Author's Note: I know it's really short, but I'm definitely posting the final part tomorrow, which will be a lot longer.
A few members of New Directions were in a circle formation around Rachel Berry's living room. There was Puck, Quinn, Rachel, Finn, Santana, Brittany, and Kurt, who had no idea why he was even there.
Puck had a plastic bottle in hand, and he eyed the group around him before stating, "Let's play truth or dare."
A few murmurs of 'okays' filled the room, and Puck smirked.
"Alright, let's do it," Puck said, before spinning the bottle. It landed on Finn. The group immediately turned to stare at him. "Truth or dare?"
"...Truth," Finn replied uneasily, scratching his neck.
"Wimp," Santana coughed, which earned a nudge from both Brittany and a glare from Finn.
"Did you really have sex with Rachel?" Puck questioned.
Rachel scrambled to her feet immediately, jabbing a finger at Finn, who avoided eye contact across from her. "You told them we had sex?"
"Uh..." Finn gulped. "I lied, we didn't," he murmured sheepishly. He stole a glance at a fuming Rachel, and quickly stood. "I-I need to pee," he stated, before sprinting off towards the bathroom.
Rachel crossed her arms angrily, and Brittany coaxed the brunette into sitting back down beside her again. Rachel slumped against the blonde, softly laying her head on the blonde's shoulder.
"Well, that was interesting," Kurt added.
The rest nodded, and Puck shrugged. "I kind of already knew he was lying." He spun the bottle again. It landed on Quinn, who was busily reading a novel. "Quinn, truth or dare?"
The reader looked up. "Um... I'll say dare," she replied warily. She frowned when Santana went over to Puck to whisper something in his ear. She was beginning to feel nervous when a huge smirk spread across Puck's face. Everyone stared at the duo in anticipation. Puck clasped his hands together around the bottle as Santana returned to her seat.
"I dare you to do fifteen push-ups," Puck started.
"Um, okay," Quinn looked at him weirdly as she tried to get into position.
"Wait... I'm not done. Do fifteen push-ups with Rachel beneath you."
Rachel's head perked up when she heard her name, and Quinn stared at Puck, before glancing at Santana. "What?
Author's Note: I'll post the second part tomorrow, maybe, depending on the reviews.