The Wrong 'Fitz'

Chapter One

Summary: After Aria and Wesley deliberate about why Maggie lied to Ezra about Malcolm, they start to grow closer to each other, consequently causing Aria and Ezra to grow apart.

Disclaimer: I don't own Pretty Little Liars. (This is the first PLL story including Wesley as part of the couple.)

"Do you really think that your mom is paying Maggie to keep quiet about Malcolm?" Aria asked in an urgent whisper as the water from the shower turned off.

"It sounds like something my mom might do. But there is only one way to know for sure." Wesley whispered back.

"That would be to ask your mom about it. Would she actually tell you the truth?" Aria asked.

"She might, she might not." Wesley replied.

"What are you two whispering about?" Ezra asked as he walked out of the bathroom.

"We're talking about your birthday present." Aria said smoothly, sparing a small glance at Wesley.

"O… kay." Ezra said slowly, looking between his girlfriend and his brother.

"Really bro, you shouldn't be so suspicious; it's your birthday; the first one where Aria and I actually get to work together to make it a great day for you. Let us do our thing while you relax." Wesley commented.

"That's exactly why I'm suspicious Wes. It concerns me that you and Aria are close enough to work together on my birthday after having just met a couple days ago." Ezra said.

"Why don't you open your presents while we have dessert?" Aria suggested.

"That is a great idea." Ezra said with a small smile.

As Ezra grabbed Wesley's present, and Aria started to cut the cake, Wesley stood there looking between his older brother and the beautiful girl in front of him. He could see why Ezra was attracted to Aria, hell, he was attracted to her; but there was something that seemed off about them. They seemed to avoid showing too much affection towards each other, and Wesley couldn't figure out if that had something to do with him, or if the whole thing with Maggie was causing Aria to be distant with Ezra.

"God damn it." Aria yelped as she drew her hand away from the piece of cake that she had just placed on a plate.

"Are you okay?" Wesley asked as he took two steps so that he was next to her.

"I just cut my finger." Aria said as she looked up at him.

"Run it under some water." Ezra said from the couch.

Wesley rolled his eyes at his brother; here was Aria, Ezra's much younger and very beautiful girlfriend, who had just cut her finger, and Ezra sat on the couch and did nothing to help or even show any concern about Aria's well being.

"Here, let me help." Wesley said softly as he held Aria's hand gently while walking her over to the sink.

As Wesley reached around Aria's small frame to turn on the water, and then gently placed her hand under the faucet, Aria leaned back against his chest. Instinct took over Wesley's body as he slowly moved some of Aria's hair behind her shoulder and lightly kissed her neck. It was like neither of them cared that Ezra was still in the room. Aria reveled in the fact that her body seemed to fit better with Wesley's body than with Ezra's.

"Eh hm." Ezra cleared his throat causing both Aria and Wesley to freeze and then turn around slowly to face him.

"Um, thank you Wesley." Aria said politely as she looked between the two brothers.

"Are you okay Aria?" Ezra asked.

"Once I have a band aid, I'm sure I'll be fine." Aria replied.

"I'll go grab one." Ezra said slowly as he eyed his younger brother.

"I can't do this." Wesley whispered once Ezra was out of the room.

"And you think I can. What are we going to do?" Aria asked.

"We need to tell him. Maybe he'll be responsible." Wesley suggested.

"Tell me what Wesley?" Ezra asked.

"Well, um…" Wesley started.

"I met Maggie today." Aria spoke up.

"Excuse me?" Ezra asked.

"I knew that we wouldn't be able to move on if you didn't. So I went to meet her, to see if she's okay." Aria explained.

"Does she know who you are?" Ezra pressed.

"No; she thinks I'm just a petite, brunette coed who is interested in teaching 1st grade." Aria said as she glanced over at Wesley who smirked.

"What would I have to be responsible about?" Ezra inquired as he stared between Wesley and Aria.

"She didn't abort the baby like mom paid her to. She… you… have a 7 year old son named Malcolm." Wesley said as he looked down at the floor.

"Why didn't she say something to me about it when I talked to her?" Ezra asked as he had an overwhelming urge to punch the wall.

"Wesley thinks that your mom might be paying her to keep quite." Aria offered.

"I want both of you to get out." Ezra said, trying to control his anger.

"But…" Wesley started to say.

"Out!" Ezra exclaimed.

"Ezra… seriously, what's wrong? We were trying to figure the best way to go about telling you." Aria said.

"But you still lied to me. Now please, before I do something that I will later regret; just get out." Ezra said as he handed the band aid to Aria, tossed both her and Wesley their stuff and then pushed them both towards the door.

"Ezra…" Aria tried.

"Dude, come one." Wesley protested.

"I want to be alone right now." Ezra said and then closed the door on them, leaving them standing in the hallway, trying to figure out what had just happened.

"Are you hungry?" Wesley asked.

"Yeah, I am." Aria answered as she tried to put the band aid on her finger, but was having difficulties due to her hand shaking too much.

"Allow me." Wesley offered as he took the band aid and placed it over the cut.

"Thank you." Aria said as she looked up at him and noticed just how close they were standing.

"I have a huge urge to kiss you right now." Wesley said as he ran the back of his hand against Aria's cheek to wipe away the tears that she hadn't noticed she was crying.

"Then what are you waiting for?" Aria asked in a small voice.

"Your permission; you are, after all, dating my brother." Wesley reminded her.

"I can't date someone who hides a teenage pregnancy from me. Besides, said brother just kicked us out of his apartment." Aria replied before she pressed her lips against Wesley's.

As the two of them continued to kiss, it soon got heated and Wesley had Aria pushed against the wall. Most of Aria's mind was clouded with passion, but there were parts of her that reminded her that she hadn't broken up with Ezra yet and that he could walk out into the hall at any minute and see his younger brother and his girlfriend making out.

"Wes… we… need… to… go… somewhere… else… Ezra could see us at any minute." Aria said in between kisses before Wesley moved his lips down to her neck and started to suck gently on her crook of her neck and shoulder.

"Let him." Wesley replied simply.

"I'm serious Wes… we need to go somewhere more private." Aria said as she ran her fingers through his hair.

"So am I Aria. I couldn't give a damn if Ez sees us or not. You deserve to be with someone who isn't afraid to be seen making out with you." Wesley said as he pulled away from her body enough to look her in the eyes.

"I haven't broken up with him yet. I would much rather continue this somewhere more private." Aria insisted.

"Do you have a specific place in mind?" Wesley asked.

"My house; my dad is working late, my brother is staying with a friend; and my mom lives above her art studio. My house is empty." Aria said with a small smile.

"Your house it is then." Wesley replied.