Okay, so this fanfic takes place from the saw part. All the events before that part are just like the original game's story, except Sam and Ashley have a crush on each other, Chris went to take a bath instead of Sam (lol, wut?) and the spirit board scene happened between Josh, Sam and Ashley.

Sam started hearing screams. Those screams sounded like they were coming from Ashley.

"Ash?", said Sam

And she followed the screams. They led her to a large dark room. She couldn't see anything but she could hear Ashley screaming.

"Ash, I'm he-", Sam began to say but the lights quickly turned on, revealing Sam a horrific scene.

Ashley and Josh were tied up and there was a giant saw right in front of them, looking like it was going to tear one of them apart. Sam was so scared that she was unable to say a word. Finally a creepy voice from the ceiling broke Sam's silence:

"Hello, Samantha"

Sam turned around to see where the voice was coming from.

"Who?", asked Sam

The voice spoke again.

"I'd like to play a game with you"

"What?"

Sam tried to realize what was happening. But the voice interrupted her from her thoughts.

"You see what's going on in front of you, right?"

"What are you gonna do to them? Don't you dare hurt them",said Sam in an angry tone.

She couldn't hide the fear she felt though.

"Oh, don't worry", the voice replied "I'm not gonna hurt them. You are"

"What?"

"That's right. You'll have to choose to save one of them but kill the other one"

"I'm not gonna do this", she replied " I won't kill my friends"

"Too bad, you have no other choice. Now, choose who you want this saw to go to, or you're all going to die"

Sam remained quiet. She was thinking who to save. Both Josh and Ashley were pleading her to spare their lives. She didn't even want to think about losing Ashley, much more killing her, but she'd feel terrible killing Josh. He was a close friend of hers, he trusted her and he told her that she was the only one who knew how he felt after he lost his sisters. But Sam's mouth suddenly got a brain of its own and screamed with all its power:

"Ashley, I'll get you out of this. I won't let you die."

Then, Sam's arm also got a brain of its own and pulled the lever to Josh's photo. The saw began moving closer and closer to Josh and he started screaming. It was at this moment, Sam realized what she just did and immediately regretted that decision.

"Alright, Sam", said the voice "You chose to save Ashley. See you later"

And laughed evily and was no longer heard. Sam didn't pay attention to the voice. She was screaming to Josh:

"Josh, I'm sorry. I'm really really sorry. Please, forgive me"

Josh could not answer her. The saw came to him and torn his torso apart. Ashley was crying, seeing the terrible scene right next to her and feeling Josh's blood coming right to her face and clothes. The door opened and Sam ran to Ashley, untied her and took her out of the room, with tears in her eyes. They ran out of the lodge, both looking horrified and tearing up.

"Sam? Ash?"

They both turned their heads up and saw Matt and Emily looking at them with a concerned look on their faces.

"What happened? Why are you both looking so terrified? Ash, what's that blood all over you?", Matt and Emily asked them

They both broke down and started crying.

"There's a maniac in this mountain", said Sam in tears "And he...he caught Josh and Ashley and he...he t...tied the...them up and he had a gi...giant saw blade and he...he to...told me to choose who to save and I...I didn't know what to do"

"What?", said Matt "That's very serious"

"Indeed" Emily replied "Matt, we need to go find help, right now"

"No, you...you just want to save yourselves", said Ashley, being in tears as well

"That's not true", Emily answered her "I just don't want to make bad decisions that will get everyone of us killed"

"We need to find the others", said Matt "Do you girls have any idea where they are?"

"Mike and Jess will be fine, I guess", Emily replied "They went to spend some private time in a cabin. I don't really care much about them though"

"But Chris is still inside the lodge", said Sam "He might be in danger"

"Okay, here's what we're going to do", said Emily "You two go back in the lodge and find Chris. Matt and I are gonna go look for help. And if you have any way to inform Mike and Jess, then do it, so we can all stick together"

"Okay then", said Ashley "Sounds like a good plan"

"We'll see you later, girls", said Emily to both of them "Be safe and don't do anything stupid, okay? Come on, Matt"

"Bye, Sam. Bye, Ash", said Matt "See you later. Please be safe"

And with those words, they left the two girls and headed to the woods.

"I really don't want to go back in there, Sam", said Ashley "Especially now that we know how dangerous that psycho is"

"I know, Ash", Sam replied "But we need to do as Em said. Plus, Chris needs us right now. He might be in grave danger"

"You're right", said Ashley "But will we stay close to each other? I don't want to lose you, Sam"

"Okay", said Sam "I won't leave you alone, Ash. I promise"

And they walked back in the lodge to search for Chris.