Disclaimer, I don't own the show, or any of its characters...

Summary: What if Pheobe had died instead of Prue? What if Prue had to face what she had been feeling for some time...? What if Pheobe was sent back to them? What if Cole had found someone else?

well thats what we are going to find out! lol

Chapter 1, Remembering....

Piper turned to Prue, they had an uneasy feeling that someone was coming then as they both turned they saw Shaxs appear

"PHEOBE!" Prue called, no answer "PHEOBE!" Still no answer

Prue looked shax in the eye, Shax just grinned slowly then send a whirlball at her and she went crashing into the wall, then using his other hand he let out another whirlball and sent Piper crashing into the other wall then dissappeared

Leo upon orbing in was shocked, there was mess everywhere! then walking as he walked slowly his face went from curisouty to pure terror as he saw his wife and sister in law on the floor, covered in debri, and bleeding

"PIper!" He uttered as he knealt beside her and started healing her, when he was sure she was ok he turned to Prue and started to heal her too

After they both came round Piper turned to Prue and hugged her tightly "Prue..." was all she could mutter, she didnt know what she would have done if she lost her sister

Prue meanwhile stood up and looked at Leo "Wheres Phoebe?"

Leo looked at Prue and was about to answer when Cole came walking into the foyer carrying what looked like Pheobe in his arms

"no..." Prue shock her head slowly as she saw Coles tear streaked face, her worst nightmare had come true, Pheobe was dead "no!" She said more firmly as if to prove something, PHoebe wasnt dead! it just couldnt be true!

Piper meanwhile walked forward with tears running down her face then checked PHeobes pulse, after a few seconds she burst into tears, Leo stepped forward to comfort her

Prue just looked from Cole, to Piper, to Leo then back at Pheobe again "NO!" She walked over to her and pulled her by the front of her top "WAKE UP!" SHe shouted at Pheobe "WAKE UP!"

Cole pulled Pheobe away from Pure and put her down, then tried to comfort Prue, Prue just pulled away from COle, she didnt want to get too close, she didnt was to let him know "Pheobe..." She whisperes as she let her tears take over her and finally allowed Cole to comfort her....

Piper gasped as she sat up suddenly, she had been having that dream for the past couple of weeks, it was like they were trying to tell her something.

Later that morning after dressing etc, Piper walked into the bathroom and watched her sister make coffee. Breathing deeply she wondered what she would ever do without Prue...

"Hey!" Prue smiled as she looked at Piper, she worried about her sometimes but that was the duty of the elder sister "Did you sleep well?"

Piper smiled and nodded "Yup, slept like a baby...."

"ha, no you didnt, I heard you tossing and turning last night..." She poured her coffee out then sat down in front of her sister "So spill"

Piper sighed then told her sister what had happened, the dream that she had started to have again

"...and well, its started to bug me again..."

Prue sat back in her chair then finished off the rest of her coffee "Well...it seems to be that you are just anxious that its a year today that Pheobe..."SHe trailed off, she still couldnt say that PHeobe had died, she didnt want to but she had to..." PHeobe died..." She gave a involuntery shudder "so it might be expected..."

"morning all!" Cole smiled as he walked into the kitchen, Prue stiffened up immedatily

Piper spotting her sister hissed at her and whispered "Prue, stop it, he is good now!" Then smiling at Cole she made her excuses and left.

After Piper left there was an uncomfortable silence in the kitchen as Cole and Prue nether spoke or looked at each other.

A few painful minutes later Prue muttered something then moved toward the door but Cole stopped her

"Prue, we need to talk..."

"About what!" Prue said shaking his arm off hers, if truth be told she liked his arm there, everytime he was near her she felt weak at the knees, but she never did anything he was in love with Phoebe!

Cole inched his face closer to hers "About us...."

"THere is no us..." Prue snarled back rather nastly, she hated it but she had to say something to back Cole off...

But Cole just looked at her, trying to find something in her expression that told him otherwise, he was aware of his own beating heartbeat that just wouldnt calm down, he smiled softly, Prue sure knew how to drive him wild, then without neither of them knowing it they were kissing passionatly, they were kissing each other with such a force they thought they would explode, then without another sound Cole shimmered out of the kitchen

"Prue could you..." Piper looked around the emtpy kitchen

"Hm....i guess she must of left early..." Then after taking an apple she walked into the living room