Warning:This story contains some season 4 spoilers

Sam's P.O.V

I walked, no strided down the hallway proud. I was now a Senior at Mckinley, Captain and Quarterback of the Football team, Co-captain of the Glee Club along with Tina, and I had a new girlfriend, Kitty.

Kitty is a Cheerio and I know she wants to be head cheerleader, it's all she seems to talk about. She is kind I guess, it's more like she is when it suits her best. I had gotten a visit from Santana a couple of days ago telling me that I need to dump Kitty because Kitty had tried to get Brittany kicked off the Cheerioes. I had just told Santana to buzz off because Kitty's nice enough to me, and cause Santana has been known to lie more than once.

I walked up to Kitty's locker and waited behind the door for her to close it. I realised that Kitty's locker used to be Quinns, but I quickly pused that thought out of my mind when I came face to face with Kitty.

"Hi Sam, didn't expect to see you atleast not until first break" smiled Kitty. I slung my arm around her sholder

"Well I wanted to surprise you" I smiled back.

As we walked down the hallway I said hi to Artie and Brittany, which seemed to make Kitty a little uneasy. I also said hi to Tina but she only gave me a half-smile which dissapeared as quickly as it had come. Tina had never really approved of Kitty, claiming she was just using me to get to the top.

We arrived at Kitty's classroom and w said goodbye and she kissed me on the cheek. Kitty turned towards the classroom then surprisingly turned and kissed me full on the lips.

"Bye" she quickly stated as she walked into her English class. I looked into the room to see the boy sitting behind Kitty giving me the evils, 'jealous much' I thought. He was the boy who had just joined Glee Club yesterday, I think his name is Ryder or something like that. i quickly waved to Kitty then left for my own class.

History is the most boring subject in the world, I don't even remember why I took it. When the teacher turned towards the board to write something, I decided it was the perfect time to try for a nap. After only a couple of minutes I was being tapped on the sholder 'Oh crap' I thought 'She caught me' I quickly looked up, relieved to see that it was only Tina.

"Sam we need to talk, she has just given us a group activity so talking won't seem out of place" said Tina and I nodded.

"What's the activity?" I asked

"Continuation from yesterdays work, but that's not important"

"But I didn't do my work yesterday" I replied. She slid her book towards me

"Copy mine" she whispered. Obviously what she wanted to tell me must have been important baecause Tina wasn't one for cheating or anything like it.

"Sam it's about Kitty" she started and I sighed

"Then I don't want to hear it, she is my girlfiend and that's that" I gestured with my hands to really prove my point.

"But I just need to know what it is that makes you like her, because I have my theories".

I sighed again "I just do okay". To be honest I wasn't sure what attracted me to Kitty, I just knew that I liked her when I saw her.

"Well then do you want to hear my theories?" asked Tina

"FIne, you tell me why I like my girlfriend"

"It's because she is just like Quinn". That both shocked and confused me, Quinn and Kitty are nothing alike.

"How?" I asked kind of angy now and I didn't really know why.

"The way she walks, the way she talks, stands, pouts, and she's even a Cheerio just like when you first met Quinn".

Thank-god the bell went cause I needed to get away from Tina, unfortuantely she folowed me.

"Even her eyes" she continued. I stopped and Tina walked straight into me. I quickly turned to face her and responded just as quickly without thinking

"Their eyes are nothing alike, Quinn's are much prettier". Tina sighs then smiles

"And you see right there, I just proved my point" and with that she walked off.

The next day went much the same until after I had dropped Kitty off at her English. I was confronted by Tina again.

"What do you want now" I sounded just a little bit to angry.

"Geez can't I just walk with you?" she answered

"I'm sorry" I apologized "It's just that I thought ... "

"Have you talked to Quinn yet?" she interupted

"You'd do that, and no I'm not even going to. I'm with Kitty and I'm perfectly happy"

"You won't be happy until you are with the real deal, not just some cheap imitation" Tina wasn't usually this mean to anyone so she must really hate Kitty.

"Please don't insult Kitty" I said softly and half-heartedly. Tina could obviously tell she was breaking me cause she smiled.

"Sam you can live your life how you want but you need to learn who you really love, and you and I both know it isn't Kitty"

Tina left me standing her completely confused and utterly lost. I really liked Kitty but obviouly not enough for what I was going to do next.