DISCLAIMER:
I do not own any of the Hayate no Gotoku! Franchises and respect the intellectual property of Mr. Hata Kenjirou. This is based on an unfinished serialization and the story might not concur with the development of the manga's plot as the manga continues to serialize. This is based on events that have happened on or before Chapter 487, and some parts of the story is a stipulation of a possible event that may happen in the future chapters of Hayate no Gotoku! This is an original fan-fiction, and it is purely a coincidence if any of the plot have coincided with any original work of other authors.
Prologue: My Story Can't Be This Simliar to Tsukasa Fushimi's
"Will you stay as Nagi's butler, Hayate-kun?"
Hinagiku asked, looking directly into Hayate. Nagi, Chiharu, and all those 50 people who came with them to take the Level 5 challenge during the school trip, was shocked by this sudden question. This seemed to be the last thing that Hinagiku would do for anybody, but there she did: Using that 150 million Yen prize money to pay off the debt for Hayate the debt-ridden butler.
"Sorry, Hinagiku-san. I will stay as my ojou-sama's butler."
"Why? Even though I won in the end and I would paid off that 150 million Yen debt for you?"
"She is my saviour and I cannot leave her. You know that more than anyone, Hinagiku-san. Please spare me."
"But I saved your life as well! You don't have to be indebted anymore! You can finally have a better life with Ruka!"
"No, Hinagiku-"
"You can have a 'normal' life with Ayumu!"
"No, Hinagiku-"
"You can have your past back with Athena!"
"No, Hinagiku-"
"And you can have a happier life with-with... with me!"
"No- Eh, wait, Hinagiku-san?" Hayate was stunned, but Hinagiku was on a roll.
"I love you, Hayate-kun! I have fallen in love with you since that meeting on the roof! I wanted to get the 150 million Yen debt just so because you said you cannot date anybody as a butler! And I don't want to see that happening! I want to go out with you! So please, go out with me!"
Silence bestowed upon them on this snowy day. Hinagiku was crying, and Hayate could do nothing but hug her. Nagi was screaming, "WHAT?", and the others were murmuring among themselves. None of them could foresee this coming.
"Sorry, Hinagiku-san. Can you give me some time to think over it?" Hayate answered, his brain completely messy right now.
"I wouldn't mind, Hayate-kun."
"Thank you, Hinagiku-san."
Hayate walked into the buildling, to the amazement of all.
