Hi there! This story is a bit AU, so you need a bit of background information.
Jessie is a lot more evil.
Santana and Finn never slept with each other. Rachel kissed Puck, so Finchel broke up.
The reason she kissed him, was that Jessie forced her to. If she didn't, he would have hurt Finn.
Matt also never left.
Don't hate me, but this is Artie/Brittany and Santana/Matt. I love Brittana, but here they're only best friends, who kiss each other sometimes (a lot…)
I DON'T OWN GLEE
Set between ''sexy'' and ''original'' song.
Rachel was baking a pie with Mercedes and Kurt in her kitchen. Her dads were on a business trip for the weekend, and she was going to have a sleepover-weekend for ND. No alcohol this time.
'' When are they supposed to be here?'' Kurt asked.
''In a minute,'' Rachel answered as the doorbell rang.
It was Blaine, Puck, Artie, Matt, Mike, Sam and Finn; they all had different kinds of snacks with them.
''Hi guys!'' Mercedes said and the doorbell rang again.
This time it was Tina, Santana, Brittany, Lauren and Quinn, they brought the sodas
''Hello ladies,'' Puck said.
''Time for some rules…'' Rachel begun, but the others just sighed.
''The only rule is no Alcohol,'' she said.
They started the party with the pie, so everyone was happy.
''I think it's time for a game,'' Puck said at the point everyone had eaten.
''What game?'' Rachel asked quickly.
''Truth or dare!'' Quinn yelled.
''Sure,'' Rachel said.
They sat in a ring at the floor in Rachel's basement.
''Who's going to start?'' Tina asked.
''I'll do,'' Mercedes answered. ''Rachel, truth or dare?''
''Truth,'' Rachel said.
''Why did you stop upload videos on MySpace?''
''Because someone gave me some comments that wasn't too nice,'' Rachel murmured.
''Who?'' Finn asked.
''Just one question a truth,'' Rachel said, but he could see her looking quickly at Quinn.
''Anyways, it's your turn Rachel,'' Mercedes said.
''Well, Puck, truth or…?''
''Dare,'' he answered, he was no coward.
''Make out with Quinn,'' she said.
''What!'' both of them screamed.
''Go for it Puckerman, we're not together you know,'' Lauren said.
''Same thing,'' Finn said to Quinn.
''But…'' Quinn started, but Puck's lips cut her off.
''Get some room!'' Santana yelled at them, and threw a pillow in their way.
Both of them blushed.
''Right…Artie, truth or dare?''
''Truth,''
''How far have you and Brittany…''
''All the way,'' Brittany said, and kissed Artie, who was red as a tomato.
''Mike, truth or dare?''
''Dare,''
''Kiss Sam,''
''Hell no!'' Both Sam and Mike screamed.
''Well that, or eat a teaspoon wasabi,'' Artie said, laughing.
''Argh,'' Mike said and kissed Sam's finger. ''You never said where.''
''Santana, truth or dare?''
''Truth,''
''Are you and Sam together?''
''No,''
''Lauren?'' Santana asked.
''Dare,'' Lauren Zizes was a badass-girl.
'' Record a video when you sing ''I'm a little teapot'' and post it on YouTube,'' Santana said evilly.
''You're going to pay for this,'' Lauren said.
Everyone was laughing while she recorded the video.
''Fabray! Truth or dare?'' Lauren shouted.
''Dare,''
''Strip down to your underwear and sit in Puckerman's knee for the rest of the game.
''But…''
''Or eat the wasabi…'' Lauren begun.
''Ok, ok, I'll do it.'' Quinn said. She felt super embarrassed, but she did it.
''Sam, truth or dare?''
''Truth,''
''Who are you in love with?''
''Mercedes,'' he said, and before anyone else reacted, Mercedes kissed him.
''Hm, Tina?'' he asked after a minute.
''Dare,'' she answered.
''Make out with a fish for two minutes,'' he smirked.
''Rachel's vegan…'' Tina begun.
''I've got fish in the fridge,'' Rachel said, smiling, and went out to get the fish.
''Oh,'' Tina sighed and took the fish.
''We're waiting,'' Puck said.
Tina started to make out with the fish, and Sam laughed so hard he could barley breath. Tina threw the fish at him.
''Mercedes, truth or dare?'' Tina asked.
''Truth,'' Mercedes answered.
''Would you rather kiss Karofski or Azimio?''
''Azimio,'' Mercedes said. ''Finn, truth or dare?''
''Dare.''
''Redo ''push it'' with Rachel,'' Mercedes giggled.
''The whole song!'' Rachel and Finn screamed/asked.
''Yeah, the whole song,'' Mercedes said.
Ah Push it
Ah Push it
Get up on this!
Ooh baby baby
b-baby baby
ooh baby baby
b-baby baby
Get up on this!
Ah Push it
Hey!
Get up on this!
Ah push it
Get up on this!
Salt salt salt salt and peppas here
Get up on this!
F-f-f-f-f-finn and Rachel's here!
Now wait a minute, y'all
Now this dance ain't for everybody
Only the sexy people
So all you fly mothers, get on out there and dance
Dance, I said!
F-Finn and Rachel's here, and we're in effect
Want you to push it, babe
Coolin' by day then at night working up a sweat
C'mon Finn, let's go show the guys that we know
How to become number one in a hot party show
Now push it
Ah push it - push it good
Ah push it - push it real good
Ah push it - push it good
Ah push it - p-push it real good
Ah push it
Get up on this!
Hey!
Get up on this!
Yo Rachel-pop
Yeah, you come here, gimme a kiss
Better make it fast or else I'm gonna get pissed
Can't you hear the music's pumpin' hard like I wish you would?
Now push it
Ah push it - push it good
Ah push it - push it real good
Ah push it - push it good
Ah push it - p-push it real good
Ah push it
Get up on this!
Ah Push it
Get up on this
Ow!
Holla!
Get up on this!
Ah push it
Hey!
Ah push it!
Ooh baby baby
b-baby baby
Ooh baby baby
b-baby baby
Ah you really got me going
You got me so I dont know what im doing
Ooh baby baby
b-baby baby
Ooh baby baby
b-baby baby
Ah you really got me going
You got me so I dont know what im doing
Ah push it - push it good
Ah push it - push it real good
Ah push it - push it good
Ah push it - p-push it real good
Ah push it
Get up on this!
Ah Push it
Get up on this
Ow!
Holla!
Get up on this!
Ah push it
Hey!
Ah push it!
When they where done the other glee members where laughing so much that Finn and Rachel begun to laugh just because they looked so funny.
''Okay, back to the game, Rachel truth or dare?'' Finn asked.
''Truth,'' she answered, looking down.
''Why did you kiss Puck?''
''Because Jesse forced me too, otherwise he would hurt you and… oh no I've said too much,'' Rachel pressed her hands against her mouth and run up the stairs crying.
''Rachel!'' Mercedes cried after her.
Finn ran after her.
He found her in the laundry room, crying.
''Rachel…''
''Don't you hate me?'' Rachel asked.
''I never did, but why didn't you tell me about Jessie,'' Finn asked as he held her in his arms.
''He's going to hurt you, he's going to kill you,'' Rachel said.
''He can't, he's like 5'8 and he's pretty scrawny,'' Finn said calmly.
''But he scares me,'' Rachel whispered.
''You have nothing to be scared off, and I actually deserves to get hurt after what I did to you,'' Finn said, rubbing her back.
''You didn't do anything wrong, I cheated on you with Puck, just like Quinn did,'' she said guilty.
''No, you didn't. Quinn had sex with Puck and got pregnant, and told me that I was the father, everyone knew it was Puck except you, and when you figured it out you told me.
You kissed Puck and told me right after, and you did it to protect me from Jessie. I forgave her but not you.'' Finn said, looking away.
''You'll always forgive your first love,'' Rachel said.
''I never loved her, that's why I could forgive her,'' Finn said,'' Let's get back to de others.''
They came in to a completely silent room.
''Well, shall we play never have I never?'' Mercedes said, breaking the silent for the fist time since Finn and Rachel left.
''Ok,'' Everybody said at the same time, but Puck said it a little bit louder.
''But Blaine didn't do any truth or dare,'' Kurt said.
''Well ok, Blaine truth or dare?'' Rachel said.
''Dare,''
''Let Kurt put make up on you tomorrow,'' Rachel smirked.
Blaine sighed as everyone else just laughed and went to the kitchen for playing never have I nerver.
