Ooh, an AU MBAV story now! Woot woot!
This one is a doozy! It's gonna blow ya'lls minds…
Maybe.
Maybe not.
Who knows?
Anyways, I don't own MBAV. Just a fan, who likes to manipulate the characters to my will.
…
"Ugh," Benny groaned as the jock behind him pushed into him again. "God."
"That's it little gay boy, moan for me," a gruff voice groaned behind him, pushing into him hard again, his grip tightening on Benny's slighter frame. "Damn, almost as tight as a girl. Totally worth the 100 bucks." Benny just groaned again as the guy sped up his movements. Benny clawed at the stall wall in front of him and bit his lip as the guy gripped his hips tightly before his movements stilled; he gave one more jerky thrust and stilled against Benny completely now. The guy pulled out and fell against the far wall of the stall. Benny pulled up his pants and fell to the ground. "Thanks dude," the guy said, dropping the money on the floor next to him and leaving. Benny nodded and pocketed the money before getting up on shaky legs.
He stumbled out of the locker room to find his best friend waiting by the door, giving him a sympathetic look.
"I don't know why you do that," Emily said, her look now turning from sympathetic to stern.
"Because I need money, and guys like sex; to them, a hole is a hole."
"That's disgusting." He looked at Emily as they began the trek home; she was maybe an inch or two shorter than him, with dark brown curly hair that barely reached her shoulders. Her dark brown eyes could analyze you and penetrate you to your very soul. She had naturally pretty cheekbones and eyelashes; she was adorable in her own way. She didn't really wear much makeup, but her ears were pierced, and usually had just plain sparkly studs in them. She wore a series of choker-like necklaces around her neck, along with some dangly ones every now and then. Today she wore a hooded top and a knee-length skirt, gray leggings, and black flat ankle boots.
"Benny, have you heard a thing I said?" he shook his head and looked into her eyes, feeling his stomach knot a bit.
Which he knew was weird.
"I'm sorry, what?"
"Ugh, Benny!" she exclaimed, voice cracking on his name. He quirked an eyebrow at that and made her blush.
"What was that?"
"Nothing!" her voice cracked again, making Benny look at her weirdly. She coughed and shook out her short hair. "Benny, I really think you should stop sleeping with so many guys."
"Technically, I haven't slept with any of them."
"Benny!"
"What?" he said with a small laugh, making her roll her eyes at him. "Oh come on Em! I'm making good money this way. Let me take you to an early dinner. My treat."
"With your dirty money? You're gonna have to do better than that B."
"Emily. Seriously." She stopped and gave him a small glance, biting her lip. "I know what I'm doing is wrong, but… what else can I do? I'm never going to find a relationship in that school. But this way, I have enough dirt on half the guys there that "don't wanna be gay", so I will never be beaten up again! It's a win-win for everyone."
"Imagine this scenario," she said, twirling to face him and licking her lips; Benny was surprised the simple action made him twitch in areas that girls never affected. "You find someone. You two fall in love. You end your business. Your clients hunt you down because they don't want to lose an easy fuck. You break the love of your life's heart for cheap, sleazy sex. Is that what you want to do with your life? Be someone's whore?" She shook her head at his expression and turned on her heel. "Benny, think about who you could be hurting. What if someone loves you?"
He watched her walk away from him, and he felt his stomach burning in something he couldn't describe.
Could she be right?
...
Benny couldn't concentrate on homework that night. He saw Emily moving about in her room, but he hadn't talked to her since she blew up at him. He looked at his watch and saw it was only 10. Maybe they would let him in. Slipping on his shoes, he hurried out his backdoor and headed to hers; Knocking on the backdoor, he saw her little sister Jane open it.
"Hey Jane!" he said, giving her a big smile. "Can I see Emily?" Jane snickered and shrugged.
"Sure, why not," she said, opening the door for him. "She's in her room."
"Thanks," he said, sidestepping the laughing 9 year old and hurrying to his friend's room. Knocking quickly, he heard a simple 'come in'. He opened the door and felt his jaw drop.
"Benny, what are you doing here?" Emily asked, standing up from her bed. He was speechless as he looked at her. She was in a tank top and short-shorts. "Benny?"
"Uhhh…. I wanted… to apologize…. For earlier."
"Oh." She nodded and sat back down on the bed, not looking at him now. "I shouldn't be pushing you to change who you are. I just worry about you. You know I care about you."
"And I care about you. Whenever you get a boyfriend, I'll be the first guy to threaten him. And no guy likes getting threatened by a gay guy," he said, coming to sit next to her on her bed.
"Uhh… there's no guys at this school that would be interested in me," she said, tucking her hair behind her ear.
"What? Are you kidding me?! You're so… adorable! If I was straight, we'd be dating by now I bet." She looked at him in shock before shaking her head.
"Benny, you wouldn't be saying that if…"
"If what?" She bit her lip then leaned forward and pressed her lips to his.
And his world EXPLODED.
The minute her soft silky lips touched his, he felt like his heart would beat out of his chest; he saw lights in front of his eyes, and he felt like he was falling.
When she pulled away, she whispered to him, "I'm sorry."
"What. Was that? I'm gay Emily. You know that better than anyone." She nodded and curled up in a ball on her bed. "Why… did I feel something with your kiss?" She whispered something but he couldn't hear her. "What?"
"BECAUSE I'M A BOY!" she screamed, tears running down her face now. She sobbed and hugged her pillow. "I'm a boy."
"Wh-what?" He looked at Emily; adorable, petite Emily. His best friend since she moved there 3 years ago. "But… I'm so confused."
"At my old school… I was bullied for being gay. When we move here, I begged my parents to help me get through this. The principal is actually an old friend of my mom's. They discussed things and enrolled me as a girl. That way I could like guys without being beaten up or abused like I had been before. And then… out of all the fuckin' guys in school… I fell for you. I didn't want to. I knew you thought I was a girl, so why would you look twice at me? I'm sorry I kissed you. I just… I couldn't take it anymore!"
"What's your name…?"
"Ethan."
"Ethan."
And when he said that name, he felt his heart tighten then explode again.
Ethan sounded so much better than Emily.
"Em-Ethan," he said, looking at her. "If you're a guy… then why do you have boobs?" She chuckled and shook her head before slipping off her shirt. He watched as she unbuttoned her bra and slipped it off her slight shoulders. He saw her slightly toned chest, her flat toned chest. "Ethan," he whispered, looking at her again.
"It's Emily."
"No. It's Ethan," Benny said, leaning forward and pressing his lips against his now.
Now, it felt right.
"Benny, stop," Ethan moaned as Benny pressed his lips against every available surface of Ethan's skin that he could reach. "You don't want this."
"Why not? You were right. I was in love. I just didn't notice it until now. I was blinded by you as a girl."
"But if I had never told you-"
"I would've wanted you eventually."
"I can't. Not tonight."
"Why?"
"Because I don't want to be another lay to you." He was now lying over Ethan/Emily, looking at her. She still looked like the girl he had known for the past few years, but he could also see the guy tendencies in her.
"I will never touch another person ever again."
"You'd stop… for me?"
"Yes."
"Benny-"
"Please, Ethan. Let me love you." He sobbed and wrapped his arms around Benny, who held him tightly. "I won't ever hurt you. Be my Ethan. Mine only."
"Yes."
…
"Can I?" Benny asked, fingers toying with the edge of Ethan's sleep shorts. Ethan nodded and slipped his eyes closed as he felt the thin material slip down his long, lean legs. "Beautiful," Benny whispered, his breath hot on Ethan's skin. Ethan whimpered as he felt a cool tongue touch his now flustered skin.
"Benny," he whimpered out, biting his lip to keep from being too loud. Benny chuckled before pinning Ethan's hips down and taking him completely into his mouth. "Benny!" Benny chuckled around him, making him shiver and attempt to move. "Benny. Please." Benny chuckled again and deep throated Ethan, getting him as deep as he could. "God." Benny pulled off with a pop and kissed Ethan, slipping his tongue into his mouth.
"I love you."
"I love you too."
"Can we…?" Ethan blushed and smiled before nodding.
…
"God, Benny!" Ethan gasped out as he pushed into him again. "Harder!"
"Fuck, Ethan," he groaned, pulling Ethan tighter against him as they moved together as one. Benny knew, sex like this was completely worth the wait now. He knew he would never get this feeling of intimacy with those douchebags at school.
"Benny. I love you."
"I love you too Ethan," Benny whispered, kissing him with everything he had. "I always have. And I always will." Ethan smiled into the kiss as they ended up in bliss together.
"Forever."
"Forever."
…
Benny walked into school the next day, a smile on his face and a spring in his step. His smile grew as he saw Emily standing at her locker.
"Hey baby," he whispered, wrapping his arms around her slim waist and kissing the back of her neck.
"Benny!" she exclaimed, turning in his embrace. "You're supposed to be gay."
"And you're supposed to be a girl. Looks like we're both lying to society."
"You're still gay."
"And at school, you're a girl. Which means I can do this," he said, giving her a loving kiss, "And not get bitched at."
"But what about-"
"Don't worry about anything baby," Benny said, tightening his arms. "I've dealt with all these assholes before. And most of them have had gay sex with me. We're good. No one will bother us. I love you."
"I love you too," she said, giving in and giving him a small smile. "Last night was a lot of fun."
"I'm glad you enjoyed yourself. I sure did." She chuckled and rested her head against his chest briefly.
"Maybe this'll work."
"It will. Trust me."
…
"Hey Benny." He looked up to see one of his usuals lounging against his desk in class. He looked around but didn't see Emily anywhere. "Wanna meet up during lunch?"
"Uh…I can't…" he said nervously; now he realized what he had been told all along. This was a hard thing to do. "I'm seeing someone."
"I'll double the usual amount."
"I can't."
"I'll triple it." Benny felt his mouth dry at the offer. This guy must have been desperate for it! But he couldn't hurt his Ethan/Emily for money… "Come on, you know you want to. I promise you'll enjoy it. We'll do it anyway you want to." He looked at the guy in surprise before shaking his head.
"I'm sorry, but I'm in a relationship now. I can't."
"Either you'll do it willingly or I'll make you. Either way I'm getting my sex from you," the guy said, slapping his hand on Benny's desk. "See you at lunch."
…
Gasp! Will Benny hurt his "Emily"? Will he resist? What will happen next?
(This story prolly won't be very long, maybe, who knows right?)
We shall see, won't we?
-JustMe133