Disclaimer: I do not own Glee or the songs included in the fanfiction :)

"Fine then! We're better than through. Don't ever speak to me again!"

…

"If I could have rewound that moment, I'd have tried to stop it. Tried to stop him from saying it, from all the tears I've cried. Over one boy, but not just any boy… Blaine Anderson. My first love. My true love. My only love. Most of all the love that I almost let slip away."

Forever and For Always: Part. 1

The One That Got Away

"All right guys!" Mr. Schuester stood at the front of the choir room, attempting to get the attention of his Glee club. "Guys!" The chattered slowly died down and Will proceeded "This week you guys will be working together. That's right duets! This means no arguments guys."

"But Mr. Shue, we do that every year." Tina pointed out.

"This year there's a theme. The theme for this year, drumroll please, Dreams."

"Mr. Shue, if I may." Rachel's confident, "better than you" tone rung out "But what exactly do you mean by dreams?"

"Glad you asked Rachel." Mr. Schuester grinned mischievously "hit it!" The sound Rockstar by Nickleback filled the room.

"Hey, Hey. I want to be a rock star." He finished the song and the group applauded.

"Mr. Shue I still don't understand." Finn said slowly.

"Dreams can be anything. They can be from something you want to be, to something you want to have, or somewhere you want to go." Will explained. "It's like you wanting to get into NYADA Rachel, or Artie wanting to walk. Dreams are what you make them. This is an important year for most of you, and your starting to think about your hopes and ambitions for life." Mr. Schuester pulled out an envelope from his pocket. "Plus the winner this year gets tickets to the Cirque du Soleil performance that's playing in the next town over."

"Those tickets are as good as ours." Rachel told Finn.

"Don't bet on it Rachel." Kurt told her, looking at Blaine lovingly.

"All right guys. I expect amazing performances from all of you." With Mr. Schuester's final words the New Directions filed out of the room.

"We've got this completion all wrapped up." Blaine told Kurt, as he got in Kurt's car.

Kurt nodded, in agreement "We just have to find the perfect song."

…

Kurt and Blaine stood in the middle of the McKinley High Auditorium staring into each other's eyes. They were singing a mash up of A Whole New World and I Can Go the Distance.

"Down an unknown road /to embrace my fate/ though that road may wander / It will lead me to you/" Kurt sang and Blaine continued with "And a thousand years/ would be worth the wait/ It might take a lifetime / But somehow I'll see it through" Then the chorus' became intertwined as Blaine continued with "And I won't look back /I can go the distance /And I'll stay on track /No I won't accept defeat /It's an uphill slope /But I won't lose hope /Till I go the distance /And my journey is complete" And Kurt sang "A whole new world/A hundred thousand things to see/I'm like a shooting star/I've come so far/I can't go back to where I used to be." They ended the song together singing the last line from Whole New World, staring lovingly into each other's eyes.

"Let's take it from the top again." Blaine said breaking the connection.

"Come on Blaine!" Kurt complained "We've done it like a zillion times."

"I'm sorry," Blaine said sincerely, smiling apologetically "I just really want to take you to that show."

Kurt blushed and smiled happily "Well Cirque du Soleil is no Broadway show but it would be fun to see, something to do together. We only have a limited amount of time before graduation."

"You know, I kind of hope you don't get into NYADA this year. " Blaine sighed.

"What do you mean you kind of hope I don't get into NYADA this year Blaine?" Kurt said, looking confused.

"I mean, I just hate to have you so far away. Couldn't it just wait a year?" Blaine asked, looking at Kurt who couldn't believe Blaine wanted him to wait on something he'd dreamed about.

"Blaine, what happens if the opportunity presents itself now? There may not be another opportunity like that. I can't stay in Lima forever, you know how I feel." Kurt told Blaine, feeling like Blaine was being selfish asking for him to wait.

"Kurt, everything doesn't' always work out perfectly in the world outside of Lima." Blaine said, feeling that Kurt was getting the wrong impression.

"So you don't think I could handle it?" Kurt asked, his tone starting to sound annoyed. "Do you think I wouldn't make it?"

"Come on Kurt!" Blaine said "Open your eyes, you're so sheltered and you're not Rachel."

"Oh I get it!" Kurt's voice rose "So I'm not good enough."

"That's not what I meant!"

"Yes it is! You're scared I won't make it… or are you scared I'll make it and forget you?" Kurt's voice sounded cold, challenging, and at that moment Blaine started to feel himself getting mad.

"You couldn't even win class president, Kurt or play the lead in the play." Blaine said briskly.

"Oh so you want to go there?" Kurt yelled at Blaine.

"Maybe I do!" Blaine shouted back!"

"Oh and you're so perfect. Mr. I was head of the Warblers, but I was too good for them!"

"When did I ever say that? At least I don't run from my problems!"

"Take that back Blaine!"

"Never!"

"You know you were way cuter in a Dalton uniform." Kurt scowled and turn away.

"You know that's it Kurt! I can't deal with you being such a drama queen anymore. It's done okay, we're through!" Blaine's words flew out of his mouth hitting Kurt like daggers to the heart. Kurt felt himself tear up and he kept thinking that this can't be happening. Finally Kurt opened his mouth and retaliated. "Fine! We're better than through. Don't ever speak to me again!"

He couldn't believe what he'd said, nor what Blaine had said before. Covering his mouth, Kurt ran backstage crying, sitting on a makeup chair and staring at himself in the mirror. He started sobbing harder as he heard Blaine stomp out of the auditorium, slamming the door behind him. Between fits of tears Kurt sang softly to himself

"In another life/I would make you stay/ So I don't have to say/ You were the one that got away/ The one that got away/ The o-o-o-o-o-one/ The o-o-o-o-o-one/ The o-o-o-o-o-one/ The one that got away…"

A/N: This is my first story so I'd love if you could favourite/review it :D