Smack
Summary: What if, thinking Jimmy was dead anyway, Abby jumped off the cliff in episode 13 to escape Henry and the horrors of Harper's Island that haunted her?
A/N: There will probably be two or three chapters to this story. This one is Abby's POV, the next will be Jimmy's POV after Abby dies, and the third and (maybe) last will be Henry's.
"This makes sense? You destroyed everything I ever loved."
"But you have me!"
"I DON'T WANT YOU!" I screamed at him. I saw the look of hurt and shock run across Henry's face and took a step back.
I glanced behind him in hope of seeing Jimmy, free, ready to save me. Henry and I stood looking at each other before I finally made my descision. There was no hope that I would be happy with Henry. This wasn't the Henry I loved. This was a monster. The monster that killed my mother has reincarnated himself into my best friend's body, taking away anything good that was left in him. But at the same time, I couldn't help but to think: He did it all for me.
He killed all of my friends and family to be with me forever. Our childhood dream. But I wouldn't. If Henry didn't kill me if I stayed, the guilt surely would. But really, who were those people I caled my "Friends?" I hadn't seen them for 7 years. The only family I had was my father – who I'd hated, and now even he's dead. I couldn't bring myself to call or talk to anyone else, and they all eventually moved on, while I stayed in the repeating nightmare of John Wakefield.
Well, everyone except Henry. I stared into the dark eyes that were so similar to mine – because they were our mother's eyes and stole one last look behind Henry, now knowing Jimmy wouldn't make it out. Henry was going to kill him to be with me.
But he won't have me. Looking diliberately into Henry's eyes, I took one step back.
Henry, who's face was twisted in hurt and fury, now had shock and desperation on his features.
"Abby," He said softly. "Don't."
I looked behind me, careful not to fall over the cliff. If I jumped far enough out, I could hit the water.
Then he couldn't have me.
"Abby, please."
"No, Henry." I said.
I took a deep breath and jumped backwards.
"ABBY!" I heard Jimmy's voice suddenly right before I landed on the water with a smack and gasped, filling my lungs with water.
It's okay, Jimmy. I thought. I'm sorry I had to do this to you.
And to Henry: Now it's just you. Alone. Forever.
And I closed my eyes.