This is a songfic about Thalia and Luke….. her feelings for him while she's listening to The One That Got Away by Katy Perry.

Summer After High school... When we first met

We met on the road though…

We Make Out in Your Mustang to Radiohead

We made out in the forest…

And On My Eighteenth Birthday We Got Matching Tattoos

I never had an eighteenth but we did get matching tattoos… of love… on our hearts.

Used To Steal Your Parents Liquor and Climb On The Roof

Talk About Our Future Like We Had a Clue

Never Planned That One Day, I'd Be Losing You

A single tear ran down my cheek as I remembered all those times we spent together… Talking about our future…. who knew he would just turn against us like that? Leave me? Annabeth?

In Another Life

I Would Be Your Girl

Yes I would. No matter what they say.

We'd Keep Our Promises…..Be Us Against The World

My heart broke as I heard this line… It'll be just like we planned, Luke… Be us against the world.

In Another Life

I Would Make You Stay

Yes I would

So I Don't Have To Say

You Were The One That Got Away

The One That Got Away

I cried and hugged myself… I would make him stay so that I don't have to say that he was the one that got away…

I Was June And You Were My Johnny Cash

Never One Without Another We Made A Pact

Never one without another, Thals. Promise?

Sometimes When I Miss You I Put Those Record On

More tears splashed on her worn-out jeans.

Someone Said You Had Your Tattoos Removed

You did. You never even once thought of me, when you gave yourself over to Kronos, did you Luke?

Saw You Downtown Singing The Blues

That's actually me

It's Time To Face The Music…. I'm No Longer Your Muse

Can't believe you were such a hypocrite.

(A/N: I'm skipping the chorus)

All This Money Can't Buy Me A Time Machine (Noooooo)

All this power can't by me a time machine.

Can't Replace You With A Million Rings (Nooooo)

I Should've Told You What You Meant To Me

Yes I Should've… Gods, I wish I had.

'Cause Now I Pay The Price

I do… Suffering with heartache.

In Another Life

I Would Be Your Girl

I hope so, Luke.

We'd Keep Our Promises… Be Us Against The World

Be us against this goddamn world.

In Another Life

I Would Make You Stay

Never let you go in the first place/

So I Don't Have To Say

You Were The One That Got Away

The One That Got Away

I love you Luke… My Being A Huntress Won't Change This.