They'd all decided to meet at Fins. His house was big and could easily be used for the entertainment tonight. Olivia and Elliot had worked on a hard case where Casey Novak was their lawyer. The convicted a man of 12 rapes, 2 double homicide, and murder in the 1st degree. The man also held Olivia hostage while him and Elliot duked it out. Elliot had gotten over him and knocked him out.
Olivia had pulled up to Fin's apartment in Queen, not too far down the road from Elliot's apartment. She got out of her car and grabbed the beer she was supposed to bring. Olivia was wearing yoga pants, a pink under armor hoodie, and a pair of black and pink Nike shocks that Elliot had gotten her for her birthday one year.
Olivia knocked on Fins door, seconds later she sees Fin open it. Olivia walks in and sees everyone else there. "Sorry I'm a little late." She says smiling.
"No your just one time." Fin said taking the beer from her hands.
Elliot walks over to Olivia and grabs a beer. "You look great Liv." He smiles sexily at her.
"Thanks" She blushes a little bit.
"Is Olivia blushing?" Elliot smiled, picking on her.
"No." Olivia said looking away.
Olivia and Elliot walk over to the loveseat and sit next to each other, and start having a conversation about many different things.
Munch is sitting with Casey and they are talking about different conspiracies. While Melinda and Fin are in the kitchen, stealing kisses when no one is watching.
Melinda smiles as they walk into the living room. Her and fin sit on the chase lounge together snuggled up. He leans down and kisses her softly on the lips.
"Elliot! Porter is a great guy." Olivia said shocked that Elliot had just said that.
"Olivia he is gay. I'm telling you!" Elliot said laughing. "He was checking out my 'friend' in the bathroom!"
"El, he isn't gay." She say in a serious voice.
"Wait Liv, you aren't say-" Olivia cut him off before he could say any more.
"Lets just say that we went on a couple dates and he isn't gay." Olivia said looking away. Elliot didn't know what she meant. Did they have sex? Or just kiss. It bothered him that someone elses hands were on his Liv. His Olivia.
Meanwhile Casey and Munch have been dating for a while and things have gotten pretty heated. The two always went out to lunch or something.
Melinda and Fin had been dating for over 5 months now. They had agreed to take things slowly. That didn't last as long as they had planned because 2 months into the relationship they started doing more intimate things.
Their friends agreed that they should try to get Elliot and Olivia together. They were planning on making them something to show their feelings.
"Guys. I think we should play a game." Melinda said happily.
"Yeah. Truth or dare." Elliot said smiling. He had been eyeing Olivia up all night. Every time she walked anywhere his eyes were glued to her butt. It was like his heroin or cocaine. She was his addiction.
Everyone agree and they all moved to Fin's kitchen table where it had 6 spaces. It went, Olivia, Elliot, Fin, Melinda, Casey, and Munch around the table. "Well, Fin. You start us out. " Olivia said.
"Okay, Casey. Truth or dare?" Fin asked.
"Truth." Casey said, Munch's hand had slipped under the table and was resting on her knee. Elliot obviously had the same idea, but he set his hand on Olivia's upper thigh, drawing small circles with his thumb.
"How many guys have you had sex with?" Fin asked.
"3." She answered blushing red. "Elliot, truth or dare?"
"Dare." He smiled brightly. All that kept running through Olivia's mind was how good she felt when Elliot was rubbing her leg.
"I dare you to switch underwear with any player of your choice." Casey said smiling.
Elliot's smiled dropped. He knew he shouldn't have done dare. "Jeez. Fine, Liv, uh hope you are wearing some sexy undies." Olivia's face got bright red.
Both her and Elliot walked back to the bathroom where she slipped in first and took off her pants and underwear. Great, the day she chose to wear a pink g-string.
She handed Elliot her underwear and he handed her his. He was wearing plaid boxers so it wasn't that bad. Elliot had put on her underwear in the hallway where no one could see him. Jesus he thought to himself, he wished he could see her in these.
They walked out moments later walked out and Elliot pulled his wedgie. "How do we know if you guys switched?" Munch asked snickering.
Elliot grabbed the string of Olivias thong and snapped it. And she pulled his boxers out of the top of her pants. "Nice thong Liv." Fin snickered, earning a tongue sticking out from her.
They sat down with the group and continued the game. "Melinda truth or dare?" Elliot asked.
"Dare." She smiled evilly.
"I dare you to sit on Fin's lap for the next 5 minutes." He said. Melinda moved to his lap and snuggled into his chest.
"Okay. Olivia truth or dare." She asked.
"Uh dare."
"I dare you , to take the pizza boy and make out with him in the hall closet for 1 minute." Melinda smiled.
"Mel!" Olivia exclaimed.
"Dares a dare Livvy." She smiled.
Seconds later a knock was at the door. She looked into the peep hole and it was the pizza guy. "Its the pizza guy!" Olivia whispered.
"C'mon Liv." Olivia rolled her eyes. She adjusted her shirt to show cleavage and ruffled her hair in a sexy way.
"That will be 45.68" He boy said. He actually wasn't as bad as Olivia had thought. He had side swept hair and blue eyes, he was probably in his 20's.
"Here is the money, but I don't have enough for a tip." Olivia said innocently.
The pizza boy eyed her up and down. "I can think of another way you can tip me." Olivia smiled devilshy, and pulled the boy inside.
She opened the hall closet and pushed him in. Olivia looked at him for a moment then got close to his face, he grabbed the back of her head and pushed his lips onto her. There was no power in the kiss. The boy didn't waste any time on letting his hands roam around Olivia.
A small knock was on the door and Olivia broke away. "I gotta get back to the party." Olivia said.
She opened the door then the boy left. Olivia walked back over to the group, she hasn't realized that the boy had pulled her shirt up past her belly button. Everyone's eyes opened wide as they say something dangle down.
"Olivia Benson." Elliot said. "You have a belly button ring?"
Olivia pulled her shirt down. "No. I don't."
"Liar!" Casey exclaimed.
"Shut up!" Olivia said.
They all sat back down. Olivia knew she wasn't going to be able to get off the hook this easily. "Fin. Truth or dare?"
"Truth." He said rubbing Mels leg.
"What is the craziest thing you have ever done in the bedroom and who was it with." Olivia smiled.
"Well, Melinda took my cuffs and cuffed me to the bed. Then she sprayed whipped cream and and hershey syrup all over my chest and everywhere else, then licked it up." He looked at Melinda, who was bright red.
"Anyway. Munch, truth or dare?" Fin said laughing.
"Dare." He said laughing.
"I dare you to do a body shot." Fin smiles, Munch shakes his head and laughs as if it were easy. "Off Elliot."
Munchs face goes blank along with Elliot's. "What the hell Fin!" Elliot and Munch say at the same time.
"Dare is a dare." Fin says.
Munch grabs Elliot's arm and does the body shot quickly. "I hate you Fin." Munch says.
"Whatever." Fin laughs.
"Truth or dare, Melinda?" Munch says.
"Truth." She says.
"Have you ever faked an orgasm?" He asks.
"Yes, once." She says laughing."Olivia, truth or dare?"
"Me again? Fine, I pick dare." Olivia laughs.
"I dare you to kiss Elliot, actually scratch that. I dare you to full blown make out with Elliot." Melinda laughs.
"I hate you Mel." Olivia laughs.
Olivia avoids eye contact with Elliot. He grabs her hand and looks into her eyes. "Lets give them a show." He whispers into her ear. Everyone thinks that he is telling her something dirty to get her in the mood.
Olivia doesn't nod or say yes, because Elliot looks into her eyes and knows the answer.