"Cheerleaders have the best Auditions"
Setting: Season 3, Episode 5 ("A Multitude of Casualties"). The Midnight Madness ep.
Peyton and Brooke see Rachel for the first time. It's Cheerleader Try-Outs. And so far, it had sucked…
What we saw was the PG version of what happened. My story puts a twist on it.
-----------------
It was cheerleader tryouts, and Brooke and Peyton were the judges.
The whole day was hopeless, with not one good try-out.
That was until the last contender came.
Brooke recognized her immediately. She had dressed up as Pamela Anderson at the School Costume Party. And she had stole Lucas, the bitch.
Peyton and Brooke watched as Rachel showed off her moves.
She was definitely a sexy girl. She had a nice face and one hell of a nice body.
And, for the sake of the audition, she definitely had a few moves too.
"I'd like to thank you on behalf of myself and the group," Rachel said as she finished the routine; "And I hope we pass the audition."
Wow. This girl knew her music. Peyton liked that.
"Nice ass," Peyton blurted out.
She tried to stop herself… she tried. But it just came out.
Both Brooke and Rachel shot strange looks at Peyton, who could only gasp.
"Thanks," Rachel said with a smile.
She walked over to the table with the two girls and around the side… right next to Peyton.
"You wanna touch?" Rachel asked Peyton mischivieously.
Her ass? Touch her ass?!
Sure, Peyton commented on it, but she didn't mean this. She didn't think of other girls like that. She never found an attraction there.
But as her mind asked these questions and told her to reject the careless offer, Peyton's body took control.
She raised her arm and gave Rachel one quick squeeze.
"Firm," she chuckled after she finished.
"Nice hands," Rachel looked behind her to Peyton. "Wanna go a bit lower?"
Brooke froze at the words. And so did Peyton, initially.
They were stunned. Who was this girl? She comes in for an audition then wants you to grope her?!
"Peyton," Brooke said, trying to stop her friend and bring her out of the unusually-lesbian trance she was in.
But Peyton was gone.
Something deep in her mind told her to go for it. To feel the redhead a bit lower. To make a move.
Slowly, Peyton reached her hand back up. Without hesitation, she sent it right in between Rachel's legs and rubbed.
The redhead had a short tight shorts and a tight red tank top shirt… damn sexy.
To top it off, her routine drew up a sweat, and her glistening skin was irresistible.
Peyton had only ever done what she was doing now to herself. She never had a thought of doing it to another girl. It was never her thing, and she felt uncomfortable when Anna only kissed her that time.
Rachel made a little whimper that sent shivers down Peyton's spine. Oh dear God, what was she doing?
Rachel had her elbows resting on the floor and her ass raised up for the newbie masseuse to do her magic.
Peyton thought about pulling out. This was too weird.
It felt great, she couldn't deny that, but it shouldn't be happening.
Just when she was about her leave the soft material that held a dampening camel toe underneath, Peyton saw Brooke coming around in the corner of her eye.
She looked at Brooke and Brooke looked at her as she made her way in front of Rachel.
Peyton watched as Brooke lowered herself onto the floor, inches away from the redhead.
The thought to stop all this vanished as Peyton watched her friend tenderly caress Rachel's face. Then she kissed her.
Holy fuck!
Here was a girl Brooke and Peyton just met and now they were making out with her.
Not just that, but Brooke despised her after than Tommy Lee-Pamela shit she pulled on Lucas.
But regardless of all that, Brooke's horny nature still prevailed.
If Peyton wasn't turned on before just rubbing Rachel, watching the two girls making out was most certainly enough.
Who would have thought a sassy redhead could turn the two lead cheerleaders bi?
Rachel whimpered and moaned lightly as Peyton intensified her finger speed, making Peyton too whimper with pleasure.
She loved the feel of Rachel's cunt – her pussy lips specifically.
Peyton would always be in bliss when she'd masturbate alone, and she loved the feel of her fingers rubbing all her sensitive parts, but still she never thought she'd like doing the same to someone else.
She had to get in there. She had to get in there and make Rachel moan. She loved hearing her own moans.
Peyton pulled down Rachel's exercise shorts – groaning at the discovery Rachel was wearing no underwear or anything of the sort – and immediately rubbed her clit and surrounding areas.
In Brooke's world, Rachel was tasting delicious. They hadn't broken the kiss once, each loving the other's taste and techniques.
And Brooke had never done anything like this either. Who knows about Rachel, she probably has been with another girl considering her keen offer that ignited this all, but Brooke hadn't done anything like this with a girl.
She had kissed Peyton once on the lips. But that was for a split second, and it was to mess with Felix and his stupid Dare Night.
That kiss meant nothing – Brooke and Peyton were BFFs – but this one with Rachel did.
Rachel might be a bitch, but she sure did taste yummy.
"And if this is just her mouth," Brooke thought as she kissed the redhead tenderly; "Her pussy must taste incredible."
Sure it was a bit soon for Brooke to be thinking about that, but one of her guilty pleasures was to dine in on cum.
She loved the taste of a guy's cum, but she loved her own just as much.
She'd often masturbate just so she could have a couple mouthfuls of herself.
"Peyton," Brooke called out to her friend as she broke the kiss and opened her eyes. "Do you wanna put her down?"
Rachel switched eye contact between the other two girls.
"Sounds naughty," Rachel giggled as she lowered her ass and rolled onto the floor on her back.
Brooke crawled up to Rachel as Peyton knelt down and done the same.
"Well, I am known for being a naughty girl," Brooke said in that raspy whisper of hers.
"What are you two gonna do to me?" Rachel asked as she bit her lip.
She was just as horny as the two of them and pre-cum was seeping out of her just thinking about them making a move on her.
"Well, I want your pussy," Peyton said.
"Me too," Brooke said with a smirk.
The two girls lowered their heads in between Rachel as soon as they were close enough.
"You guys are the best cheerleaders," Rachel laughed for a bit, but was cut off as the girls gave their first licks. Straight away, Rachel was groaning and making the most heavenly noises imaginable.
Brooke and Peyton dove and licked away in a sea of pink.
It was better than expected. The feel… the taste. All of it.
These Cheerleader Try-Out Auditions definitely weren't a waste of time after all.
Brooke and Peyton had learnt a bit more about their sexuality, which they would be dying to explore some more.
They had found a squad member and a girlfriend they could feast on…
END OF CHAPTER ONE
Hot, right?
Wanna give a shout out to toddntan. I don't give him nearly as much credit as he deserves. He's always leaving good reviews, and I don't reply back often, but I appreciate it heaps! Hope you'll like this story, although I know you're not a fan of Peyton (so sorry about that factor). But I can't draw myself away from Peyton. Sure, her personality's a pain in the ass at times (okay, more often than not), but I still find her sexy… and that's thanks to Hilarie Burton and her personality.
As for Haley, she's now pretty hot – in Seasons 5 and 6. But right from the start 'til the fourth season's end, I never thought anything other than "cute."
Of course, Brooke will remain the sexiest EVER of any woman…ANYTHING.
And Rachel's…well Danneel is damn fine – she can be a sexual creature when she wants to be, huh :D
Okay, all that post-chapter talk was pretty irrelevant, but oh well. :)