This takes place after Extraordinary Merry Christmas (3x09) at Rachel's house. And Puckleberry got back together because Finn was being a douche to Rachel.
SamPOV
I walked into the Berry living room to see Rachel sitting on the couch.
"What happened at the soup kitchen?" she immediately asked.
"You were there."
"I meant before... when it was just you and Quinn there."
"If by what happened you mean something intimate, then nothing happened. We just talked," I explained.
"About what?"
"I told her that she deserves good things."
"That's it?" she looked disappointed "Okay. By the way my dads aren't home tonight and Puck is coming over. Just to warn you." I groaned loudly.
"Why are you just telling me this now? I would have called someone else and slept over at their house."
"Don't worry, we're not that loud. And I'm sure Quinn wouldn't have minded you sleeping over." What the hell is that supposed to mean? I walked into the guest room and started to get into my pajamas. Just as I was about to take off my boxers, I heard a noise. I looked over and saw Quinn on my bed in a Santa costume. Not a fat old man Santa costume. No way. It was a sexy Santa costume with a short skirt and no sleeves.
"Hey," she said. She grabbed me and pulled me on top of her. She grabbed my face to kiss me but I stopped her.
"Stop."
"But it's Christmas. At Christmas you give to the needy. Can't you give to me what I needy?" She gave me her puppy dog pout.
"You're doing it again."
"Doing what?"
"Focusing on what you don't have." She got off the bed and walked away.
Quinn POV
I walked into Rachel's room.
"Plan B," I said.
"I feel bad doing that to Puck."
"Sam's too good of a friend to do that to Puck. He'll cave eventually."
Will update once I get 4 good reviews.