Summary: Fells Church gang meets Mystic Falls gang. Elena and Bonnie aren't the best of friends anymore but when they meet themselves, literally, things change. Different pairings.
A/N: This idea is stolen from Queenkeeta69, so a shout out to her!
Disclaimer- I don't own the Vampire Diaries or any of the characters.
Also, I have another story but I'm not going to post that one up so this one might be a little confusing. Basically, the Fells Church gang fought Klaus and won so he's supposed to be dead but somehow he ended up in Mystic Falls. Also, Bonnie M. was turned because she was dying so in this one she's a vampire. Damon and her were dating but they broke up because she walked in on Damon & Elena mid make-out. As always, reviews are appreciated. So don't forget to review!
xxx
Elena brushed her dark hair out of her face as she looked down at her phone waiting for Bonnie to respond to her text. Bonnie slipped her phone out of her pocket so that she could see the text Elena had sent. They were both worried because neither Jeremy nor Stefan was here.
'Where are they' Elena texted.
Bonnie's fingers flew over the keys, 'Don't know... S said something about someone weird in town'.
Elena huffed reading the text. 'Meet me after school?' Elena texted back.
'The Grill for Coffee?' Bonnie asked.
'Yes' Elena replied.
After school the two girls sat across from each other at the Grill.
"So what do you think is going on?" Elena asked, her eyebrows scrunching together.
"I don't know... but I'm getting this really bad vibe... like something from another world is here." Bonnie whispered so that their conversation wouldn't be overheard.
"Hmmm... Do you think it's Katherine?" Elena asked, worried. The memory of her doppleganger wasn't forgotten.
"No way... She doesn't have that much power" Bonnie almost laughed at the thought. Almost.
Over at the bar a man zoned in on the two teenager's conversation. He smiled, his deep brown eyes shining.
'I will get back to my Elena... one way or another' The guy thought to himself.
"Never seen you here" Another guy with blazing blue eyes and dark hair joined him at the bar.
"New in town" The other smiled back.
"Welcome to Mystic Falls... I'm Damon... the head of the unwelcoming committee."
The other laughed, "I'm Klaus" he responded.
"Odd name" Damon laughed and took his drink to join the two girls he was listening to earlier.
xxx
Elena was in the kitchen of the Boarding House, tapping her nails rapidly against the counter as she waited for her coffee to be ready. The familiar *ding* sounded from the coffee maker and she poured the steaming-hot liquid into a cup.
"Are you planning on drinking that plain?" A voice asked from behind her and she whirled around, coming face to face with Bonnie.
She forced a smile, "No. I'm gunna' put cream in it too... Do you want some?"
"No, thanks." Bonnie grinned back, but her smile didn't quite reach her eyes.
They stared at each other for a few awkward seconds before Bonnie stepped around her and said, "I'm going to make pancakes for everyone."
It was quiet after that. A velvety voice broke the silence minutes later, "Morning."
Bonnie didn't turn, instead keeping her eyes glued to pancake mix she was stirring.
"Morning, Damon." Elena offered.
Damon nodded his head her way but continued staring at the red-head.
"Pancakes, little redbird?" He heard himself saying, "But you don't eat human food anymore."
"It's for the ones who do." Bonnie replied with a touch of hostility.
Elena blew on her coffee, eyeing the two individuals warily. She could feel the tension between them. Ever since Bonnie had walked in on Damon and Elena making out in the Training Room/Basement, nothing had been the same. Of course, Bonnie and Damon had split, and Elena and Stefan had gotten into a huge fight that ended in a break-up. She slowly tip-toed out of the kitchen and into the living room. She didn't want to be in the same room as them knowing it was her fault they were acting like that in the first place. She was turning the corner when she smacked into someone. She squealed, the cup of coffee almost tipping over.
"Whoa." Matt steadied her, "Are you okay?"
"Yeah." She answered, her blue eyes flickering toward the kitchen nervously.
He followed her gaze and shot her an understanding smile when Bonnie's tired voice floated toward them, "Damon, please. I can bake them by myself."
Matt made his way into the kitchen confidently. "Morning, Bonnie."
Elena heard him say and then Bonnie's joyful chirp, "Hey, Matt!" For a second, she sounded like the old Bonnie.
"Those pancakes smell delicious..Need any help?"
"Sure."
Elena sighed in frustration as she sat down on one of the love-seats. Bonnie wasn't being fair to Damon.
"You're up early." Stefan commented. She hadn't even realized he was there.
"Couldn't sleep." Elena shrugged, taking a small sip from her coffee. Stefan smiled but didn't respond. Just then Meredith plopped down beside Elena, rubbing at her eyes.
"I over-slept." She said sleepily.
"It's only 10!" Elena protested with a giggle.
She pushed her coffee into Meredith's hands, "Here. It'll help you wake up." Meredith smiled at her gratefully and took a long drink before handing it back to her.
Then she got up and rushed to the kitchen, saying, "I smell pancakes!"
And just like that, the Boarding House was alive and buzzing with excitement. Sort of.
xxx
"Hey Damon." Elena smiled as he joined them at the table. Bonnie glared at him.
"Well if it isn't the wicked witch" Damon smirked.
"Damon don't" Elena warned.
He smiled, "Fine" he rolled his eyes sitting back in his chair.
"Who was that you were talking to at the bar?" Elena asked looking over at Klaus who was still sitting at the bar.
"His name is Klaus" Damon replied looking over his shoulder to look where Elena was looking.
"Odd name" Elena muttered taking a drink of her coffee.
"That's exactly what I said!" Damon laughed.
Elena rolled her eyes, "You're such a child" She laughed pushing him.
"You know you loooove it" He waggled his eyebrows at her.
"I'm gonna go home" Bonnie spoke up feeling awkward sitting between Damon and Elena flirting.
"Alright bye Bonnie see you Saturday" Elena waved to her friend as she left.
"What's on Saturday?" Damon asked taking a sip from his glass.
"Caroline's Birthday party... You should come" Elena smiled.
"That'd be fun... Is Caroline planning it?" Damon raised an eyebrow.
"Yeah... Bonnie and I were supposed to but you know Caroline had to jump in." Elena laughed tucking a strand of hair behind her ear.
"Well I'll see you Saturday" Damon stood and hugged her before heading back to the bar. Elena stood and left going to find Caroline for more party planning.
xxx
Today was Caroline's birthday. Elena and Bonnie stood in the mirror and helping Caroline curl her hair. Caroline was wearing a white, knee length, strapless dress. It looked perfect on her with her golden hair and tan skin. Bonnie was wearing a red, knee length, halter dress and her hair was straight. Elena was wearing a lavender, knee length, frilly dress and her dark hair was pulled up into a curly ponytail.
"We look amazing" Bonnie laughed as they looked at their reflections in the mirror.
"Let's get ready to break some hearts" Caroline giggled and headed down the stairs with linked arms.
They were greeted by several of their friends from school. They all walked around mingling with their friends as the party went on Elena and Bonnie were laughing and talking when they ran into a guy with sandy hair and hazel eyes.
"Oh I'm sorry" Elena laughed.
"It's alright" The guy had a faint English accent.
"I'm Elena and this is Bonnie" Elena smiled gesturing to her friend.
"Nice to meet you" He smiled but seemed slightly confused, but held out his hand for them to shake. Elena shook his hand.
Bonnie did too and as she did an image of a bunch of kids about their age standing before him crossed her mind. The mad died and so did another girl.
"how are you here?" She gasped.
"Excuse me?" Klaus pulled his hand away looking worried.
"You died" Bonnie said not really meaning to say it out loud.
"A witch huh?" Klaus mumbled, straightening up.
xxx
"Guys, it's Saturday night." Bonnie was chewing on a strand of her curly red hair. She was that bored.
"So?" Matt said, eyebrow raised.
"And we're just sitting here, doing nothing!"
"Well there's nothing to do."
The gang was spread around the living room, everyone doing their own little thing. Meredith was reading a book, Matt was on his laptop, Elena was flipping through random channels on the tv, and Stefan and Damon were playing on their phones.
"Can we at least put on a movie?" She was almost whining.
"Sure, why not?"
"My feet are falling asleep." Elena spoke up. She shook her feet, green toe-nails wiggling. Everyone chuckled at her childish gesture.
"So which movie are we watching?" Meredith asked from her spot on the floor. Matt and her were sharing a blanket, laying on the ground since there wasn't enough space on the couch.
"A scary one." Bonnie suggested, mischief twinkling in her light brown eyes.
"Are you sure you won't be too scared?" Stefan teased, glancing up from his Android to look at her.
"Course not. That was the old Bonnie." She puffed out her chest and giggled.
"How about Nightmare on Elm Street?" Offered Elena, who had been looking for horror movies on Netflix.
"Yeah!" Bonnie agreed.
Everyone settled down and got comfortable. Meredith put her book aside and hurried over to turn the lights off. Soon, the smell of popcorn wafted out from the kitchen.
"I made butter popcorn, dears." Mrs. Flowers said, giving everyone a plate of their own. When she got to Stefan, Damon, and Bonnie she leaned closer to them.
"Fresh blood from donors." She said before handing them each a glass.
Bonnie sniffed the red liquid before delicately taking a sip. She was still getting used to the whole blood thing.
"It'll get less weird over time." Stefan whispered to her encouragingly.
"Thanks but I thought you were on a diet.."
"I am."
"But this is human blood."
"It's not the same thing. I-"
"Are we going to watch the movie or what?" Matt snapped, not bothering to hide the annoyment on his face.
"Matt!" Meredith scolded.
"I'm sorry but all they're talking about is blood and I don't even like the fact that Bonnie's a vampire."
"He's trying to help her." Meredith replied calmly. "She was going to do so much more in her life! She was going to grow up and have children! They stole that from her and now they're rubbing it in our face!"
"It was the only way to save her." Meredith argued.
"What, so now you're on their side?"
"That's not what I meant, Matt."
"I didn't expect that from you, Meredith. You, the vampire hunter."
"Don't bring that into this situation!" Meredith cried, nostrils flaring angrily.
Matt ignored her and continued, "There's a reason the word hunter is in there. You're supposed to hunt them and kill them, not live with them."
"Shut up, Matt." She said in a flat voice before getting up and racing up the stairs. Everyone stared at him, mouths open in shock.
"You're screwed, Mutt." Damon chuckled darkly, "You'll never get Scary Mary back."
xxx
Bonnie backed away from the strange guy quickly.
"We have to go" She pulled Elena away not waiting for a reply.
"What was that about?" Elena asked concerned.
"I don't know... I'm going home... Stay away from him alright" Bonnie warned before pushing through the crowds to the door.
Elena was so worried about her friend that she jumped when a hand touched her shoulder. "Oh my God Damon" Elena gasped spinning around.
"Sorry... but I've been instructed to keep you away from the new guy" Damon smirked.
"As well as I" Damon's smile disappeared when he heard Stefan's voice behind him.
"Really Mr. I'mhoppeduponhumanblood" Damon glared at him.
"Not now" Elena whispered getting in between the two brothers.
"Elena you wanna dance?" Tyler asked holding out his hand.
"Sure Ty... Just gimme a minute" Elena looked at both Stefan and Damon.
"I'll be right back okay?" Elena didn't want to be under the watch of the two Salvatores.
Although she was worried about Bonnie she still wanted to have some fun before the doom and gloom washed over the town. She walked over to Tyler.
He smiled, "So... are you single?" Tyler asked.
"Yeah" Elena laughed.
"Really? I thought you were with Stefan or Damon" He pulled her in closer to him.
"No... things got way to complicated" Elena smiled.
"Well in that case," Tyler's hand dropped lower on her back to her butt.
"What the hell are you doing?" Elena asked backing away.
"Oh come on... We're both single... we could get out of here" Tyler offered.
"Hands. Off. Now." Damon grabbed Tyler's hand removing it from Elena's butt.
"I thought you said that you were single" Tyler glared at Damon.
"Well she lied... now scram dog" Damon sneered.
"HEY COPS ARE COMING GET OUT" Damon shouted.
They house cleared quickly, "Why did you do that!" Elena snapped, "I could handle myself"
"Looks like it" Damon glared.
Elena rolled her eyes and stormed over to the couch and sat down.
"You have issues you know that?" Elena glared at Damon. "Good intentions" Damon smiled sitting beside her. She just rolled her eyes.
xxx
Bonnie Bennett was laying in her bed, staring up at the ceiling. She'd been staring so hard and long at it though, it was starting to look like a big blob. There's a new vampire in town. She thought, How much damage will this one do? She shook her head in dismay and sighed. I won't let him hurt anyone I love. She vowed silently to herself, Not my friends. Not after what happened with Grams. Just thinking about her Grandmother made tears well in her eyes. She blinked them away and rolled over on her side, closing her eyes. Soon after, she was fast asleep.
"The movie was good." Elena said with a yawn as she got up, "But I'm beat. I'm going to bed. Night!"
"Goodnight." Damon responded.
He stifled a yawn of his own and stretched. Matt had left half-way through the movie and nobody knew where he was. Meredith-well, Meredith was a sobbing mess in her room, and Bonnie had fallen asleep on Stefan, who was also knocked out. He got up with the intentions of going to his room but found himself crouching down to Bonnie's level and absentmindedly stroking her bangs from her face as she continued breathing softly. Finally, he forced himself to pull away from her and hurried to his room. Feelings were starting to re-surface in him even though he'd been trying so hard to push them away.
Bonnie was walking through a meadow. Everything was so beautiful and colorful. To her left and right was tall grass, so green it hurt to look at. But she was floating through a little path of bright flowers and she knew that she needed to follow the trail. For a second, she was worried she would crush the pretty flowers but they were smiling at her, encouraging her to continue. She could feel her red curls bouncing as she skipped. Suddenly, she saw a light. She squinted and walked faster. Now the light was right in front of her. She looked closer and realized it was an open door. She stepped through the door frame, the blue summer dress she was wearing fluttering.
"Hello?" She called out.
Then everything became clear and she was standing in the middle of an unfamiliar room. A girl wearing a party dress was curled into a ball on a bed, snoring lightly.
"Hello!" She repeated, her voice frantic. All of the peace she had felt when she was in the meadow drained from her like a balloon.
"Hey, can you help me? Wake up!" Bonnie grabbed a pillow from the bed and hit the girl's head with it.
"Hey!" The girl cried out, her eyes flying open as she sat up. She stared at Bonnie for a few seconds before she screamed, "What are you doing here? Who let you into my house? Who are you?"
"I don't know." Bonnie whimpered, "I was walking through a meadow and then I was here!"
"What?"
"I said...I was wal-"
"I heard you. But that doesn't make any sense. Tell me who you are!"
"I'm Bonnie."
"Is this some kind of joke?" The girl snapped, green eyes blazing with fury.
"No?" Bonnie raised an eyebrow in perplexity, "Who are you?"
"I'm Bonnie!"
Bonnie's eyes flew open with a gasp. She looked around with wide eyes but she was still in the Boarding House. Just a dream. She told herself. She pulled her head away from Stefan's shoulder and glanced around the living room one last time before she went to her room. There was something really creepy about that dream.