Senior Year
No Ones P.o.v
"You treat her like crap, she deserves better than you hudson" Puck shouts at his ex best friend, who is dating the girl he's in love with and who had became his best friend
"what someone like you? your kidding yourself on if you think your better than me" Finn smirks as he shouts back
"He'd be ten times better for her than you, he'd be better for anyone than you, Rachel deserves someone who loves her for who she is not someone who tries to change her" Sam says from where he, Quinn, Mike and Tina are at the door to the choir room
"Stay out of this Evans, you don't know shit about mine and Rachel's relationship" Finn snaps at the blonde guy
"Yeah but we all do, Sam's right she deserves so much better than you, you messed both of us around, switching between us, I was such an idiot then, but Rachel she doesn't need anyone to change her" Quinn spoke up from where she was standing in shock
"I didn't mess yous around or switch between yous, i was trying to find out who i truly loved and i love Rachel and she loves me, your just jealous" Finn smirked as he answered Quinn
"So what loving Rachel means fucking satan as many times a week you can, yeah?, your an ass hudson" Puck glares at Finn as he saw Santana walking into the Choir room
"Trust me i stopped fucking him as soon as i found out he lied about breaking up with Rachel, and hudson thinks he's in the clear" Santana smirked as she walked in with Brittany, Artie and Mercedes
"What do you mean he thinks he's in the clear?" Tina asked looking at Santana as she stands next to her
"He thinks Rachel doesn't know about me and him, well he's wrong i told her as soon as i stopped it, she's known for a month, a month in which we have been trying to decide how to take hudson down" Smirking at Finn
"Thats not true, she's not like that she would of confronted me straight away if she knew" Finn smirked back at Santana "and what makes you any better Puck you slept with Shelby" Turns back to Puck
"W-what?" Rachel said standing at the door with Kurt and Blaine
Everyone turned to see at the door the tiny diva's eyes were already full of tears..
"Baby, it was a mistake" Noah says as he looks at Rachel,feeling his heartbreak
"Don't call my girlfriend baby, asshole!" Finn shouted at Puck as he glared at him
"Are you kidding me?, your as bad as him, you cheated on me with Santana,who told me about it and didn't lie to me" Rachel looked at him, with tears streaming down her face "The only think you done right is that you didn't promise me that you wouldn't hurt me"
"You promised you'd never hurt her to then break it" Quinn glared at Puck "Have you not learned anything?"
"I know i promised i'd never hurt you baby, it was a mistake and i'm so sorry" Noah said as he began to walk towards her
"Don't you dare come anywhere near me or call me baby!, either of you, we're over for good Finn" Looking at him then back to Puck "I can't believe i thought you were my friend, i hate you" Rachel said before running out the room
"Rach-" Noah sighs as she runs out of the room "Fuck!"
"You two deserve a good slap! Santana your up!" Kurt says before walking out with all the girls apart from Santana to go look for Rachel
"I've finally got permission to slap both of you, my dreams are about to become real" Santana smiles, looking at them
"If your gonna slap us just do it already" Puck sighed as he knew she was going to kill him
"Hold on Puckerman" Santana said before walking over to Finn "Your gonna tell Mr Schue that your quitting glee and that he can't stop you, you'll stay away from all of us and away from Rachel, got it?" Glares at him before slapping him after he nods "Now get out of here hudson!"
"You'll lose without me" Finn mumbled before he walked out rubbing his cheek
Santana walked over and slapped puck,then looks at him "What you did was fucked up, what kind of idiot fucks the girl he's in love with mums"
"It was a mistake, a moment of weakness i was seeing Beth for the first time but fuck Shelby isn't Rachel's mum i mean what kind of mum looks for their daughter to find her and go i don't want her, Shelby replaced Rachel with my daughter, Shelby isn't Rachel's mum!" Puck snapped getting angry at her
"I know that, we all know that but Rachel's been looking for her mum, wanting some sort of relationship with her, she needs closure with Shelby" She sighed looking at him "Look everyone knows she'll forgive you, she always does, thats the only reason i'm not kicking you out of glee but until you get her to forgive you, don't even think of talking to me or any of the girls and kurt til then, you've got the boys you need help with something go to them, got it?"
"Yeah i got it, thanks San" He smiled slightly at her
"Your my friend" Santana shrugged before walking out
With the girls and kurt in the auditorium...
"Hey Rach, you okay?" Kurt asked as he sat down next to her on the stage as everyone finds a spot
"I don't care about breaking up with Finn, that was going to happen soon anyway" She said as she sniffed, looks at Kurt "H-how could Noah do that to me?, he's never broken a promise to me before"
"He's never broken a promise to you ever?" Quinn sighed and wraps her arms around the small diva "Oh sweetie, i'm so sorry"
"I-if Shelby was my dad and had gave me away and adopted Beth, would you of fucked him?" She said through her tears, leaning back into her best friends arms
"No i would never do that to you Rach, i'd never think of sleeping with anyone to see my daughter" Quinn tightened her arms around her
"Then you have nothing to be sorry for" She said wiping a tear away "W-what's wrong with me?"
"What do you mean honey, nothings wrong with you?" Mercedes asked taking her hand from beside her
"Then why does no one want me or love me?, i mean Finn used to switch between me and Quinnie, then he cheats on me but i wasn't really in love with him, i just..." She asked looking at her friends when she got interupted
"You just love him" Santana says as she sits down in front of the stage, smiles softly at her
"Yeah but w-with Noah it's different, he was my first boyfriend, my first kiss, m-my first l-love" Sniffs even more "I gave him my heart and... and he didn't give it back - i always thought he'd be the one that would never hurt me" Rachel said as fresh tears begin to roll down her cheeks
"Oh baby girl, i knew you loved P-Noah and I know he hurt you so much by breaking his promise, i know he did and i know he feels lik a dick right now because he broke your heart and i think we all know that he's going to try this hardest to make it up to you because he loves you too" Santana said as she squeezes her thigh "Rach?"
"Y-yeah" She said looking up at Santana
"Promise me that when you think your ready to talk to him that you'll listen to what he wants to say before you shout or scream at him, yeah?" She says as she looks her in the eyes
"I promise when i'm ready if i'll ever be ready to talk to him i'll listen to him before i shout or scream at him" Rachel giggles wiping her tears