In this story, it's set during the third season. Artie and Brittany still broke up the same way, but Brittany confessed to Santana. Santana feels the same way but doesn't vocalize it and tell Brittany she can't. She is terrified of how her family will take it, she has a little sister and a big brother and she also still has the same fears as in the school. Her, Puck and Quinn have been friends since Kindergarten and only Quinn knows how she feels about Brittany, but does not. Santana has slept with almost all the jocks and Brittany still had her kissing tally mark going. Their friendship is on an edge. They still had their flings like in the show. A new girl comes in and gives Brittany what she is searching from Santana, love and attention. It does have Brittany and the original character for a bit, but Brittana is the ENDGAME. Promise. Anyway enjoy I hope you like it, and I have a small feeling that you'll get mad at me, cause I'm pretty sure I'll get mad at me for writing some of this. Please review and tell me what you think and give me some of your ideas, I'll update as much and as soon as I can I have other stories I'm writing also.
"Ladies and gentlemen, this is our new student, would you please introduce yourself?" Mr. Schue said as if he was introducing a new Broadway star, Santana rolled her eyes and looked at the new student. Her summer has been horrible since her and Brittany had a fight about being together, she glanced over to Brittany was staring at the new girl hard.
"Hi, I'm Kylie Veel, I play guitar, sing, dance and I'm in gymnastics," Kylie said politely, some of the guys start gossiping and whispering about the girl. Santana just rolled her eyes while they talk about her expected flexibility skills. Brittany was mesmerized by the girl. She had long black hair and bright hazel eyes that seemed to brighten the room, and the girls voice was so smooth. Brittany looked over to Santana whom was staring at her. Santana blushed hard and looked away quickly; Brittany internally smiled and turned when she heard a voice to her left.
"Hi, mind if I sit here?" Brittany looked up to see Kylie there with a smile, Brittany blushed and smiled back.
"Uh n-no no of course not you can sit anywhere," Brittany stuttered, when did she stutter? She only did that with Santana. Santana was watching the exchange and felt her heart shoot with unbearable pain, Santana looked away and zoned out.
Brittany looked over to Santana and saw her just staring at Spanish book with a blank expression, Brittany frowned, then suddenly felt a foot brush her leg. Brittany jumped and looked over to Kylie.
"Sorry, I was crossing my legs," Kylie whispered.
"It's fine," Brittany replied, she felt her leg tingle from the touch.
"Santana!" Mr. Schue called for the fifth time. Santana jumped and looked up to him.
"What?" Santana asked, not knowing what she was doing.
"Are you okay?" Mr. Schue asked concerned and annoyed.
"Just not feeling to great," Santana murmured.
"Well can you tell me what 'excuse me' is in Spanish please," Mr. Schue asked. Santana looked at him and was about to answer when she noticed Kylie's leg brush against Brittany's leg again and saw Brittany smile slightly.
"I- I don't remember, can I go to the nurses please?" Santana rushed out, the pain in her heart was killing her and she could feel the tears in her eyes forming.
"How can you not know? You're like fluent in it," Finn questioned from his seat, Quinn slapped him in the arm.
"Finn enough! Yes Santana you may," Mr. Schue said, Santana quickly grabbed her stuff and ran out the room, Brittany watched worriedly, Santana rarely got sick and when she did she wouldn't ever talk about it, normally she and Quinn had to force her to stay in bed.
"Can I go and make sure she gets there okay? I'll be back," Quinn asks from her seat, Mr. Schue sighed and nodded, Quinn got out of her seat and gave Brittany a look before leaving.
"Wow, does she have something against you or something?" Kylie whispered in Brittany's ear.
"Huh? Oh no she doesn't, she's actually one of my best friends," Brittany replied, Kylie gave her a shocked look and then went back to paying attention to the lesson. Brittany, however, spent the rest of the time worrying about Santana.
Santana ran into the girl's locker room and saw some cheerios ditching in there.
"Out," Santana growled, scared the girls ran out. As soon as Santana heard the door shut she fell back against her locker with a thud and sank to her knees sobbing uncontrollably. Outside the door Quinn saw the two Cheerios run out, when Quinn made it to the door she heard the loud thud and quickly ran in to see Santana crying on the ground into her hands.
"San," Quinn whispered, Santana looked up hoping to see Brittany, but in the end, Brittany didn't follow her. Quinn didn't need to ask what was wrong, or if she's okay. She also saw the exchange between Brittany and Kylie and fumed over it. Quinn squatted down and held Santana closely and sobs racked though her body.
T.T
After class Santana was at her locker and Brittany ran up to her.
"Hey San, you okay?" Brittany asked. Santana pulled herself out of the locker; she looked as if she hadn't been crying for thirty minutes, but Brittany could still see sadness in her eyes.
"Fine Brittany," Santana replied as friendly as she could. They stood awkwardly staring at each other and Brittany hated it. She wished they could go back to being able to talk to one another easily. Santana hated it also, she wish she could just forget everything and grab Brittany's pinky with her own and walk to class with her, smiles on both of their faces.
"Santana I still love you, I still want to be with you," Brittany whispered. Santana self-consciously looked around and sighed sadly. Her next words killed her inside.
"I know, but I can't I-I don't like you like that Brittany, please just forget about me okay? Find someone else who can love you back the way you deserve," Santana said emotionless. Santana walked away on the verge of crying again. Brittany stood there her eyes glazed over with tears. She turned and saw Kylie standing there wide eyed.
"Oh um," Brittany stuttered trying to find words.
"It's okay Brittany I get it, no worries," Kylie said smiling, "I myself am gay," Kylie said.
"But I'm not gay, I'm just," Brittany struggled with her words.
"Bi?" Kylie asked, Brittany nodded, "Well cool, but um I need to get to my locker," Kylie said pointing to her locker. Strangely hers was right between hers and Santana's. Brittany stepped to the side and allowed Kylie access.
"You should join Glee," Brittany blurted, Kylie looked at her with a smile.
"That's that club that does show choir things right?" Kylie asked.
"Yup, you'll have so much fun since you like guitar and singing and stuff," Brittany said.
"Well, sure but only if you do something for me," Kylie said.
"Okay," Brittany replied.
"I'll audition and make it in, if you go out on a date with me this Friday at this restaurant I saw called Breadstix," Kylie smirked. Brittany was taken aback by the words. Should she, she still had feelings for Santana, but Santana said to be with someone else. Kylie made her feel how Santana used to, wanted. Brittany made up her mind and nodded.
"Yes I will," Brittany said, Kylie grinned.
"Okay, see you at Glee," Kylie winked and walked away.
"Yeah," Brittany breathed. Quinn was watching from afar and shook her head. Why did Santana have to be so stupid and lie?
D:
At Glee club everyone was talking and gossiping about the new girl who came, while Santana just rolled her eyes and leaned back in her seat.
"Hey you okay?" Puck asked, Santana looked at him and nodded. She was shocked when she saw Brittany coming in with Kylie holding hands and Mr. Schue following behind them.
"Alright guys, this is Kylie and she's going to audition for Glee," Mr. Schue said and sat down. Brittany smiled at Kylie and went to sit next to Artie.
"Um I'm going to sing 'If I Had You' by Adam Lambert," she said. Everyone shifted in their seats slightly excited. The band started playing the music and Kylie started dancing, and it impressed them all especially Brittany and Mike.
So I got my boots on,
Got the right amount of leather
And I'm doing me up with a black colored liner
And I'm working my strut but I know it don't matter
All we need in this world is some love
There's a thin line 'tween the dark side,
And the light side, baby tonight
It's a struggle, gotta rumble, tryin'a find it
But if I had you,
That would be the only thing I'd ever need
Yeah if I had you,
The money, fame and fortune never could compete
If I had you,
Life would be a party, it'd be ecstasy
Yeah, if I had you
Y-y-y-y-you y-y-y-y-y-you y-y-y-y-y-you
If I had you
From New York to LA getting high, rock and rolling
Get a room trash it up 'til it's ten in the morning
Girls in stripper heels, boys rolling in Maserati's
What they need in this world is some love
There's a thin line 'tween the wild time,
And a flat-line, baby tonight
It's a struggle gotta rumble, tryin'a find it
But if I had you,
That would be the only thing I'd ever need
Yeah if I had you,
The money, fame and fortune never could compete
If I had you,
Life would be a party, it'd be ecstasy
Yeah, if I had you
Y-y-y-y-you y-y-y-y-y-you y-y-y-y-y-you
If I had-
The flashing of the lights
It might feel so good
But I got you stuck on my mind, yeah
The fashion and the stage, it might get me high
But it don't mean a thing tonight
That would be the only thing I'd ever need
Yeah if I had you,
The money, fame and fortune never could compete
If I had you,
Life would be a party it'd be ecstasy
Yeah if I had you
Y-y-y-y-you y-y-y-y-y-you y-y-y-y-y-you
If I had you
That would be the only thing I'd ever need
Yeah if I had you,
The money, fame and fortune never could compete
(Never could compete with you)
If I had you, life would be a party, it'd be ecstasy
(It'd be ecstasy with you)
Yeah if I had you
Y-y-y-y-you y-y-y-y-y-you y-y-y-y-y-you
If I had you.
Everyone cheered and clapped, her voice was amazing and rough, perfect for rock songs. Santana just looked away while Brittany gave her a hug.
"Welcome to Glee club Kylie," Mr. Schue said. The club ran up and greeted Kylie into the club.
"It's nice to meet you guys," Kylie said smiling she noticed Santana in the back sitting down with a scowl on her face.
"Santana, don't be rude introduce yourself," Mr. Schue said, Santana sighed and Brittany felt a slight anger towards her for it.
"I'm Santana," Santana greeted after she got up and walked towards the girl, extending her hand out. Kylie hesitantly took it.
"Nice to meet you," Kylie said softly. Santana gave her a fake sarcastic smile. Brittany gave her a hard glare, knowing that smile that she used on everyone she didn't like.
"Yeah, likewise," Santana said and let go going to go grab her stuff when she heard Kylie say something that made her blood run cold.
"So since I made it, I'll pick you up at six on Friday for our date?" Kylie said to Brittany, everyone was shocked.
"Damn," Puck mumbled, saddened he didn't get a chance at the new girl.
"Yup," Brittany giggled. Santana felt her heart shatter. Didn't take Brittany long to move on, I wish I could. Santana thought.
"Hey Santana! How about we hook up this weekend?" Puck asked walking up to her, Santana and everyone turned to him by his forwardness. Santana looked at him for a second before answering.
"No," Santana said. Puck was stunned that she turned him down for the first time ever. Breaking up was one thing, but Santana always said yes to hooking up with him, they were each other's go to fucks.
"N-no? But Santana we always-"
"Puck I don't have to fuck you whenever you want okay, you can't just ask me and expect me be fucked every time you want to," Santana growled. Everyone went silent and speechless at Santana's words. Puck quickly closed his mouth and nodded.
"Santana we don't use that language," Mr. Schue slightly scolded.
"Yeah whatever, we're high schoolers, you should expect it," Santana remarked, grabbing her binder and leaving the room.
"She's a rain of sunshine today isn't she?" Sam commented.
"Really, she's like that every day to everyone," Finn says.
"Enough about Santana guys and go home," Mr. Schue sighed pinching the bridge of his nose. Brittany looked to Kylie who was reeling by the drama of the club.
"You'll get used to everyone and he drama, promise," Brittany said, Kylie smiled.
"Yeah, I don't think Santana likes me too much," Kylie replied, Brittany looked at her and silently agreed.
"You think?" Quinn said from the door way, pink hair and everything.
"Quinn?" Brittany said shocked by her appearance here.
"Santana doesn't like you and frankly neither do I," Quinn said walking up to them.
"Okay, understood but why I haven't done anything to you two," Kylie replied crossing her arms, Quinn smirked at the challenging posture.
"Oh you did, you just don't realize it, Brittany you should be careful, if you don't you won't have Santana here to protect you anymore," Quinn said to Brittany. Brittany's eyes widened in fear, Santana has always been there to protect her, why would she stop?
"She doesn't need Santana to protect her, I will," Kylie said stepping in front of Brittany.
"What makes you think you can? You're at the bottom of the food chain here girlie, your new, a music geek, and you joined Glee club, you have no authority at this school to protect Brittany. Santana on the other hand can, she's head cheerleader and has a bitchy side to her that no one wants to mess with. Everyone tight now knows not to mess with Brittany unless they want to write their death sentence, but if they see Santana not there to defend her, she will be tormented. Why do you think she hasn't been slushied yet?" Quinn said crossing her arms and smirked.
"Slushied?" Kylie questioned.
"Oh everyone who's a loser gets one, even Santana did once, but she had a small word with Karofskey and let's just say she hasn't been slushied since, I would be careful if I were you, you're probably on the top of the list right now," Quinn said and started walking away.
"I don't need Santana to protect me," Brittany said suddenly which made Quinn turn.
"Trust me Britt, you do more than you think, but she needs you way more that you need her," and with that Quinn walked out leaving both Brittany and Kylie wondering what Quinn meant.
