Jeans
They all sat there grinning after singing the My Chemical Romance number. Even Sue was grinning from ear to ear with her arm around Puck's shoulders. They all started picking themselves up from the edge of the stage when Finn walked over to Rachel. "Hey Rach."
"Hello Finn," she said simply.
"You did good," he said, shoving his hands down into his front pockets.
"Thank you, you didn't do so bad yourself," she complemented.
"I've never seen you wear jeans before." A simple statement from anyone else, but from Finn, it came off as a come-on.
"I'm always tellin' her that," Sam said as he walked up behind her and put his arms around her.
"When have you seen her in jeans?" Finn asked, confused (which wasn't hard to do to be honest).
"I do hang out with other people Finn. Sam and I are friends, and we go do stuff, some of which requires me wearing jeans," Rachel explained.
"What?"
"Dude, we're kinda dating," Sam said before leading Rachel off stage. "You do look hot in those jeans."
"So you say," she said saucily as she sauntered off, wiggling her hips a bit more than necessary. Sam just smirked and thought about how lucky he was to have Rachel freakin' Berry.