I was reading a lot of prompts from the Valentine's Day Exchange that weren't used so I decided to do one by Katie Diaz.

February, 14, 2009

Logan Huntzburger was standing right in front of Henry waiting for his fiancée to quit taking so long so they could go out and celebrate their very first Valentine's Day as an engaged couple. He still couldn't believe that the two of them were engaged, especially after they had spent the last year apart, following Logan's disastrous first proposal after Rory's graduation. Of course Logan now knew that wasn't just Rory fault. He had been an idiot to assume that Rory's no meant Rory did not want to be with him. She wasn't ready to get married yet.

Logan thought about the night he and Rory had gotten together again. It was at the Democratic National Convention in August of 2008. They had spent the whole night hashing out their issues in a hotel room and then engaging in hot make- up sex. It was true what everyone said about make- up sex.

They now lived in a fabulous apartment in one of the most chic neighborhoods in New York. They had both managed to make it look very homey - not like the museum Logan had grown up in. He had moved his online venture to New York, and Rory was now working for a small New York paper. After everything they had been through these past four years it was hard to imagine that they had managed to achieve a level of normalcy and happiness.

Logan was caught up in his thoughts when a familiar slender white hand had tapped him on the shoulder. Logan smiled when he saw Rory looking as breathtaking as ever in bright low cut red dress, heart shape necklace and Valentine's Day earrings. Logan smiled, when he saw the shiny tennis bracelet that he got her on he had given her in Martha's Vineyard three years ago. He put his arms around her and pulled her close placing a soft kiss on the top of her head.

"Hey stranger you looked really deep in thought." Rory observed as she planted a soft, chaste kiss on his lips.

"I was thinking about how glad I 'am to be with you celebrating our first engaged Valentine's Day, and thinking how far we've come since the convention last August."

"Aw I was just thinking the very same thing in the bathroom. And we need to savor our one and only engaged Valentine's Day, since next year will be our first married Valentine's Day."

"Well, it will be our first married Valentine's but also our second, and last, engaged Valentine's. I hope you didn't forget our wedding date."

"How could I when my grandmother reminds me at least twice a day? I swear I understand that she is ecstatic about planning my wedding since she didn't have much of a say in both of my mom's weddings. Plus, we are getting married in Martha's Vineyard just like she suggested, but if I hear one more thing about flowers and bridesmaid dresses I think I'm going to scream," Rory ranted as Logan rubbed her back.

"We could change the venue and have at your towns Gazebo, or elope in Vegas?" Logan suggested. He didn't really care where they were married. Anywhere would be fine as long as it was with his Ace.

Rory shook her head."Nah, I love Stars Hollow but there is not much deep significance with us as a couple in that town."

"Let's not focus on Emily, and focus on tonight. We are going to one of New York's finest French restaurant Jean Georges."

Rory burst into a fit of laughter.

"What's so funny? Is it my irresistible French accent?"

"No it's just you uttered the exact same sentence on our very first Valentine's Day together." Rory smiled as she starts to get a vivid flashback of that very night.

"The Valentine's weekend at Martha's Vineyard? Cause we didn't go to any French restaurants then."

"No silly, I'm talking about the Valentine's Day the year before when we weren't an official couple. I remember being so nervous."

"I remember that night. It really was special, no matter how hard we tried to deny it, given the state of our relationship. You didn't seem nervous that night."

"I was trying to play it cool."

"You didn't seem like it." Logan was surprised. He recalled Rory acting very confident that day.

"Why do you think I dropped my keys on the bed?"

"So you could start our old fun tradition of 'looking for the keys'? A tradition that has caused us to miss for we've come late to many of our reservations since?" Logan smiled.

"Contrary to popular belief I actually did lose my keys. I was scared that if I mentioned that it was Valentine's Day you would think I would have wanted more, and you would have run for the hills.…"

"Well I was scared that you would have gotten the wrong impression by my asking you on Valentine's Day. It's why I was partly relieved and curious when you acted like it was any other dinner when I first asked you out.…" Logan couldn't believe that they had never talked about their feelings to what happenedfrom that day before.

"Don't you remember me telling you I really didn't know it was Valentine's Day till later?"

"Oh I definitely remember." Logan pulled Rory to sit on their white couch. "Rory before we go out tonight tell me how you were feeling that day. I know we really didn't share a lot of feelings back then." Logan said as he pushed a loose strand of Rory's hair behind her ear.

"Well, it was one crazy day," Rory began. She continued to tell Logan the events which happened that day through her perspective, and then Logan told his. They both held hands and smiled as they reminisced about that day.