After Regionals
"Hey, Blaine." Kurt says touching his hand.
"Yes, Kurt?" Blaine says turning around.
"Have you seen Rachel anywhere? I want to congratulate her."
"No, I haven't."
"Oh." Kurt shows disappointment through his voice.
"Good luck finding her." Blaine kisses Kurt's cheek.
Kurt smiles and moves on. He would be able to go and look for her in the green room, but if everyone was there. He wouldn't be able to get his job done. There was tap on his back. He turns around, and grins.
"Hey, Kurt." Rachel says.
"Rachel!" He says excitedly. He hugs her tightly wanting to squeeze her eyes out of her head. "Congratulations on that victory of yours."
"Thank you." She says flattered.
"I have something to give you, for you victory." He hands her a blindfold.
"A blindfold?"
"Put it on, I need to take you some place where you'll get your gift."
Rahel put on the blindfold. Kurt guided her to a fire exit. It didn't have an alarm, he opened it and lead Rachel to the alleyway where the dumpster was. He closed the door quietly. He took the knife out of his blazers sleeve. Rachel's back was facing him. He held the knife to her neck.
"Kurt, a necklace how sweet, but I already have the one Finn gave me."
"Guess again, Rachel." Kurt whispers in her ear.
"This has to be a necklace Kurt."
He slices her neck open. Her body falls dead silent on the street pavement. He takes his blindfold. Wipes the blood on his blade off. A wicked grin spreads across his face.
Two Weeks Later
"And so Rachel Berry's serial killer has yet to be found. Police say once he or she is found that charges are inevitable." The news reporter makes Kurt freeze in his living room.
"Kurt what's wrong?" His father's voice asks. "This serial killer thing is making you all jumpy lately."
"Well, you know if a person killed Rachel…they could strike me next or maybe even Finn." Kurt pauses. "They could come after you dad."
"Kurt, I won't let anyone touch you. Your going to be late for your date with Blaine if you don't leave now."
"It's just coffee dad."
His father smiles at him. Kurt smiles back. He runs to his dad before he leaves, kisses his cheek. Then he leaves for coffee.
The Coffee Shop
Kurt lets out a sigh. Blaine is late again. He wonders what is taking him so long. Maybe an emergency Warblers meeting that he was not notified about. He turns on his phone. No new messages. He drinks the warmth, he hopes it will soothe his tension. He wanted to see Blaine. He was going to tell him his dirty secret.
The bell rings on the shop door rings. Kurt looks at the door, it's Blaine. Kurt stands up leaving the table abandoned. He hugs him close. "I've been waiting for such a long time." "I'm sorry." Blaine whispers.
"I have something important to tell you."
"Hrm?" Blaine whispers. He was taking in the scent of Kurt. He was taking in all of Kurt. "It's a secret. We should go to my car. Or the bathroom or something." Kurt whispers.
"That's right." Blaine looks straight up. "I really had to pee."
Kurt shakes his head in embarrassment. The two of them walk to the bathroom holding hands. Blaine opens the door. Kurt walks in first. He walks to the sink and stares at himself in the mirror. Blaine goes to the urinal. "So, what did you need to tell me?" Blaine asks.
Kurt turns on the water. He starts to wash his hands. He breathes slowly. "I killed Rachel." He says feeling his heart sink and weighs fly off of his shoulders. "You did what?" Blaine asks. Now he is washing his own hands.
"I killed her. I'm sorry Blaine. It's not my fault but the world is better off without her." Kurt starts to cry.
"It's okay Kurt, we'll get through this together right?" Blaine holds Kurt's hands and kisses him. "I killed someone once to you know."
Kurt's eyes get wider. "Y-you did?" He whispers.
Blaine nods. "He was my best friend. I loved him, wanted to marry him even. Then he fell in love with this girl. I killed her out of jealousy."
"What about the boy?"
"I forgot about him."
"How old were you?" Kurt asks out of disbelief.
"Old enough to remember."