm feeling… Maybe she feels it too, she thought to herself.

As soon as that thought crossed Faye's mind, she decided maybe she should push her luck. After all, she was feeling very lucky tonight. So, what if she tried to use the attraction spell on Diana?

If it didn't work out, she could always work her way around it and find a reversion spell and if only she was lucky enough, Diana wouldn't even remember it.

Faye was always up for some good fun, and this idea sounded like a whole bunch of fun.

Ugh, what the hell Faye thought, as she got up and ran downstairs, heading straight for Charles' liquor cabinet, grabbing a bottle of wine and two glasses.

Back in Diana's room, Faye poured the wine into the glasses, adding the four drops of anointed oil required for the spell in one of the glasses. Leaving the cups on the table, she continued to undress, thinking of a way to spend time while Diana was in the bathroom.

She then picked up Diana's favorite body lotion, pouring some big amount of it on her legs and massaging herself while waiting for Diana to come out of the bathroom.

Faye continued spreading the body lotion throughout her long legs for what seemed like an eternity. And when Faye was bored, she always tended to listen to the little devil inside her head.

Hmm, let's think this through. If four drops of oil into the drink equals seduction, what would eight drops of anointed oil do in body lotion?

And with that, Faye dropped the anointed oil on her legs, mixing it with body lotion.

Can't hurt if I try.

Diana didn't know how long it had taken to get dressed. Probably more time than necessary, but as she gathered courage and finally decided to get back to her bedroom, she came across Faye wearing nothing but sexy panties, spreading her body lotion on her body.

For a second Diana forgot how to breathe. When she started breathing again, she noticed two glasses of wine on her study desk. What's going on here?
As soon as Diana came out of the bathroom, Faye slowed her movements, shaking her hair so it would cover more of her face and torso, her nipples still showing.

Sometimes Diana didn't know when Faye was being unintentionally malicious or really mean. Whatever Faye's intentions were, she had managed to disturb Diana's mind in a way that might be irreversible now.

Trying to stay sane before such vision, Diana looked away from where the provocative figure of Faye was lying, as she spoke about why those drinks had appeared out of nowhere in her room. Curious, Diana cautiously asked as she finally found her voice "Faye, what are you doing?"

Faye got up slowly, feeling aroused herself, picking up her dress on the bed, she said "I fixed us some drinks to, you know, get in a party mood" she said, biting her lip and offering Diana the glass of wine which contained the ingredient for the seduction spell.

She knew that what she was doing was wrong, using her best friend like this, but she just wanted to have some fun.

Diana thought that maybe drinking a little bit would help her distract herself from Faye, maybe even let her forget those confusing feelings for her friend… or maybe not.

Faye raised her own glass for a toast "a toast…" she thought for a second before continuing "to the two sexiest witches on Earth" She arched an eyebrow "Cheers." Faye smiled and took a long sip of her wine.

"Cheers." Diana followed Faye in a long sip. She was not much of a drinker, but she did love wine.

"Told you you'd look gorgeous in it…" Faye said as she scanned Diana's body up and down, giving greater attention to her thighs, which were hardly covered by the dress.

The compliment and Faye's provocative eyes didn't make Diana blush this time. Could it be the effect of alcohol already breaking her wall of shyness?

"I'll get dressed too, don't wanna be late." Faye said in a sweet voice, which was classic Faye. A lot of teasing combined with a sweet voice, trying to sound as innocent as possible.

Faye spoke again and Diana barely registered the words. All she was hearing was her heart beating in her ears, her blood running fast and hot through her veins, and her accelerating breathing… Faye was all that Diana saw and felt. She could feel every fiber of the other girl's being, vibrating inside her, as if they were one.

Diana seemed distracted and Faye would probably give anything to get inside her mind and see what she was thinking. Maybe there's a spell for that as well… She considered.

Snapping Diana out of her thoughts, Faye asked "Would you help me close the zipper?" Faye teasingly asked. The help wasn't necessary at all, considering her dress had a side zipper, but she figured it would be the perfect opportunity to see if the attraction spell had worked, 'cause if it did, Diana wouldn't be able to resist touching Faye's skin as well.

Suddenly, Diana could no longer reason with herself. She simply moved mechanically, without looking away from the exposed skin of Faye's ribcage. She could feel the pale, soft and warm inviting skin calling hers to meet in a small touch.

Not resisting the impulse, Diana's thin fingers touched Faye's skin, and it was like an electric shock had passed from one to another.

Faye thought for a moment if she hadn't drink the potion by mistake, or if the idea of mixing the anointed oil with body lotion had actually been a good one, because she felt her whole body tingling with desire at the touch of Diana's hand.
A primal, carnal desire, she wanted her friend more than she'd ever wanted anything in life. A feeling so strong she would never be able to put into words.

Yes, she had probably thought about being with Diana before, the desire was somehow always there. It was the intensity that scared Faye this time. And this wasn't natural, nothing used to scare Faye.

Shit, Faye, what have you done? I can't ruin our friendship! I can't stand living without her! I just. I need her. Ugh! Fuck this! If I mess everything up — which probably I will — I'll just find a spell to erase her memory. And I'll have some amazing memories just to myself. Yup, sounds like a plan.

Faye's thoughts were mixed and confused. It was as if her brain was about to shutdown and let her emotions completely take over.

Faye came back to reality when Diana removed her hands for an instant, making Faye suddenly feel as if air had been sucked out of her lungs. Faye took Diana's hand and places it on her own neck, as if asking Diana to pull her closer.

"Diana? Please tell me …" She moved closer, her hot breath against Diana's lips.

Diana didn't have time to think. In fact she didn't want to. Something in her had changed, or perhaps awakened. She was the type of girl who usually calculated every step she took, but now she felt like acting entirely on impulse and desire. Maybe it was the effect of being in love with Faye that was finally being able to change her, or maybe it was something else.

Whatever had happened, Diana saw her own hand being placed in the back of Faye's neck,and her fingers brushed the skin there. She could feel chills break Faye's skin with the light touch of her fingertips on the nape of her neck.

"Tell me that you feel this…too." Faye finished, eyes focused on Diana's looking for an answer.

When Faye's low voice, slightly husky and full of desire caught her attention, she was already placed a few centimeters from Diana's face. Diana went from Faye's hungry eyes, to her inviting lips.

She didn't have time to think about an answer as Faye pressed her lips against Diana's. She just reacted the only way she could — kissing Faye back.

Slowly at first, but as soon as their tongues touched, the kissed turned into pure lust, tongues dwelling, heavy breathing, hands everywhere.

Faye sighed as they kept kissing, relieved by Diana responding the way she wanted her to, or relieved that the spell actually worked. Deep down, she really wished that Diana would want her without the help of any spell. But she knew that Diana would always see her as a friend, not as a lover.

And then Faye realized that if there was anyone in the world able to change her opinion about love, relationships and fate, that person would be Diana.

Her actions had finally sunk in. She had blown it. It had barely started, and she had already blown it, which had to be a record, even for her. And once again, Faye ruins the day.Not knowing if Diana's reactions were driven by her own feelings or by the spell, she decided that it would be better to just enjoy what she had already done.

Faye involved Diana with her arms, stroking Diana's back, intensifying the kiss.

Diana felt dizzy, although she only had taken one sip of wine that her friend offered.
Maybe being this numb was a side effect of Faye's kiss. The more she gave herself into those deep feelings she has for the other girl, letting Faye involved in her arms and deepening the kiss, the less she wanted that moment to end.

Her skin pulsed stronger as Faye's hands touched her, and Diana had the strangest feeling that Faye's hot blood ran in her veins now. She was so drunk with desire — desire to taste every part of Faye.

Without breaking the kiss, the hand that was in the back Faye's neck, went down her bare shoulder, until it found the zipper of her dress which was only half closed. She opened it, pulling the strapless dress down, and returned to run her fingers along the side of Faye's body. With her other hand on the girl's hip, Diana pulled her closer, leaving nothing, not even a trickle of air separating them now.

Faye was so ecstatic with the events, she felt as if everything was happening slowly and she was only observing it outside her body. She now had confirmation that Diana was already under her spell, because that was definitely not Diana's normal self.

Faye felt a pang of regret inside. She was using Diana for her entertainment, for some sex toy. Diana would never forgive her. As soon as this is over, I'll go looking for that memory erasing spell.

But tonight, Faye decided that it wouldn't matter, that this would probably be the first and only chance to enjoy Diana this way. Faye stiffened, deciding of not turning back and enjoy the effects of her spell, running her hands through Diana's hair, pulling her even closer, loving how soft Diana's tongue felt against her own.

Diana's heart was about to explode of excitement at any second now. They kept prolonging and intensifying their kiss, and it seemed like minutes since the girl last breathed.

She was giving herself increasingly to her voracious desire, biting Faye's lower lip, and then passing her tongue onto it, tearing a moan from the girl. The almost guttural sound that came out of Faye's throat caused an increasing heat throughout Diana's body, specifically on a specific lower part. Suddenly, Diana regretted having dressed up at all.

Wanting to get rid of the fabric that separated her skin from Faye's, she put her hands to her back, to unzip the dress, but was stopped by the other girl's hand, who seemed eager to help her.

Faye broke the kiss, gasping for air. She could never imagine to feel such excitement only from a kiss. It's the spell, it's gotta be itshe tried to convince herself, refusing to hear the voice inside her.

Diana could be the woman of her life, her destiny. But no, Faye didn't believe in that crap. After all, she had a bad girl reputation to keep. Even though I would change everything for hershe thought.

Realizing that she already was half naked, Faye decided to make things even, which seemed to be the same thought Diana had. She quickly caressed Diana's back, kissing her neck as she did so "Diana, I want to make you mine", she whispered to Diana, slightly biting her neck by the end of her sentence and pulling the zipper of the dress to its end, playing the skin under her fingers and sliding the dress along Diana's body, until it was completely off. "Tell me you want me, tell me you want this" demanded Faye, stealing one more kiss from Diana.

That whispers in Diana's ear caused a strong tremor in her body. Faye had said that she wanted her. What are you waiting for?Said Diana's mind blind with desire, who was feeling exactly the same.

Already with the dress fallen at her feet, Diana trembled more and more as Faye's hands began to explore her body, drawing endless chills out of her. The words that Faye said then, echoed through her mind until Diana found her own voice and responded after a stolen kiss that took her breath away. "I want you… I've always wanted you, Faye."

"Good. 'Cause tonight I'm gonna make you mine" Faye whispered as she ran a finger along Diana's face, which in return closed her eyes. "My god, Diana. You've never been prettier…" Faye memorized Diana's features, never wanting to forget this moment.

Diana's eyes slowly opened with Faye's comment, her intense gaze, showing how much she craved Faye.

Whatever had possessed Diana that night, it was clouding her judgment. She couldn't think of anything except Faye. She was acting strictly by her feelings and desires. Feelings that she already had for that girl for some time now, and desires that were awakening stronger by each slight touch, stare and kiss Faye was giving her. Diana has never been looked by another person like that before, much less touched in such an intimate way. That new feeling made it all more exciting for her. Luckily her shyness had not given a sign that one day it had ruled her life, though Faye still had the power to slightly intimidate her, making Diana vulnerable towards her. But nothing would make her stop all that. Not when every fiber of her being claimed for what was yet to come.

Faye knew Diana felt extremely vulnerable under her touch and decided to do what she did best: dominate. Faye led Diana to her bed, sitting on top of her, her thighs feeling Diana's warm body beneath her, and she kissed the other girl slowly at first. While stroking her back, Diana's hands went up Faye's naked arms, reaching the back of her neck, until it totally disappeared through her dark locks.

Faye took advantage of her position to slightly push her body against Diana's, their breasts fully touching, Diana's nipples hardening at the contact, as well as Faye's. She didn't even try to resist the urge to trace kisses all the way from Diana's mouth till her breasts, licking, sucking and lightly nibbling on them.

When Faye left her lips to kiss her neck, all Diana could think was go lower, lower… and it was like Faye was hearing her thoughts, making her hidden wishes come true right away. Diana has never been more aroused in her whole life. She held the other girl's head against her chest, and couldn't hold moans from escaping her lips, even though she was strongly biting them.

Faye moved back and forth between both breasts, not before brushing them with her teeth and pinching the other nipple with her free hand, accepting Diana's whimpers and hair pulling, as a signal to continue.

Faye as usual acted according to her impulsivity — which today, more than ever — was over the roof. The way Diana pulled her hair immediately increased her — already heavy — breathing and heartbeats. Faye decided to lie in bed completely, still on her position of dominance over Diana, intertwining their legs.

Diana didn't offered any resistance as her body was being pushed back, leaving Faye to lie above her. The new position let Diana feel the heat between both her and Faye's legs increase. And it seemed like Faye also noticed that.

Faye felt her thighs wet when in direct contact with Diana's "Hmm, feels like a little someone wants this as bad as I do…" Faye couldn't help but tease Diana, even in a moment like this.

Faye's teasing was countered with a "Shut up and kiss me." As Diana's hands still tangled in Faye's hair, pulled her close, to silence the other girl with her own lips.

Faye smiled wickedly, pleased with herself that she could always get on Diana's nerves. "You see, I could think of ways to shut up…" she said, her fingers slowly caressing Diana's thighs, one finger teasing on the waistband of Diana's panties, not quite pulling it down "…I could keep my mouth busy for hours…" Faye then touched Diana's center with her middle finger over her panties, feeling it completely soaked "… Would you want that?"

Faye seemed to have been born with the gift of being naturally provocative. If exciting Diana with her actions wasn't enough, she could also arousal her with what she was saying. Diana didn't know you could get so aroused with a few words spoken. Of course, Faye's fingers touching her in places never explored before was helping her achieve that level of pleasure that she thought wasn't possible to achieve with only foreplay. Diana swallowed hard, biting her lower lip, when Faye proposed another way to keep her mouth busy. "I wouldn't want anything more…" she was able to answer in a husky and low voice.

"So I guess it's your lucky day" or mineFaye said in a teasing tone, giving one last kiss on Diana's lips, before travelling south to explore that beautiful body beneath her, leaving a trail of kisses along the way, until she reached the limit between Diana's silk skin and the only tiny piece of clothing she still had on — Diana's sexy black lace panties.

Pulling her panties with her teeth and a little help of one of her hands, Faye stripped Diana completely, moistening her lips when she got a full view of Diana's body. Faye now took the opposite route, kissing her way back up starting with Diana's ankles, to her inner thighs, always keeping eye contact with Diana, pleasure written all over her face. Faye started teasing, leaving feather light kisses all over Diana's thighs, waiting for the girl to beg her to continue.

The excitement no longer fit within Diana, as Faye took her panties off with her teeth and began to explore her whole body with kisses. As Faye was approaching her sex, looking at her with green eyes glowing dark with desire, Diana writhed with that little torture the other girl was putting her to.

Faye wanted to please Diana more than anything, even if she didn't know quite yet if she could do that, despite all her confidence, she had never done it before. She knew what pleased her though. In fact, she had learned what pleased her thinking about Diana, many, many times.

And then here she was, facing Diana's hot and wet sex. She felt her mouth watering with that beautiful view. She wanted to taste Diana so bad.

Without hesitation, Diana leaned forward, taking Faye's face in her hands, encouraging the girl to go a little higher "Faye, please …" she said slightly breathless. She couldn't wait any longer.

Hearing Diana's pleas was all Faye needed to gain some confidence. Slowly, Faye stuck her tongue out and temptatively started lapping on Diana's center while grabbing her ass in both hands. The first time Faye swallowed Diana's sweetness, she couldn't help moaning herself. How does she even taste this sweet? God, so good…

If Diana was in her normal state, she'd be wondering if Faye had done this before. Her eyes went straight to the back of her head as Faye's tongue came on contact with her throbbing sex, making the air of her lungs escape in one long moan.

Faye eventually opened her eyes to look at Diana's face. Her face was beautiful and showing nothing but pleasure. As if they were sharing the same thoughts, Diana opened her eyes to look at Faye too. They locked their gaze for a while, just until Faye's tongue made Diana roll her eyes again, but this time, she whispered Faye's name, breathlessly "Oh… Faye…!"

Diana's words alarmed Faye and her mouth left Diana's center for a few seconds "Am I hurting you?" Faye left her softer side show again, worried if she was hurting Diana. She had all the indications to think otherwise, but still, considering she had never done this before, it wouldn't hurt to ask.

"What? No!" Diana almost laughed at Faye thinking that. And who would have guessed Faye Chamberlain would show a softer side in a moment like this? She's just so full of surprises. Diana almost went insane with the lack of contact and begged for more. "No… please… Don't stop, Faye. Please…?"

Never. "Sure, baby" Faye spread Diana's legs wider, gaining more access to her center and allowing herself to push her tongue deeper inside Diana, eventually sucking lightly on Diana's clitoris and blowing some air on it, and when she felt Diana's body shaking slightly, she figured she was probably doing the right thing.

Diana arched her back moaning loudly as Faye's tongue entered her. She kept a hand on Faye's hair, slightly brushing and tugging it to encourage the other girl to speed up the pace, as her body started to shake and her arousal became unbearable.

Faye felt Diana starting her own rhythm and followed her hips, pushing her tongue deeper inside Diana, touching her clitoris with her left thumb and massaging Diana's boob with her right hand. She could feel herself getting wetter and wetter, her own thighs burning with desire.

With the new pace, Diana felt her body shivering as her climax was building quickly now. She had done things to herself before, but she had never felt this much pleasure before.

When Faye felt Diana's body shaking, she figured she would probably come, and fast. She knew it would be the perfect time to use a move she used on herself when she needed to come hard and fast. She entered Diana with two fingers, her fingertips quickly finding a softer spot inside Diana. She massaged the spot, her tongue never leaving Diana's clitoris.

They must have been sharing their minds, because when Diana wanted to feel more of Faye, the other girl decided to just that.

The feeling was so overwhelming that Diana was off the edge in two seconds, digging her nails in Faye's shoulders, arching her back once again, screaming Faye's name, as another word come out of her mouth too "Oh, Faye… Fuck..!" She wasn't the type of girl who cursed, but she wasn't feeling like her usual self right now.

The noises Diana was making marveled Faye for a moment. She never thought of her to be a loud girl in bed, much less to talk dirty too. She appreciated the dirty talking, which worked perfectly to help her reach an orgasm herself.

Once Faye felt Diana collapsing and screaming her name, she was about to explode. Arching her body, she drove her free hand inside her own sex, touching herself with two fingers. She was so wet she could barely feel her walls around her fingers.
As Faye rode Diana and herself to a mind blowing orgasm, she moaned loudly against Diana's clitoris, her deep voice breaking "Hmm, Diana… Fuck…"

Diana didn't think it was possible to feel such an intense ecstasy, but when Faye started coming seconds after her, she felt like she was dying, but in a good way.

That's when she realized something odd started happening around them. A bright explosion of colors come out of nowhere during their climax. They probably wouldn't notice it, since they were looking at each other coming. In fact, she was pretty sure Faye hadn't.

That was the best feeling Diana had ever experienced. They did not just made love, but also made magic together.
Diana was overwhelmed and exhausted. Her limbs were heavy, and she was felt a bit dizzy too. If Faye wasn't holding her firmly, she might have fallen onto the mattress and slept for days.

Faye herself felt like she had just run a marathon, and won. With deep breaths, she removed her fingers from inside Diana, licking them clean and enjoying once again her sweet taste.

Lifting herself on the bed, she decided to stay in a sitting position, pulling Diana closer to her, intertwining their legs together, Faye's dripping wet sex touching Diana's.
Just because she was tired, doesn't mean she was going to stop already. In fact, stopping was not an option for Faye tonight. She wanted to feel all these amazing feelings for as long as she could.

"That" Faye kissed Diana hard on the lips "Was… so… Good." she whispering between kisses. Faye could feel Diana was almost worn out, but she was setting the rules tonight, and she could probably figure out a way or two to keep Diana interested "Ready for some more?" she stated firmly, locking their thighs together with a wet sound.

Even though Diana felt like sleeping, Faye's lips began to wake her not her yet-fully-satisfied-desires, and when Faye suggest another round, there was no way she would deny it. Their hot sexes were touching, her taste still fresh on Faye's lips made a flow of arousal rush into her veins again. The girl bit the bottom of Faye's lips before teasingly replying "What you got left to show me?"

"Left? What makes you not think that I'm just starting?" Faye sounded offended even. She might not be a pro, but she still had several cards up her sleeve, mostly learned from very educational movies, but oh how she planned on using all of them tonight. Faye tightened her legs grip around Diana's lower back and made their wet clits touch again. Bitting her lip, she started a low pace, waiting for Diana to fully come to her senses again so she could enjoy this as much as she was.

"I'm just asking, that's all…" Diana replied with her voice going down by the end, as her body suddenly trembled again, with Faye pushing her hips further against hers. The move made a jolt run down her spine and she grip onto Faye's shoulders hard so she wouldn't fall. As the other girl started creating a slow rhythm, Diana moaned throwing her head back and started to follow the pace.

Diana throwing her head back was the perfect invitation for Faye to devour the girl's neck, kissing and licking her, and finally marking Diana as her own by the end of it.

Diana held Faye's head against her, and hissed while the girl was leaving a hickey on the soft flesh of her neck.

Leaving a big purple mark on the right side of Diana's neck, Faye smiled, pleased "See. Told you I'd make you mine." she emphasized the 'mine' part by thrusting one more time against Diana, fastening their pace. She was in love with how lovely Diana sounded when she came, and right now she was working really hard to hear it again as soon as possible.

Diana had to giggle at Faye's statement. It was classic Faye. The Faye she was falling for. "I was already yours… Didn't you know?" she added in between moans. Faye fastening the pace was already making Diana feel closer to the edge of another crushing orgasm.

Faye's heart melted at Diana statement, and for a second she even forgot she had the girl on a seduction spell. It felt so good to hear that. She'd finally get to have something of her own, someone who'd love her back "I want you to be mine, forever…" Faye said, running her hands through Diana's hair.

Faye wanted Diana forever. The other girl's statement echoed in Diana's mind. She didn't know it before, but now she knew that she secretly wanted the same thing.

Diana held Faye's head close to her as she repeated in a whisper on Faye's ear "I'm already yours…" and she kept saying it like a mantra while both were getting closer to their climax.

Breathing in Diana's hair and neck, and taking in her scent, Faye added "Hm, you smell so good… And you taste so good, too, Di…"

She felt her nipples rock hard against Diana's and her whole body trembling "Fuck, Diana… We barely touch and I'm already on the edge."

Touching their foreheads, Faye stared deeply into Diana's eyes, admiring the girl's lovely look, and she thought that that was undoubtedly the most beautiful thing she's ever seen. She was causing it, they were doing it together. It felt like magic, only better.

As Faye's was admiring Diana, Diana was doing exactly the same. Every little aspect of Faye was incredibly beautiful. Diana always saw Faye as the most beautiful girl in town, but now she was really seeing her. She got lost inside Faye's greenish eyes as they locked their gaze. She'd always loved that pair of eyes, and also her little dark spot under her nose. Diana leaned in and planted a kiss there and then kissed her way down to Faye's full lips.

They ended the kiss to stare at each other once again. Suddenly, all the energy that was once slowly building up hit Faye's body all at once, she started trembling. "Hmmm, Diana, come with me, baby…" Faye begged, moaning loudly and grabbing Diana's hands, intertwining their fingers. She wanted every inch of her skin touching Diana's.

As soon as Faye begged Diana to come with her, it only took another thrust of hips and the wave of another crushing orgasm started to wash over them, making both cry out loud each other names into the night.

When Faye felt Diana coming with her, she tried her best to keep her eyes open and analyze once again how gorgeous Diana looked while coming. Instead, something else caught her attention. A set of candles next to Diana's Book of Shadows. She blinked her eyes several times to make sure she wasn't just hallucinating from her recent activities, but it seemed pretty real. The flames in the 7 candles had turned colors and were rising twice as big as they normally would be, now colored with all the colors of the rainbow. "Diana…" Faye tried to catch her breath "Do you see that too?" Faye pointed to the candles.

Diana felt her body exploding in a wave of pleasure, and surrendered to the feeling by shutting her eyes, as she rocked her hips a few more times against Faye's. But she was suddenly been pulled away from all that when Faye called her name asking about something over her shoulders. Diana had seen early bright lights circling them while they were first coming together. This has got to be collateral effect of witch sex.

"What..? Oh… I… I think we're unconsciously… making magic together…" Diana answered trying to form a sentence when she wasn't quite able to think straight.

"We are? Wicked!" Faye laughed, throwing her hair back "I didn't even know it was possible. It looks pretty" Faye said, contemplating the bright flames, now returning to their natural color "Not even remotely as pretty as the witch in front of me, though" Faye kissed Diana once more "Still, it's not fair. Just when I was getting there, some silly candles distracted me" Faye pouted, putting her cute face on "Now, what are we gonna do about that?" Faye caressed Diana's boob, loving the feeling of how soft her flesh was.

So Diana leaned in capturing Faye's bottom lip in her own, letting it go with a pop sound and purred inches from the other girl's face "How about making more magic together…?" she suggested with the word 'together' trailing off with a double meaning. Diana kissed Faye hard this time, her tongue hungrily invading the other girl's mouth, as she was pushing Faye to lie with her back on the mattress.

After Faye was lied down, Diana reversed their position, now facing the girl's feet. Before making any move, she looked back at Faye over her shoulder, with a lusty expression on her face. She couldn't wait any longer, she had to taste Faye too. So she grabbed her thighs and started kissing a path of wet kisses from her knees to her dripping sex.

"That's my girl" Faye smiled lecherously, first looking surprised at how quickly Diana took charge of things, but then she remembered it had to be the spell. She felt her own sex drip with the feeling of Diana's mouth so close to where she want it.

The position they were in was so hot and so intimate… She quickly grabbed Diana's thighs, pulling her closer. This is gonna be interesting. Faye smiled inside, the anticipation making tiny butterflies fly all over her stomach. She was facing Diana's shaved, quivering sex once again, and even though her mouth had just been there a few minutes ago, she already missed it, her mouth watering at the thought of tasting Diana again.

As soon as Faye grabbed Diana's thighs and kissed her folds, Diana did just the same, and then temptatively tasted Faye for the first time. She moaned when the sweet taste of Faye hit her tongue. Those lips were just as sweet as the ones she started loving to kiss.
Diana then started lapping at Faye's sex, teasing her clit, going all the way inside her, repeating it and creating a slow pace.

Once Diana's hot tongue entered her, Faye knew she would never feel anything as good as this. The movements Diana did were reflecting her personality. It was calm but determined, strong, yet gentle. Faye was in a position she was not used to be, but she wouldn't complain: she was at Diana's mercy and she loved it.

In order to give Diana better access, Faye lifted her hips, adding a pillow bellow her so Diana wouldn't have to struggle anymore. As if saying 'thank you', she felt Diana squeezing her butt a little tighter and licking her in a faster pace.

After just enjoying the wave of sensations Diana was causing all over her body, Faye started lapping on Diana's hot sex, spreading Diana's butt cheeks, her face buried inside, her tongue making immediate contact with Diana's swollen clit.

That made Diana's body quiver with the sensation, making the girl slightly dig her nails into the other girl's buttocks. Responding to Faye's ministrations, Diana began to suck on Faye's clit, causing the other girl to moan inside her, initiating a chain reaction as she began to moan too.

Even though time was not a concern for Faye tonight, she knew they had been doing this for a long time. She was feeling her jaw numb from sucking and licking Diana, but hell she didn't want to stop. Enjoying every second of this and every drop of Diana's sweetness, Faye continued licking and teasing Diana's clit, her red nails scratching Diana's back and buttocks, leaving red marks all over them. Diana's back already felt hot under her touch, revealing that there was probably not much of skin that Faye hadn't scratched.

She then placed one hand near Diana's sex, her thumb lightly touching Diana's clit at first, but soon she was entering Diana with two fingers, earning her the loudest moan of the night, and making it the hottest one as well, 'cause Diana moaned right in front of her sex, her voice vibrating on it and sending waves of pleasure through her whole body.

Diana felt like she wasn't going to last any longer. So she decided to speed up things for Faye as well, mimicking her, entering her with two fingers. Diana kept sucking on Faye's clit as thrusting her fingers deeper inside, finally hitting the right spot sending shivers all over the other girl. Her walls clutched around Diana's fingers just in time when she was feeling on the edge once again.

Faye was massaging Diana's g-spot with circling movements, the walls of her pussy gripped tight against Faye's fingers, as if asking Faye to never remove her hand. Faye started fucking Diana in and out while still sucking her clit, her moans becoming louder and louder, but when she opened her eyes, something startled her.

They could see the first glimpse of dawn starting to appear through Diana's bedroom window. Shit, the spell. It's probably gonna be over soon. Faye cringed at the thought. She didn't want this to end, but it had to. Not only that, she needed to also erase Diana's memory, according to her previous plan. This is wrong, so wrong. Her thoughts were interrupted by Diana's finger thrusting her in and out. But this is good, so good.

As Faye was making Diana come, ripping the air of her lungs, she cried the girl's name asking for Faye to join her. "Faye… Come with me…" And by saying that, Diana thrust deeper into Faye hitting her g-spot in no time.

Faye knew she was about to come even before Diana's words hit her, all worries leaving her mind for a few seconds, except for the intriguing thought of how on Earth had she lasted this long. She felt proud of her self-control, because before tonight just the thought of Diana doing half of the things she was doing would be enough to make her cream her jeans.

Faye fucked Diana harder now, sliding in and out of her with more force, leaning forward and sucking on Diana's clit, feeling Diana's fingers working frantically on her sex as well as a powerful orgasm hit both girls at the same time. Between the deep cries of pleasure they felt their trembling bodies so light, as if they were… levitating?

Diana couldn't believe when she opened her eyes and saw the bed at an odd distance below them. "Oh… Faye…Can you… Can you see…? We're… Oh…" it was all she managed to say in a rasped voice, while her mind began to fade as she reached the highest pitch of her orgasm.

Feeling no longer the bed below her, Faye opened her eyes to see Diana's room from a different view. A 5-feet-above-the-bed view. She felt like she had no control under this spell, but it sure felt amazing, making this one definitely THEorgasm to remember.

As the climax finally wore off, breathlessly, Faye tried answering Diana, holding tightly against her like a child would hold her safety blankie. "God, Diana… We're so hot, gravitation couldn't handle us."

Diana was breathing so heavy, that her body hurt. After that mind blowing orgasm, they slowly got back in bed, softly hitting the mattress like feather. They stood still for a few minutes, as both were catching their breaths, clutching each other, not wanting to let go like they might disappear if they move ever so little.

Diana looked over her shoulders to Faye, wanting to be closer to her now. So she placed herself behind Faye, spooning her, her head resting on the girl's shoulder, and she could swear they were glowing.

She ran a hand through Faye's hair, her forehead was sweaty and her hair was messy, but beautiful regardless. Leaving light kisses on her shoulders, Diana softly placed Faye's hand and hers above the other girl's heart. She could feel her heartbeats so incredibly fast, just like her own, and whispered "Thank you for everything. Thanks for making me feel so special and loved. I'll never forget this." The words came out of her mouth in a weak, breathless tone, as a single tear fell from her left eye.

Diana's words hurt Faye worst then a million knifes through her chest. She had to make Diana forget. Otherwise Diana would never forgive her, she knew it. The whole thing had gone way too far and Faye would put an end to it tonight, all these amazing feelings would stay buried with this wonderful night and Faye would have to live with just that. "Please don't thank me…" Faye said weakly, her voice breaking, tears starting to form in her eyes. At this point, Faye was pretty sure she was the worst person on Earth. Using her best friend like this… The only decent thing to do would be erase her memory and try to put all of this behind them.

She quickly decided it was time to be strong, try to do the right thing. Getting away from Diana's embrace, she jumped off the bed. "It's cold, maybe we should get dressed." Faye could see Diana looked puzzled and she realized this was only getting harder. "I'll go get our pj's and then I'll warm you up till you beauty sleep." she faked a smile.

Faye felt dirty and evil. If she could, she would probably punch herself in the face right now.
She quickly came back with both their pajamas, wanting Diana to sleep fast before the spell wore off.

Faye was being evasive, Diana could feel it. Did I do something wrong?She asked herself as Faye got away from her to get their clothes. She would've said something to the other girl, ask her if she was okay, but her mind was foggy right now. She was exhausted. Her eyes were so heavy, her limbs were numb, but somehow she managed to get dressed by herself.

As she was dressing up, she couldn't stop looking at Faye quietly dressing. She thought she had seen tears falling down her face that were quickly cleaned away by her hands.

They went back to bed after that, with Faye lying down behind Diana this time, leaving one arm over her waist. Diana got hold of that hand and led it to her lips, kissing it gently, before she held it closer to her heart. "Faye…?" She asked, her voice so low it was barely a whisper.

"Yes?" Faye was tense. She was working on auto mode till Diana fell asleep. She could not show any emotions right now. She just wanted to get this over with and forget it ever happened.

"Are you okay? Did I… Did I do something wrong? I'm sorry if I did, it was my first time, it clearly wasn't yours 'cause you were so good at it, but I promise to be better next time…" Diana panicked for a few seconds.

"Wh-what? No, you didn't do anything wrong, Di. Anything at all…" Faye's words trailed. She kissed Diana's cheek one last time, closing her eyes for a long time, trying to stop the tears from falling. If Diana had said anything, it was lost during her concentration, since she could now hear Diana's low snores. The girl had to be pretty tired for falling asleep so quickly.

Faye started to remove herself from Diana's embrace, letting go of her hand, not without whispering, loud enough for only her to hear "Yes, Diana, you were my first too."

With her final words, Faye left the bed, grabbing the Book of Shadows that was resting on Diana's study desk, knowing exactly what spell to look for. She would have to adjust some words, but it would probably work just fine. It had worked on her mom the last time she tried adjusting the words, anyways. Yes, Faye, 'cause you're not being a jerk enough tonight, you have to compare hiding a broken vase from your mom to erasing your best friend's memory 'cause you used an attraction spell to have sex with her.

Faye hated herself right now. But she knew if she erased her own memory it could get ugly. Sometimes spells had some kinks and she had used magic enough for one night, better not to push her luck. Just one more spell,she thought, her fingers stopping in the right page of the book and the words to the spell coming to her as if someone was whispering in her ear.

Looking directly at Diana, she said barely out loud:

"Gates keepers, hear my cries

I summon thee through space and time

To clean what's done on this darkest night

No memories hers, all memories mine"

Once she finished her last word, she examined Diana's sleeping body. The hickey she had left on the girl's neck a few hours ago slowly disappear, till Diana's skin was normal again, as if nothing had happened. And hopefully the same thing happened on her mind, Faye thought.

She lay in bed beside Diana this time facing the other girl's sleeping face, but keeping her distance. She couldn't touch nor even look at Diana right now, so she closed and tried to sleep — except she couldn't. She was so pissed off at herself. That was such a stupid thing to do. Why couldn't she for once not screw everything up?

Though it seemed like her mind wouldn't let her sleep anytime soon, she was exhausted not only from all their recent activities, but from this spell that wore her off even more.
So Faye's body simply shut down. She fell asleep with the taste of Diana still fresh on her lips, as she cursed herself regretting ever daring crossing that line.

{END of Part 1}