As Rachel walked into the choir room she saw Noah Puckerman her current boyfriend, school badass besides her when she was drunk, football player, and guitar god kissing Quinn Fabray head cheerleader and school slut and she screamed and ran out. She knew they were taking a break from their relationship but how could he not be fazed by it. "You know he would've cheated on you one day." Santana said
"It was that stupid fight we had last night." Rachel said with tears remembering the night before
Flash Back:
"You will never change." The petite girl yelled with tears
"Why cause I'm a guy and can't be tied down. We need a break." He yelled back and she tried to stop him by grabbing his hand but he wouldn't let her and walked out of her room. She cried that whole night and frowned.
Flash Back Over:
"Hun, at least it he didn't sleep with her again." The Latina shook her head
"You don't know him like me we've been in each other's lives since we were 3." The petite girl walked back into the choir room she was determined to sing a song that expressed her feelings right now so she raised her hand when Mr. Shuester came in. "Mr. Shue can I sing a song before we start." Rachel asked as the teacher nodded and she gave Brad the Piano Man the sheet music and he started:
Ohh, ohh
So much for my happy ending
Ohh, ohh
So much for my happy ending
ohh, ohh,ohhhh
Let's talk this over
It's not like we're dead
Was it something I did?
Was it something you said?
Don't leave me hangin'
In a city so dead.
Held up so high
On such a breakable thread
You were all the things I thought I knew
And I thought we could be
You were everything, everything
That I wanted,(that I wanted)
We were meant to be, supposed to be
But we lost it (we lost it)
All of the memories so close to me
Just fade away
All this time you were pretending
So much for my happy ending
ohh, ohh,
So much for my happy ending
Ohh ohh
You've got your dumb friends
I know what they say (they say)
They tell you I'm difficult
But so are they (But so are they)
But they don't know me
Do they even know you?(even know you?)
All the things you hide from me
All the shit that you do (all the shit that you do)
You were all the things I thought I knew
And I thought we could be
You were everything, everything
That I wanted (that I wanted)
We were meant to be, supposed to be
But we lost it (we lost it)
All of the memories so close to me
Just fade away
All this time you were pretending
So much for my happy ending
It's nice to know that you were there
Thanks for acting like you care
And making me feel like I was the only one
It's nice to know we had it all
Thanks for watching as I fall
And letting me know we were done
He was everything, everything
That I wanted
We were meant to be, supposed to be
But we lost it
All of the memories so close to me
Just fade away
All this time you were pretending
So much for my happy ending
You were everything, everything
That I wanted (that I wanted)
We were meant to be, supposed to be
But we lost it
All of the memories so close to me
Just fade away
All this time you were pretending
So much for my happy ending
ohh ohh ohh ohh
So much for my happy ending
ohh ohh ohh ohh
So much for my happy ending
ohh, ohh, ohh, ohhhhh
As she finished she had tears in her eyes and so did Puck so she sat down. Then as soon as everyone left Rachel was about to leave but Puck grabbed her hand. "Let me go." She said
"No." He smirked as she turned around.
"Ugh what do you want Puck?" she looked annoyed
"Puck?"
"Yes what everyone calls you."
"When were you everyone Rachel?"
"When you decided to blow me off for basketball then to the slut's house to make out with her."
"I'm." she cut him off
"Sorry like you always are right."
"Forgive me I know I was an idiot choosing a basket ball game over you last night then telling you if you wanna be with me you have to except I might flirt with other girls and even sleep with them." She had tears remembering everything.
"I guess we can have a happy ending. She kissed him and knew they still had a good few years in this relationship.
Puckleberry forever I thought of this story after my best friend telling me how her and her boyfriend borke up then got back together after her singing this song and they worked on their relationship. Go Puckleberry!