Title: Now You Know
Summary: Okay, so this is another story that Nicky's coming out in, because the song that this is based off of really makes me think of Rod and Nicky. If you like it, tell me, and if not … still tell me. Does this song remind you of Rod and Nicky? Coz it does for me. Even though I think this would more fit Rod showing his feelings for Nicky instead of the other way around, but that's not how I'm writing it. We all know how Rod is – he wouldn't do this. So Nicky's getting stuck doing this.
BTW, this story takes place AFTER 2004 – maybe about two weeks after the move came out – because the movie came out in 2004. Alyson and Anna dragged Nicky and Ricky to see it. And I'm gonna be expecting an email about your review, musicalvampire.
Alyson high-fived her sister as they passed each other on the stage steps. "I think we're gonna close with … with this next song because I think we all have to go to work tomorrow since it's only Tuesday night. My boyfriend – soon-to-be ex-boyfriend – for good reason!" she added as people 'awwed' at the announcement. "Uh, he wants to explain this break up in a song. I'm not sure that some of you know it because I don't think you saw 'A Cinderella Story' when it came out, but that's what this song's from. And I swear on my life that he's not singing this to me. It's to a friend of ours … a guy."
The Monster smiled at Nicky as they passed each other, Nicky pulling her into a hug at the last second before going on. "If that wasn't a give away as to why we're calling it off, I don't know what it," the green muppet grinned, nodding at the pianist.
In these eyes
More than words, more than
Anything that I've spoken
When the skies
Turn to grey, my heart's
Just about to crack open
So the story goes
There's somethin' you should know
Before I walk away and I blow the ending
I never wanna be without you
Oh no, here I go, now you know
What I feel about you
There's no endin'
Must've been wrong to doubt you
Oh no, there I go, no control
But I'm fallin' so, now you know
Feel so light
Cravin' oxygen
All this truse leaves me empty
Will you run
Can you handle it
Cuz I need you to tell me
Maybe this seems bold
But I'm hopin' you'll stay for the happy ending
I never wanna be without you
Oh no, here I go, now you know
What I feel about you
There's no endin'
Must've been wrong to doubt you
Oh no, there I go, no control
But I'm fallin so, now you know
No I won't look back when I tell ya what I think about you
No I won't look back when I tell ya what I think about you
So the story goes, yeah
You already know
So don't be a fool and go spoil the ending
I never wanna be without you
Oh no, here I go, now you know
What I feel about you
There's no endin'
Must've been wrong to doubt you
Oh no, there I go, no control
But I'm fallin' so, now you know
I never wanna be without you
Oh no, here I go, now you know
What I feel about you
There's no endin'
Must've been wrong to doubt you
Oh no, there I go, no control
But I'm fallin' so, now you know.
Alyson looked over at her little blue friend, smiling when she saw his mouth hanging open. "Close your mouth, please, Rod. You are not a codfish," the Monster smiled as she passed him again, closing the show for the night before coming back to her seat through the crowd getting up and leaving the restaurant, some of them staying to finish their dinner, the group of them planning to do the same.
"Nicky, I … I never knew. Why didn't you say something before?"
"To be honest, I wasn't all that sure about how I felt. Aly and Anna helped with that. They've been ever so supportive of me this whole time."
"Thank you both," Rod said, smiling and thanking the waitress as she set his order down in front of him. "But that still doesn't explain why Ricky's here."
"Moral support," Ricky replied. "My baby brother asked me to come, make him remember he's not alone in this family."
"Well, then maybe it's a good thing everybody's kept me here," the blue man said. "I'm starved."
A/N: YES, I'm making Ricky and Nicky related – brothers, even – because they look so damn similar. How could they NOT be related? YES, Alyson's a monster. She's married to Trekkie. She and Nicky are friends, which is why she does the 'boyfrined' thing when she's announcing his song. YES, Rod and Ricky aren't dating anymore, but they're still friends.
Oh, and let's just pretend they've found the sheet music to this or something like that, because I've tried to find it some six years after the movie came out and I haven't been able to find it. See if you can.