A/N: This story is getting completely redone. It's now a character study for Elizabeth, Jack, and Will. Possibly more in the future. Now read and enjoy.
The Bitter Truth
It had to be done. It was the only thing to do.
Why did I do it?
They ask me where he is. I tell them he chose to stay; to do the right thing… for once. I didn't lie. He chose to stay… But then, I really gave him no choice.
Why did I do it?
I can't look into Will's eyes. He knows I lied. I've betrayed one love and killed another. How can I live with myself?
Why did I do it?
I remember Jack's eyes when he found out what I had done. When he realized… I'd sent him to his death. He faced it with calm acceptance, but his eyes held… regret.
Why did I do it?
His last word to me… Nothing could have been more accusatory, or more true.
Pirate.
It seemed so glorious. Now I know the bitter truth. I sent a friend to his death. I deserve to die.
I am a pirate.