Disclaimer- I don't own any right to glee… but I'm sure you know that.

A/N: This is a new glee story… Quinn is at Yale and Puck is still in Lima. They can't stop thinking about one another. When Puck decides to show up on her doorstep what will happen with our high school sweethearts?

Chapter One: You'll be in my Heart

Quinn Fabray brushed her blonde hair out of her face. She was focused intently on the chapter of William Shakespeare's 'A Mid Summers Night's Dream'. Every single time she crossed the name of Puck, the fairy, she couldn't help that her mind drifted back to her time in Lima Heights Ohio.

She looked up at the framed picture on her desk. In the picture were smiling people, they looked like a family. There was a girl with long blonde hair and on her lap sat a baby, who looked to be about two, a boy with a Mohawk had his arms wrapped around the two.

Quinn's fingers traced the edges of the picture gently, "Beth… You look so much like your Daddy" Quinn murmured to herself. She knew Beth was with Shelby, Rachel Berry's mother, but she thought about her every single day; just like she thought about Noah Puckerman.

She lay down on her bed cradling the picture to her chest, "Puck…" She whispered as sobs wracked her small form.

Noah Puckerman was watching his little sister Sara as she slept. He was studying for his test in class tomorrow, but he found he couldn't focus. His mind kept drifting to the beautiful blonde mother of his child.

He was going to the community college in Lima, but he wasn't happy. He was going here for his mom. She was surprised he'd even passed his Senior Year of High School, but he had his secret. Quinn Fabray.

Quinn had kissed him the night before his finals and it was magic. He'd passed his exams and was able to walk across the stage with the rest of his friends. Only one problem, Quinn was nowhere to be found. She'd gone off to Yale. She didn't tell anyone when she was leaving, didn't say goodbye.

He put his head in his hands frustrated. With a swipe of his hand all of his books and papers flew to the floor. Tears formed in his eyes. He had only ever loved Quinn and now she was gone forever.

"Quinn" He whispered the name like a prayer, maybe he was praying for God to bring them back together. "Why did you leave me behind" He muttered putting his head back in his hands to hide his falling tears.

Quinn awoke to the sound of her cell phone ringing on her night stand, "Hello?" She mumbled annoyed.

"Hey Quinn… It's Mercedes… The glee club is having a Reunion next weekend. Can you come?" She sounded excited.

"We've only been gone for two years Cedes" Quinn rolled her eyes.

"Mr. Shue wants to see us before he transfers. He also wanted us all to get together before we got out of college and lost touch" Mercedes explained laughing.

"I'm not sure that's a great idea" Quinn sighed, her mind drifting back to Puck, again.

"Look… We all want you to come. Kurt and I already had something perfect for all three of us to wear… please Quinn… come" Mercedes begged.

"Fine… but only for you and Kurt" Quinn forced a laugh before hanging up the phone. She knew this wasn't a good idea. What if she saw Puck again? Then again, when was Puck one to show up to anything?

Puck was lifting weights at the gym when his phone started ringing. He put down the heavy bar and sat up to answer it.

"Hello?" He was out of breath.

"Hey Man, It's Finn" Finn's cheerful voice came over the phone.

"What up?" Puck asked.

"Glee club is having a reunion next weekend. Do you want to come?" Puck could tell Finn was smiling on the other end.

"No" Puck replied ready to hang up.

"Wait! This might be the last time we see Mr. Shue" Finn argued.

"I see Mr. Shue all the time… Have fun though" Puck grumbled and clicked the phone shut. He no longer had the energy to work out. He stood and went to get his gym bag before walking out into the hot summer sun.

He couldn't take Quinn off of his mind. He pulled a small folded piece of paper from his pocket. He unfolded it for the umpteenth and looking down at the picture of Quinn, Beth and himself. He missed them both so much that it hurt.

"You look so much like your Mommy" Puck spoke to the picture of Beth as if she were there, "I need to see her… one last time" He murmured.

The Reunion came and went and sure enough Puck hadn't shown. Quinn had a great time reconnecting with the friends she hadn't really kept in touch with. She remembered her goodbye to all of them, all except Puck. She couldn't say goodbye to him, it hurt too much.

Quinn was on a plane back to Connecticut. She couldn't wait to be in her warm apartment alone. She loved her friends, but the memories that came with them were too overbearing.

Quinn dragged her small suitcase up three flights of stairs due to the broken elevator. She was panting when she got to her room. She searched through purse for her keys and opened the door easily. She settled in and threw her pajamas in and popped in a romantic comedy.

The movie was halfway over when there was a knock at the door. She opened it and a guy was standing holding a bag in front of his face.

"Um… Hello?" Quinn's soft voice questioned.

"Ice cream delivery" The guy replied.

"Ice cream doesn't deliver… I wish it did… but it doesn't" Quinn was about to slam the door shut in his face when he lowered the back and Puck was staring back at her.

So what do you think? Loving it? Hating it? Should I continue? Review and let me know! I really appreciate it :D