The woods were always a place Kaytlin would go. It would calm him down after a stressfull day or make him feel better when he was depressed. The slender trees would sway gently and the cool summer breeze would disrupt the redhead's hair. He didn't mind though, his thoughts today were stopped by a paper he had found on one of the tall trees. The male had heard rumors of a tall faceless being in these woods, but brushed it off as an immature prank. So, when Kaytlin found this paper, he shrugged it off as a dumb kid trying to scare someone and walked away. After venturing deeper into the dense woods, he had started to hear a slight static noise. Still, the teen walked on, unfazed but on gaurd. He was, after all, a fan of creepypasta and strongly believed in being one someday. The kids at school were starting to tear away his sanity and having no parents made it lonely. That's ok though, Suko lived with him. It was never awkward, since Kaytlin was gay. They often read pasta fanfics together and argued over favorite characters. Kaytlin was stuck between Laughing Jack and Slenderman for their killing styles were more gruesome. He was always interested in creepy, gory things. So when the static started to get louder, Kaytlin started to get worried. A kid would have grown tired by now. He sped up his pace a little, but fog was setting in and he knew then that this wasn't some joke. For some reason though, he wasn't as scared as he thought he would be. So instead of panicking or running, the male sat down on a damp fallen log. Moss and mushrooms had already started to grow off of the dead wood. It was slightly wet from the strange accumalating mist, which was eerily getting thicker. It was almost to the point where he couldn't see the trees that were three feet away from him. He was calm though, shivering slightly from cooling air. It was some time before the noise had finally stopped, giving off a pin-dropping silence. There were no birds singing their sweet tunes. The trees did not move in the wind. There was nothing to signal life for miles. Kaytlin had found it almost peaceful. A twig would snap here and there, the static noise following it, but Kaytlin just leaned back and relaxed. When the static sounded right above him, he flinched at the piercing sound. Opening his ruby eyes, he found himself staring into a blank white face. He did not move though, instead he reached up to touch the being, not frightened by the consequences. Said humanoid vanished instantly, so fast that Kaytlin thought it could have been his imagination. Sighing, the teen got up to head home, though it proved difficult in the still dense fog. He finally made it to the egde of the woods, his house a few feet away. Looking back, he could have sworn those tree branches had moved, but instead of investigating Kaytlin just headed inside. Upon closing the door, he was bombarded with questions from Suko, to which he replied that he took a walk. She must have known something was off for she didn't stop bugging him about details. The last thing the male said that night, which frightened Suko, was that...He's real... Soon after, Kaytlin headed up to his room, claiming he was tired. Suko had gone to bed after hearing the scary news, so she wouldn't expect Kaytlin to sneak out. Being daring and somewhat confident, he had managed to sneak out of his window on the second floor. Remembering to bring a flashlight, he turned it on and ventured back into the woods by his home. The fog had yet to leave, but the moon shown brightly through the trees, making it easier to see. Regretting not bringing a jacket, his ruby orbs darted suddenly at the now familiar static sound. Instead of waiting this time, Kaytlin walked towards the noise. He didn't move far before a tentacle wrapped around his ankle, swinging him upside down in the air. Still, he didn't panic, just stared at the tall being with interest. Slender stared at the strange male, confused as to why he was not cowering away in fear. He brought Kaytlin closer to him, causing the smaller to blush slightly at their closeness. Again, Slenderman could not comprehend the boy's reactions. A voice rang out into the open air, its tone low and somewhat scratchy. It sounded almost like many voices and the static came right after it. "You are not afraid?" The slender being tilted his blank head as he spoke, waiting for an answer. The other male shook his head, he was starting to get lightheaded. He was then turned right side up, the blood rushing everywhere making him want to vomit. Shaking his head, Kaytlin was able to concentrate better on the being. He could feel Slenderman staring at him, trying to reach inside his soul. The static suddenly got extremely intense, breaking through his mind and the rest of his sanity vanished. Something snapped inside of Kaytlin and it hurt. He yelled in pain as Slender searched through his memories and thoughts. Slenderman wrapped a black tentacle around the boy's mouth to silence his pained screams. Once Slender collected enough information he removed the tendril. Kaytlin was silent for some time with his head hanging down. Slender was startled when the human started laughing quietly to himself. Once he was composed enough to speak, Kaytlin looked up and smiled. "You could've just asked about my past. That hurt hehehe..." Slenderman once again tilted his head, this person was strange. His memories were interesting to Slender and he was considering him being a proxy. "Child, listen carefully. If you so wish, you could become a proxy of mine. Your past a peculiar to me and I can tell you will be a great addition to the family." Kaytlin barely had time to register the offer before a stabbing pain shot through his back. Slenderman seemed surprised as he peered behind the male to see Jeff, the infamous killer. He let the male down, who was choking on blood and gasping for breath. The slender creature grabbed Jeff and threw him back in the direction of his mansion. Going back over to Kaytlin, he noticed that the knife was lodged in his lower shoulder blade, close to his heart. "Child, you are going to die, but if you accept my offer, you will come back as one of us. He held out his hand to which Kaytlin struggled to reach up and grasp it. The operator symbol burned itself into his pale hand and the last of his energy faded away. There was a snap of a twig and the ever smiling killer came back into view, unscathed from being thrown. He went up to the unconscious form and ripped out his knife. "So what's so special about this one huh? Do you like him or something?" Jeff questioned the taller form, who tensed at the words. Jeff's permanent smile twitched as he started to chuckle. "Ah, so you do like him…" He pushed Kaytlin over to see his face and chuckled more darkly. "He is pretty cute. Better watch out." With that said, the bleach white killer ascended back towards the mansion. A large gasp cut into Slender's thoughts and he turned towards the panicked male. "Ow...It worked?" Kaytlin struggled to get up as a tentacle coiled around his waist, lifting him up to stand. There was no strength in his legs and he fell right back down when the tendril left. "Why can't I get up?" Kaytlin again struggled to move, his arms and legs trembling to hold his weight. "You have just come back from the dead. You will regain your energy in time." Slender lifted the exhausted male and placed him in his lanky arms. Said male's face became red from embarrassment, obviously surprised that the humanoid would want this kind of physical contact. He said nothing though, realizing just how tired he really was. Finding himself falling asleep, Kaytlin relaxed as Slender turned to leave. There was a voice in the distance that stopped them. Suko sprinted out of the brush, panting heavily from running so much. She came to a stop a few feet away, glaring at Kaytlin the whole time. After she regained her breath, Suko marched right up to the slender being and smacked Kaytlin on the head. "You idiot! I knew you'd come out here to find Slenderman on your own!" Said male flinched at her sudden loud voice. He didn't get to speak as Suko rambled on, also commenting on why he's being carried. Kaytlin explained everything, even asking Slender if she could become a creepypasta. After some persuading, Slenderman had agreed to let Suko join them, quickly transforming her so they could go home. Their stuff could be packed tomorrow and brought to the mansion. Kaytlin had once again fallen asleep, snuggled against Slender's chest. Suko smiled cheekily, knowing that Slenderman must have some affectionate feelings towards her best friend. "Are you falling for my buddy?" She giggled when his blank white face flushed red. He nodded slightly, unsure of the feelings fluttering inside of him. Thinking about it, Slender realized that he did fall in love with the male. He was different from the others and he didn't run away in fear when they met. Slenderman understood now that he had been craving for someone to see him as something other than a monster. They said nothing more as the mansion came into view. Everyone was either asleep or out killing so they headed for the guest rooms without a dilemma.
*Time skip cuz I'm lazy*
It was the afternoon of the next day. Everyone had been introduced and Kaytlin seemed to fit in perfectly. Suko was different because she immediately started playing games with BEN. There was a problem earlier when BEN said Kaytlin wasn't scary and he decided to show just how scary he could be. His jaw ripped open, causing the ends of his mouth to tear into a wicked black smile. Ruby orbs turned pure black as Kaytlin advanced towards BEN, who ended up crying for two hours. The mansion had settled down by now and Suko suggested playing a game. Seven minutes in heaven! It took a while for everyone to agree, without Sally of course, and now everyone was sitting in a circle awaiting the items to choose from. An hour went by and neither Kaytlin nor Slender had played yet. Suko was up to something. She giggled evilly as Kaytlin stuck his hand in BEN's hat, who put up a fight before the game. He pulled out a piece of paper with Slender's symbol and before anything could be said, Suko had already shoved both of them roughly into the closet. Kaytlin had landed first, smashing his cheek on the opposite wall from the door. Slender had crouched down to make room, but he moved to pick the stunned male up. As he was being lifted into long skinny arms, Kaytlin began rubbing at his sore cheek. It was slightly red around a gash mark. It stayed silent until ripping and tearing sounds could be heard. Now Slender's mouth had appeared and was currently pressed against the mark on Kaytlin's face, which flushed crimson at the contact. His lips moved towards an unsuspecting mouth and Slender paused to see if there was any rejection or disgust. Kaytlin simply closed the distance, their lips molded together perfectly. He was lifted slightly higher for better access and the wall met with his back as Slender forced his tongue hungrily into the male's moaning cavern. The smaller male's legs were wrapped around Slender's skinny form, his hands clutching his black suit. Long arms were locked securely around Kaytlin's petite waist as they tangled their tongues together in a sinful dance. Light then protruded from the door as a flash nearly blinded them. Many of the pastas were standing in front of the door staring at the bewildered couple. They didn't see much as Slender teleported both of them away, reappearing at the couch with Kaytlin on his lap. His face was compared to a tomato, squirming slightly on his new lover's lap. All eyes were on him and it was getting uncomfortable. He buried his face in Slender's suit, trying to disappear away from the stares. Deep chuckling resonated out of the chest he was pressed against and suddenly they weren't in the living room anymore. This was Slendermans bedroom. Kaytlin squeaked when he was set on the bed. He never imagined it being so soft and he found himself rolling around on it, snuggling into the pillows. Slender watched, clearly amused by the childlike behavior. A tentacle slithered around around the boy's hips, causing him to squeak as his was yet again set on Slender's lap. This time his legs were spread around the being, straddling him. Arms were once again placed around his small form and Slender lent down to kiss the male's face. He left butterfly kisses on a pale neck, making the other giggle. "Heh that tickles...ah!" His laughs were cut short as sharp teeth sunk into his neck. There was no pain however, as the teeth never broke the skin. They nibbled down to Kaytlin's shoulder and gently grazed over his chin as their lips met again. Slender's long tongue found its way back into now familiar territory. His cold hands made Kaytlin shiver as they ran up his chest and sides, stopping at his nipples. Fingers moved to lightly pinch the pink nubs and he found himself moving closer to the large hands. Slender was satisfied to hear the moans and whimpers from his lover. He could feel the excitement from the other rubbing against his lower stomach and slightly brushing against his own need. Kaytlin was unconsciously grinding their clothed erections together as they made out. Clothes were shed and Kaytlin ran his hands around Slender's form, astonished to find that he wasn't as skinny as he thought. Muscles were packed tightly into lanky arms and legs, along with his chest and stomach. Something practically resembling a third leg was pressed against Kaytlin's backside, making him gulp nervously. It was very warm and very big. Slender sensed his nervousness and brought his white hand to a flushed cheek, stroking gently. "Do you want to continue?" Kaytlin nodded hesitantly. "W-will that even fit?" He stuttered out. Slender chuckled. "Do not worry, you must let me prep you thoroughly so it doesn't hurt." Nodding to his words, Kaytlin moved to lie down on his back. He gasped in surprise as Slender pushed his legs open and moved in between them. One smooth tendril coiled around his erection, drawing out a low moan. A cold wet finger made its way towards his ass, circling around his twitching hole before pushing inside slowly. Kaytlin yelped at the sudden invasion and the coldness. His legs moved to close shut, but tentacles were securely wrapped around them. Ruby eyes squeezed shut as the finger moved inside him. His back arched a little when the finger curled upwards, hitting his prostate. A loud moan echoed off the walls, followed by the sound of a hand clasping over a flustered face, muffling the rest of his moans. It did not last long as a second finger joined the first, a whimper following. "Ow…" Slender barely heard the soft whisper, but stopped moving his fingers. "Relax my dear, it will get better soon." The smaller male nodded, Soon two fingers felt comfortable inside Kaytlin and Slender moved them vigorously, causing the other to moan and squirm. The appendages suddenly spread his walls out in a scissoring motion, but it did not hurt since they were still pressing against the sensitive bundle of nerves. His legs were trembling and he felt close to his release. The pleasure was cut short again as a tendril made its way inside his tight hole. The pain lasted only a second as it slithered up to to his sensitive spots. "W-what?" Kaytlin gasped out breathlessly. "You still need to be stretched, love." The tendril wriggled inside him shooting sparks of pleasure throughout his body. Once again the pleasure stopped when the appendage was removed. Slender laughed quietly when Kaytlin whined, his hips moving to search for a source of pleasure. Slender moved to ground his member between Kaytlin's plump cheeks, eliciting a moan from both of them. The hard tip was pushed past the tight ring of muscles, but not even halfway in, Slender had stopped. Tears were fighting to escape beautiful red eyes, lips were pressed tightly together, and his face was slightly scrunched up in pain. Neither of them moved as Slender comforted his lover, trying to ease the pain by stroking his now limp cock. Kaytlin nodded for him to keep going, holding his breath as it pushed in further. Everything went still as he finally reached all the way inside. Kaytlin was once again filled with intense pleasure when Slender moved only a little and it struck against his prostate. Said being must have noticed the change in his lover's reaction when he moved on accident, so he started out with a slow pace. Kaytlin squirmed at the feeling of something rubbing at his inner walls, gripping the sheets beneath them as Slender sped up, hitting the nerves straight on. A loud moan echoed off the walls again and hands entwined together before Kaytlin could cover his mouth. Instead, a tendril came up to his lips and he opened them to let it slide inside. It was smooth against his tongue and he sucked on it harshly as Slender started pounding inside at inhuman speeds. Kaytlin could feel the dick inside of him twitch along with his own excitement. Both were close to their release and Kaytlin moaned around the tentacle as he came, coating his and Slender's lower stomach. The walls around his member tightened and brought Slender to his climax, spilling completely inside the warm moist walls of his lover. Both were panting heavily and Slenderman slid out slowly to lie beside the exhausted male. Tentacles cleaned up their mess. Limbs tangled together as they fell asleep.
*Time skip*
Light crept past slightly opened curtains, stirring both figures in the bed. One got up to stretch, but immediately collapsed. The other, awoken by the distressed male, leaned over the bed to see Kaytlin lying on the floor in a bundled mess of blankets. He was groaning quietly, trying to get untangled from the mass of blankets they had cuddled under. "Are you alright?" He got a grunt in response as the pieces of fabric were still wrapped around Kaytlin's limbs. Once he was free, the male face planted back onto the bed, groaning loudly. Slender tilted his head in confusion, placing a hand on the mop of crimson hair that adorned the boy's head. "What is wrong my dear?" Kaytlin grumbled something incoherent before lifting his face to speak. "Isn't it obvious? My ass hurts." Again he smothered his face into the bed. "I apologize if I was too rough with you." Kaytlin shook his head. "It was amazing, this is just normal after someone's first time." He blushed from admitting that he liked it. Slender pulled him into a hug. "I love you…" he
*Extended ending*
Slenderman had to ignore the snorts and wolf whistles from his proxies as he made breakfast. Kaytlin hid upstairs most of the day. From embarrassment and pain...