It takes him five years to show himself again, five years of peace he has given, five years until he seeks his revenge.
To be honest, you should have known better.
You take time to realise who he is, and what sort of glamour he used to make him look so, different. He looks nothing like he does in your nightmares, -or dreams, when your heard betrays your mind- he is brunette, and he is less muscular, but he still shows strength. His skin is a shade paler, but with all his differences, he still looks beautiful.
One thing he can't change is those quartz eyes, which haunt you the most.
And that is what finally gives himself away.