Missing Piece of Me (Kaoru x OC)

by InfernityChick

I DO NOT OWN OHSHC! Before Tamaki came along, the twins were friends with a girl, (Y/N). She was the first one to ever win the 'Which one is Hikaru Game'. However, she suddenly had to move to America when they were in middle school. Because of that, the twin's barrier between them and everyone else grew thicker. Now, that barrier is all but gone thanks to the Host Club. But,

1. Chapter 1

If you would rather read an "x reader" version, please go to my Quotev, Wattpad, or Archive of Our Own profiles (InfernityChick). It will be under the same name as this story.

"Let's play the 'Which one is Hikaru?' Game!" Hikaru and Kaoru exclaimed simultaneously, sporting their matching green hats to hide the parts in their hair. All of their female guests squealed, wanting to see if they could be the one to guess which twin was which. One of the girls guessed but got it wrong. Even so, they both played it off and continued to entertain their guests.

About two hours later, the twins were on their way back to their estate in their family's limo. On the way, Kaoru thought of the game they had played that day, and how their guests still weren't able to tell them apart. Even after all they've been through in their lives - and even after joining the host club - it still hurt them, beyond what others could comprehend, that almost no one could tell the very different twin brothers apart. On that thought, Kaoru's mind wandered to the first time anyone ever got that very question right, even before Haruhi came into their lives.