Hi there –
I've been scouring the fanfiction archives to try and locate this story and I am hoping you all can help. The story is a future klaine story. Kurt and Rachel are in New York and I believe Kurt and Blaine broke up and Kurt left for NY. What I remember of the story is that Rachel convinces Kurt to go to this local bar to see a singer. Kurt doesn't want to go, but Rachel convinces him to stay for just 5 songs and then after 5 songs, he can leave. Obviously, Blaine turns out to be the singer and Kurt desperately wants to leave, but he adheres to his promise to Rachel to stay for 5 songs. I don't remember what 5 songs Blaine sings, but the last songs he sings is "You and I" by Lady Gaga. The song strikes a chord because it's what had happened between them and Blaine even changes some of the lyrics (i.e. 'lipstick' to 'chapstick' and 'cool Ohio guy'). I would be really grateful if anyone can send me a link to that story or even knows what I'm talking about. I can't stop thinking about it and would love to re-read it and mark it as a favorite. Thanks so much!