Tbh this has been on my mind for a while lol. Been teasing poor Riven with her love for James so I figured I'd do that here. With a snarky and friendly Katarina as well :D
"Well, this is certainly unexpected." Evelynn mused to the two women sitting before her.
"Um, I feel like I should remind you that she's the one who wants it, not me." Katarina said.
"Then why are you here love?" Evelynn asked.
"She felt more comfortable with a friend by her side." Katarina answered. "I can kind of understand it."
The Agony's Embrace purred, looking mischievously at the white-haired woman who had her head hung in shame.
"You do know that I and James aren't exactly the type of couple to fool around right love?" Evelynn stated. She looked away briefly with her talons on her chin. "Well, it's more like him who doesn't like that. I'm personally open to having more people join in, though it's only women that I'll allow."
The white-haired woman finally brought her head up, cheeks crimson red just like her eyes. Riven took a deep breath as she stared at the succubus.
"I can't take it anymore Evelynn." She sighed. "Me and him have been best friends for years, but I'll always have the urge deep down to just drag him to my bedroom and just sit on hi-"
"Shh." Evelynn soothed. "I know what you mean love. It's a feeling I felt when I first met him. Gods he was so good, and he still knows how to make a woman feel to this very day."
Evelynn's words were driving Riven to the brink of insanity and she couldn't take it anymore. The succubus could see how badly she was mentally torturing Riven, and she chose to give her a break.
"Well… alright, love. I suppose I could let James be yours... if you agree to two things." Evelynn said.
Katarina raised a brow and looked at Riven, seeing that she was clearly telling herself that she shouldn't take this given who Evelynn was, but she was thinking from her heart and not her brain. She leaned forward to hear the blue woman's words.
"Well given that this might set up a new thing for him, I'd like it if you wore your um, infamous bunny suit. At least for one session." She cooed.
Riven's eyes widened at this, a slight glare aimed at the succubus who had a naughty smile on. She giggled at the fighter's reaction and looked to see Katarina glaring as well. Riven tried to remain angry, but in a way, it aroused her. Hearing this was naughty and perverted, but she got butterflies thinking about how nice it could be to have James see her in such an alluring outfit.
"Okay, fine." Riven said firmly, Katarina looking at her with rare shock. "And the other one?"
Evelynn hummed and her golden eyes soon fell upon The Sinister Blade. Katarina narrowed her eyes in suspicion before coming to a conclusion.
"You want… me… to…?" She asked pointing at herself.
The Agony's Embrace giggled. "With your kitty-cat uniform."
Riven widened her eyes in alarm. Katarina, on the other hand, seemed to be completely unaffected by it. The redhead put her arms up, folding apart her hands with an exasperated look.
"Sure, why not?" Katarina asked nonchalantly. "After all it's not like I haven't had the same thoughts of having that man all to myself. Although granted we'll be sharing him it seems." She said to Riven.
"N-No!" Riven stated defensively. "I'm not doing this! This is supposed to be between me and James!"
"What's wrong love?" Evelynn sneered. "Are you afraid of a little friendly competition?" She winked at Katarina who rolled her eyes.
"No!" Riven spat out. "I just wanted this to be a more intimate and romantic scenario."
"You're asking her to give you her boyfriend so you can ride him." Katarina said sarcastically.
Riven glared daggers at The Sinister Blade who put her hands up in defense with a smug smile.
"Calm down!" She laughed. "I'm just saying what's true."
"Both you girls have lovely rears that mesmerize even me." Evelynn giggled. "Though Katarina's does a far better job at being shown given her leather pants."
"That's not true!" Riven shouted, sounding almost offended which made the succubus look at her with a shocked grin.
"Maybe you should wear your bunny suit the moment he sees you." Katarina said nudging Riven playfully.
"I'm not going to do that because this isn't happening! No deal Evelynn!" Riven spat.
Evelynn sighed and stood up from her chair. "Alright, guess me and Katarina will just have to make do with him."
"W-What?!" Riven exclaimed. She looked at Katarina who was looking at Evelynn. "Kat, you're seriously not considering this right?"
The Sinister Blade shrugged, soon getting up from her seat. "Well before I could give or take, but now that I've had some time to think about it, I actually want to do it more. James is my friend, but I'll be damned if I don't take this opportunity to see how good he is in bed."
"Splendid love!" Evelynn exclaimed. "I trust you'll allow me some access to that shapely rear of yours?"
There was something about Katarina being so casual about this whole ordeal that it made Riven feel a bit jealous. How could the redhead see this is a mere fling? Maybe she was more laid back than Riven. It made the girl feel irritated.
"Fine!" She stated.
Katarina and Evelynn looked at Riven who had a vein along her head, her fists clenching as she set aside her pride and agreed to this. Evelynn smirked mischievously and paced to her.
"Excellent my dear." She purred. "I knew you'd come to your sense sooner or later."
Riven grumbled, grabbing Evelynn's shoulder with the woman tensing up at this. She pulled her closer.
"If you ever tell anyone about this, I wil-"
"Oh relax!" Evelynn said exasperatedly. "I would never dream of exposing my beloved James Holland to public humiliation. If it was you or Katarina, I'd have no problem with it."
"If that's supposed to get a rise out of me, it's failed." Katarina said bluntly.
Evelynn sighed before speaking. "Well splendid! I'll get everything set up and inform you of where to meet!"
"How will you get James to agree with this?" Riven asked.
"Oh don't worry dear, I already have it planned out."
…
James was enjoying his time to himself, sitting on the couch with his feet propped on the table. Dressed in his unique armor minus the helmet, James felt comfortable. An ice-cold beer in his hand completed everything. The man preferred to keep the celebrations of his birthday to a minimum as that's the way he liked it. He heard the door open and he shifted his head to see his lover Evelynn walking into the room. She had on that seductive and malicious type of smile, a look he'd become familiar with and came to love.
"James…" She purred.
She advanced on him, those curves of hers standing out as always whenever she waved them at him. James allowed her to straddle him with her thighs quickly moving down to his, hugging them and trapping the man. Her hands wrapping around his neck as James acted on instinct, putting his hands on those shapely hips.
Well, with the beer bottle dropping onto the carpet with no damage done thankfully. He looked up into the eyes of his love, remembering how much of a predator Evelynn was, but could look completely innocent as well. She leaned closer to him, their noses touching as the woman cooed.
"And what exactly can I do for you?" He asked.
Evelynn hummed, pretending like she was thinking. "I have a special gift for you my love, but first, how about a kiss?"
"You made me stop drinking my beer for a kiss?" James asked with a raised brow. He held off a chuckle at Evelynn's unamused look and he smiled. "Well you know I can never resist you."
As he prepared to close the distance, Evelynn abruptly pulled him in for a heated kiss. By this time, James knew of Evelynn's advances and he matched her tongue, both neck in neck as their tongues dance. Evelynn suddenly bit down on James's lip, receiving a growl from the man who responded with a harsh spanking, eliciting moans from the succubus who ran her claws along the couch, shredding it in the process. Through their kissing, James, without bothering to look, tried to turn off the nearby lamp, but he couldn't find the switch and as Evelynn licked along his side jaw, she bit down on his soft skin and drew some blood from the area. James gave up and just grabbed the lamp, throwing it onto the floor with a shatter and leaving the two of them in near darkness.
He grabbed her lashers and tugged on them, making Evelynn let out a little yelp as she was forced to follow. James then lunged at her with both of them falling off the couch, landing on the carpet with a loud thud. He was in a rare primal state, attacking Evelynn's collarbone and chest. The woman almost allowed him to dominate her right there, but then James felt a pinch on his arm.
It was a different feeling.
Looking over to where it'd come from, James could see that Evelynn's glowing talons embedded themselves into his skin, and he glared with an unamused look when turning back to his love who had on a devilish grin.
James let out an exasperated sigh as he felt the world around him fade. He saw Evelynn's eyes turned purely red with that grin becoming wider.
"God… Dammit…" He droned.
"Lights out."
…
When James finally regained consciousness, he was assaulted by a blinding light and he put his hand up to shield his eyes as they adjusted to the new environment. He heard the presence of someone else in the room, but his vision was blurry and he could only make out a brief silhouette before they disappeared outside, the sound of a door closing was heard. He felt sheets covering his body and the mattress having welcomed him after being on it for presumed hours. With a strained groan, James finally sat up from the bed, putting his hands over his face and rubbing the dried crust from his eyes in the process.
He could hear wildlife outside of the room, and after some hesitation with leaving he comfortable bed, James got up with a stretch. He then realized that the only thing he was in was his boxers, leading him to immediately cover himself given that there were no blinds on the screen door. Cursing under his breath, James proceeded to move but noticed a chair with a red tropical shirt on it with some shorts.
He shrugged and dressed up in the clothing. He took a sigh of relief as he felt more comfortable. Remembering his situation, James paced towards the screen door and slid it open, stepping into the blazing heat of the sun. He felt the hot ground burn his feet and James quickly hurried under a tree for shade. After taking comfort in the area, he finally noticed something else.
In the distance, he could see two long beach chairs, one of them occupied by a person who seemed to have tentacles coming out of her…
"Evelynn." He muttered.
Immediately, James paced towards the chairs, fists clenched as he glared at his girlfriend who was clearly in the chair. Upon reaching it, he found that she'd changed her appearance, hair black with a few blue bangs. Evelynn slowly turned to his direction, having on a pair of sunglasses with a blue bikini, though the bottom was unfortunately covered by a towel. She smiled at him as she lifted up her glasses, revealing her blue eyes.
"Glad to see you're awake love." She said with a smile.
James rolled his eyes, taking a step towards Evelynn who took a sip from her mojito, not taking her eyes off him. She pouted while tilting her head. "Are you mad at me?"
"Oh you mean apart from putting me into an unconscious state with your charm and dragging me to God knows where?" James asked sarcastically. "No. No, I'm not mad at all!"
"Aww, don't be mad booboo." Evelynn cooed. "I think you're going to like the reason why I dragged you here."
"And what reason could that possibly be?" James asked rhetorically.
Evelynn didn't look at him, just choosing to point straight ahead with James following it. Upon looking, James soon found himself looking at a sight he didn't expect.
Out of the ocean's water came Katarina, The Sinister Blade soaked all over in a sheen of cascading water droplets. James blinked a few times, finding himself unable to look away from the redhead. Katarina ran her hands through her head, flipping back any hair that dared to flop down in front of her. Donned in a two-piece bikini, Katarina's ample chest was shown to be concealed by a black bra that glistened with water. As she took more steps out of the water, James could see some garters on her thighs, noticing they held some of her daggers.
How cliché.
He wanted to look away, but with the sight presented before him, James couldn't do that. Evelynn noticed this and could only giggle. Katarina finally walked out of the water, seemingly swaying her hips as she smiled at the man who was observing her body.
"What is going on here?" He asked Evelynn who cooed.
"Aw, don't you get it love? This is your birthday present!" She squealed.
"Katarina in a bathing suit?" He asked.
"Not exactly." A voice said behind him.
James turned around to see his friend and fellow soldier Riven, standing in an outfit that immediately made his eyes widen, heat rushing to his cheeks.
She was in a white off-the-shoulder-bikini with bottoms of the same color, though it was wrapped in a green beach skirt with half of her alluring legs exposed, allowing James to see parts of the skimpy clothing form around her figure. He could've sworn he felt blood leaking from his nose as he couldn't break away from the woman who soon blushed as well. Evelynn laughed at this, getting off the chair and putting her arms around Riven and James, the lashers scooping up Katarina who yelped at this.
"Oh James, you may be an inventor, but you're still completely oblivious to the most obvious things." Evelynn cooed.
"It's your birthday James!" Katarina exclaimed. "And given that we're your friends, we chose to think of the perfect gift for you, with Evelynn's help and permission of course."
"The hell do you mean by permission?" James asked.
The Sinister Blade exchanged a look with Evelynn, as if asking for her permission, the succubus actually giving her an exasperated expression. James raised a brow at this before feeling a hand snake under his shirt, looking at Evelynn with the expectation that she was doing it, but she wasn't.
It was Katarina's hand.
And he felt her mouth along his exposed neck, peppering his skin in kisses and small nibbles.
James wasn't sure what to do. He felt frozen and didn't know why he wouldn't go into full defense mode when he felt Riven's hand on his Katarina-free side. However, she was much more, well respectful and careful than Katarina who started to lick him greedily, finding herself losing control and falling down into the hole of a primitive mind.
Riven looked at him with furrowed brows and vulnerable eyes that he'd never seen on her. She leaned to his neck, planting a soft kiss on it, followed with nibbling and sucking. The taste of him, even if it wasn't his mouth, drove Riven insane, and she also found herself soon acting like Katarina.
"What… is… the… meaning of… this." James said trying to restrain himself from letting out any form of affection.
"Oh shut up Holland." Katarina said breathlessly as she tangled her fingers into his hair, still attacking his neck with ravenous kisses. "Originally this was going to be Riven's gift to you, but Evelynn had other plans and if it wasn't you… I'd have never agreed to it."
"Wait Riven you planne-?!"
"Enough talking James love!" Evelynn interrupted. "You'll be happy to know that I gave them full permission to do whatever they'd want and I won't feel hurt in the slightest if you return it with equal passion. I'll be leaving you alone with them for the remainder of the day so I suggest you make the most of it!"
"Oh don't worry Evelynn, we will." Katarina said with a wicked grin.
"Just don't make him too sore!" Evelynn said walking away. "I still want to ride that thing in the future!"
The succubus disappeared and left the three of them alone, Riven and Katarina having stopped their actions on the man trapped between them. He sighed and broke away from them, Riven furrowing her brows as she bit her lip. Katarina, on the other hand, was the exact opposite, ignoring James's obvious conflicted emotions and strutted towards him.
"No, no, no." He said putting his hand out.
The redhead rolled her eyes, taking James's hand and pressing it between her breasts. He tried to retreat so she grabbed his arm with her other hand.
"Come on Holland, you have no idea how much trouble Evelynn went through to give you this gift."
"How can you be so casual about this?!" James exclaimed. "I've known you two for a long time and I like you guys, but I can't do this! I don't want to do this!"
"Is that why you let me and Riven have our way with you like 30 seconds ago?" Katarina asked smirking. "Not to mention you haven't tried to get your hand off my chest despite being able to easily bypass my grip."
James grunted angrily and freed himself from Katarina who chuckled. He glared at the redhead and turned his attention to Riven who rubbed her right arm, her red eyes occasionally meeting his before looking away. She was embarrassed.
"Riven, did you really want this to happen?" James asked. "Did you really come up with this idea?"
The girl kept rubbing her arm, but she looked at him with defiance. "Well, I didn't intend for Katarina to join in! I just wanted it to be me and you! I talked to Evelynn about it!"
"Riven…" James said pinching the bridge of his nose. "You of all people should know my position on this. I'm not the type of guy who likes to swing around."
"Should've thought of that before you got into a relationship with a lust demon." Katarina snickered.
James groaned at the assassin and walked to Riven. "Can we talk about this inside?"
She nodded and followed him inside. Katarina scoffed at him not including her so she stood directly outside of the sliding door, keeping her full attention on James and Riven who sat on the edge of the bed. James couldn't look at Riven who felt hurt by this. To her, it felt like her whole world was crashing down, her relationship with James deteriorating at a rapid pace.
"Why would you do this?" He asked. "Why in the world would you want this?"
"Because… well… let's face it I'm just a fucking idiot." Riven said grimly.
"No. No." James said annoyed. "Nobody plans her friends birthday gift with his girlfriend to be his two closest friends having sex with him knowing that he wouldn't agree to it and then just calls themselves stupid afterward. You had something else that motivated you. What was it?"
Riven gulped loudly, her breathing shaky from James's tone of voice. He usually wasn't an angry person, but when he was, Riven felt terrified.
"James… you know that I have feelings for you." She said solemnly. He offered no response. "We've known one another for a long time, and I've been holding it in for most of that. But sometimes… a person just can't hold it anymore, and needs to let it out."
James took a deep breath. His hands buried themselves into the mattress as he sighed afterward. "Riven, I can understand that feeling, but sometimes, people aren't meant to even get that close to one another. Some people are just destined to be frie-"
"I love you."
The man stopped his words when he heard that. He slowly looked at Riven whose face was a tomato. He narrowed his eyes at her. For a brief moment, his heart fluttered at her words, but it quickly disappeared.
"What?"
"I said I love you."
He buried his face into his hands, groaning with frustration and confliction. Riven didn't look at him, but her lips quivered as her eyes began to glisten slightly. James heard this and peeked out at his friend. He took in her emotions right now, seeing just how hurt she was by his actions.
It'd taken all of her willpower to say that, and while James still found it to be annoying that she came up with such a perverted gift, he felt bad for making her feel this way. James knew Riven all too well and figured that she had a feeling he wouldn't go through with this, but despite all of that, she still took action.
This made him wonder if she'd reached the point of where she desired him so much that she'd be able to keep herself from flat-out destroying their friendship. Riven seemed like she'd gone all in with this gift and while Katarina certainly wasn't planned to be involved, she took the risk anyway.
Riven felt his hand entwine with hers, the girl gasping with glistening eyes at his touch. James's other hand trapped hers in his and Riven looked into his eyes.
"Do you really mean that?" He asked.
His tone had a hint of acceptance and it made Riven feel a jolt of hope spark inside her. She nodded and James sighed.
"Riven, regarding your words a minute ago, you are most certainly an idiot for thinking I'd go through with this thing." James said with a chuckle. Riven blushed again. She felt James's hand move around to her neck and he pulled her closer. "But it seems like you thought about this long and hard. You knew this could've jeopardized our relationship, but it was before things got too beyond your control and urge, yes?"
She nodded again. James looked away with a smirk that showed he couldn't believe he was doing this. He chuckled and soon cupped Riven's cheek with his hands. Her crimson eyes widened and she felt something ignite within her core.
"If this is what you want to give me for my birthday Riven, then I guess I should accept the gift." James said with a hint of defeat. "But please… don't expect this to be a very common or regular occurrence. Just maybe a one-time thing."
Riven's eyes lit up with excitement and her mouth gaped. James chose to release his hands from her, but after that, she turned into an animal and tackled him off the bed, landing on the carpet with a thud. Immediately, he found himself smothered by her lips, hands roaming down to the buttons of his tropical shirt and ripping it open with a few buttons flying.
James was surprised by Riven's sudden actions. He figured he was correct on her holding it in for presumed years. He felt her trace her hands all over his exposed abs like it was a dotted map. The man finally chose to take action, given that he was a Commander after all. Riven hadn't even tried to kiss him on the lips and James grabbed her head, bringing it up to his level as she saw a primal hunger in her eyes.
"I don't appreciate you ripping my shirt open like that." He said.
He pulled her down where they met in a passionate and tense kiss. Riven could taste James after so many years and it drove her mad. Her hands dug themselves into his back, not letting him break away as she began to moan. Riven had straddled herself onto James who chose to sit up, bringing the kiss to an abrupt end.
"If we're going to do this Riven… I feel like there's something I must do first." He said with a hint of solemn.
Riven furrowed her brows and put her hands on his shoulders. "What do you mean?" She asked.
James gave a brief look down at her legs before looking at her again. Riven realized what he meant and blushed immediately. James closed the distance as he kissed her, Riven whimpering pitifully at his taste. She felt his arms wrap around her back and James lifted her up as their lips stayed connected. James placed Riven on the bed where he chose to abandon the kiss, choosing to go lower to the nape of her neck and planting gentle kisses on it. Riven, lost in her own lust, grinded her hips gently against his as he kept kissing her. She could feel heat flood her body, soon going down to her loins where it started to build up.
With the girl on the bed, James moved down to her waistline, undoing the skirt obstructing her figure and afterward, he saw a minor damp spot on her bikini bottoms. James raised a brow at this while Riven looked away with shame. He roughly grabbed her head, Riven looking at him with surprise before he mashed his lips into hers again. She felt herself melting away at his slightly aggressive action, her hands moving down to her top to undue it.
"Riven…" He whispered. "If you want me to stop… I will."
The warrior felt a greater flame ignite inside her, and she laid back on the bed. Her fingers curled around the rails of the headboard, and she spread her legs in a mute, unmistakable invitation to the man before her. Riven felt a tongue on her womanhood, and she couldn't stop a gasp from escaping her at the gentle touch of his tongue. So long she'd dreamed about this, and it was finally happening.
"James…" She moaned.
He curled one hand around her hip but not for long, as Riven took one hand off the headboard, entwined her fingers in his, and clung to it with all her might as she lost herself in desire. His tongue exploring her folds made Riven's mind go numb to the point where she couldn't remember her own name. Her body went limp at this point, letting James's actions wash all over her body. His tongue wriggled inside her lower, inner lips as Riven curled her toes.
Sensing that she enjoyed this motion, James licked eagerly into Riven who actually bit her fist as her moans became pitiful. She made sounds she never imagined she could make, but James proved otherwise.
"You taste good Riven." He said. "I could probably do this all night long."
"OH JAMES!" She shrieked.
James smiled to himself and licked, rubbed and ate the girl all the more. Little did he know Riven was near her pinnacle of pleasure. The intensity increased with every rub, every stroke of the tongue, and every breath from his warm wet mouth. Riven, despite having done this a few times beforehand, had no idea what was happening. At first, she felt she was going to die, but the satisfaction soon overpowered her fear and she didn't care, just as long as this feeling would never end.
James removed his hand and started from the bottom of Riven's lips with his tongue one more time. As he reached up to Riven's breasts, the pressure burst. Riven's legs involuntarily clamped down on the man's neck and warm, wet splashes doused James's face. The man was trapped for what felt like hours, but it was only a minute before Riven finally regained her strength and released James from the makeshift prison.
"Riven?" He asked. James got no response. "Hey Riven, you alright?"
"Oh James…" She said weakly.
"Are you okay?"
Riven laughed gently. "Yeah… never better."
"Well, you don't look okay." James said slightly concerned. "You look like you could use some rest."
The girl was absolutely exhausted, which made her feel a bit shameful. She had a lot of tenacity, but it seems like that faded away when James's tongue explored her, but she also refused to rest. She chose to do the next best thing. "I could really use… a nice, hot bath."
James chuckled at the unexpected choice, but he chose to oblige. He gently lifted Riven up, using the skirt he undid to cover her exposed bottom. He carried her to the bathroom, setting her down briefly as he reached for the faucet, turning on the water. After a few moments, James closed down the stopper when deeming the water to be warm enough. He picked up Riven and set her into the tub that began to fill up with water. She moaned on contentment at the warm feeling, resting her body fully as she undid her top and threw it aside. She weakly looked at James.
"Won't you join me?" She asked, using a soft tone she deemed to be seductive.
James chuckled at this. "Not quite. You need to regain your strength Riven. I'm not gonna take advantage of a person who's exhausted."
"All the more reason as to why I'm attracted to you." She cooed. "Even though I gave you permission."
He scoffed, giving her a friendly smile before choosing to leave Riven alone in the bathroom. She further sunk into the water, relishing at the comfortable feeling.
When stepping away from the door, James suddenly felt himself bump into another person and found himself face to face with a mischievous looking Katarina.
"What the hell are y-?!"
James's words abruptly stopped when the redhead grabbed his groin that was concealed by his shorts.
"Well Holland, you've succeeded in making Riven feel pleasure I can only assume she's dreamed off for years." Katarina said. "Quite a good show I might add."
"You saw the whole thing?!" James exclaimed.
"I was literally right there in the sliding door!" Katarina snorted. "Did you both forget about my presence, or were you so enveloped in pleasing her that you didn't have a care in the world?"
James grumbled and offered no response. Katarina hummed at this.
"Where is she now?"
The running water from the bathroom answered the question and Katarina raised a suggestive brow at this.
"Well then… I think I know where this gift will begin." She snickered.
"There is no way in hell I am go-!"
The redhead's grip tightened drastically and James croaked. Delighting at her hold on him, Katarina led James into the bathroom where Riven was seemingly asleep in the warm tub.
"It's time for the real gift to begin." Katarina snickered before closing the door and locking it.
We got more on the way. Doesn't end here by a long shot ;)