Love triangle
A fanfic based around the Spider-Man PS4 game. After finding out in the DLC, we found out that the Spider and the Cat were "involved" and MJ wasn't happy. Then at the end, Cat's penthouse was blown up which drove Peter into depression. What if MJ and Felicia met and argued over the webhead?
I want to say thanks to my friend Spider-Girl18, we worked together to write this and we hope you enjoy our story.
I don't own Insomniac, Marvel, Spider-Man or it's characters.
Outside Mick's:
Mary-Jane Watson had just left Mick's after trying to cheer Peter up after he witnessed Felicia get blown up. She was about to get a cab when she heard something down an alley so her being her normal danger seeking self, MJ went to check out the noise and when she got halfway down the alley, she saw the body of a tall woman dressed in black suit with pearl white boots and snow white hair. MJ remembered Peter giving her a description of the Black Cat and from what she could tell, the female body laying in front of her was the feline thief herself. She was about to call Pete but realized that his feeling for the thief would come back and he would push her away. Mary-Jane thought instead of telling Peter, she would take Black Cat back to her place and tend to her injuries without telling him.
MJ's apartment:
It was late when Mary-Jane got Black Cat to her apartment and when they got into the apartment, MJ locked all the windows and closed the curtains then locked the front door to stop Peter from getting in while she tended to the wounds that Black Cat had.
"I can't believe Pete didn't tell me about them earlier, didn't he trust me?" MJ thought, that made feel like Peter didn't trust her enough to know about the other woman he had a relationship with. She knew about when the two got physical but didn't know her real name but that was about to change when Mary-Jane removed the mask and saw her face.
Peter's new apartment:
Peter was at his new place making some improvements to his mask, now it could scan people's faces and get intel from the police databases without them knowing he was it. He was about to go to bed when his phone started ringing, he checked the ID to see it was Captain Yuri Watanabe.
"Hey Yuri, what's up?" Peter asked in a cheerful mood. He was looking at his various spidey suits and trying to decide on which one to wear.
"Can you come to Felicia Hardy's penthouse?" Yuri asked which made Peter freeze as he was still trying to get over losing her but now he was asked to come to the scene where she had died.
"Sure, just give me a few minutes." Pete replied then hung up, he decided to wear the Dark Suit that Cat left for him then he jumped out the window and swung to the crime scene. On the way, Spidey was thinking about the times he was with Cat and how much he was now missing her but he had to cheer up as he had Mary-Jane who was doing her best to make him better.
Penthouse:
Spider-Man arrived at the scene and stood by the railings was Captain Watanabe, she was reading a file while waiting for her silent partner to arrive. Yuri turned her head to see that Spider-Man had arrived but he wasn't acting his normal cheerful self, she started to think that he knew her on a personal level.
"Why did you ask me to come here?" Spidey asked, Yuri walked over to the hero and handed him the file. "What's this?" He began reading the file while Yuri watched him.
"That's the forensic report, it says there were nobody here when the bomb went off." Yuri explained which made Spider-Man fall down on to the floor and feel like he was falling into a pit of despair.
"How? I saw her get blown up!" Yuri could tell that Spider-Man was emotionally confused about how the Black Cat could possibly survive that explosion. "So you're saying that Cat survived?" Spidey looked up at Yuri and she shrugged her shoulders, she sat down next to him and held his hand like a concerned friend.
"There's a possibility that she survived but if she did, she'd be seriously injured." Yuri explained, she wanted to help the hero after what he had done to help protect the city. "Are you okay?" Yuri asked, the hero nodded then handed the file back to the Captain.
"I need some time alone, thanks for telling me this." Spider-Man got and walked towards the edge, Yuri got up and walked towards him but before she could say or do anything, Spidey jumped off the edge and started swinging away with Yuri watching him.
Empire State Building:
Pete had swung and climbed to the top of the the Empire State Building and now had a view of all of Manhattan, he was thinking about what Yuri had said: about Felicia surviving the explosion. He kept on thinking if he had missed something when he and Cat had last spoke but nothing came to mind until he remembered the phone call before the blast.
"Don't worry, Spider. I still have all nine lives left." Peter knew that it was a superstition, but the city was mad enough to have a man made electricity and a man who could corrupt someone with a touch, why couldn't it be possible for Black Cat to come back to life? Pete was about to jump when his commlink started beeping, he checked who it was and find out it was Mary-Jane, he wanted to talk to her but he didn't know what to say about what he found out from Captain Watanabe.
"I'll call MJ back later but now, I need to be alone." Pete spoke to himself, he leapt off and dove down towards the ground and just before he hit the ground, Pete shot a web and swung into the city while still wearing the Dark Suit. The suit made him think of Felicia and what if she was alive, he was in love with two women and couldn't choose between them even through one of them was dead.
MJ's apartment:
After a while of removing the Black Cat's suit and bandaging her, Mary-Jane began to make something to eat and didn't notice that Felicia was starting to move, she noticed her gear on the table in front of her but she didn't know where she was. MJ walked into her living room and saw that Felicia was trying to stand up but she was always moaning in pain as she kept trying to stand up.
"Do you need help?" Felicia looked behind her and saw a tall redhead holding a plate and a cup with steam coming out of it. "This is for you." The redhead place a cup of tea and the plate which turned out to be Spaghetti Bolognese, Felicia picked up a fork and began eating the Spaghetti Bolognese while Mary-Jane went into the kitchen and got the another bowl then sat opposite the thief.
Pete's apartment:
Pete had returned to his apartment to change his outfit as wearing the suit that Felicia made was making him feel depressed, he opened his wardrobe and picked a red, gold and blue backpack; he pulled the straps and in a matter of seconds, Pete was now wearing the Iron Spider. He climbed out the window and swung away, Peter thought about who he had lost and with that, he found himself swinging towards the cemetery.
Cemetery:
A shadowy figure was walking towards two graves under a tree, the figure knelt and dusted off the dirt from the gravestones. The figure was Spider-Man and he looked at the graves and clenched his fist, he had lost many people who got close to him. He was hoping that he wouldn't lose MJ or Miles as they were the only ones he cared about left and with that, Pete decided to take a swing over to Mary-Jane's place to see how she was doing.
"I hope that MJ's free to talk, I could do with someone to talk to." Peter suggested but it seemed his plans as Captain Watanabe had sent him a message to meet at the precinct in Chinatown. "Well, name the last time anything went as I planned." Pete mumbled as he was getting fed up with the days since Felicia's death.
Chinatown, an hour later:
Yuri was standing on the roof by the helicopter, she had started smoking again as she was getting fed up with the job but she soldiered on to protect her city. Spider-Man arrived to see the captain lighting a cigarette, Yuri looked at the hero and dropped it then stamped it out.
"What happened to you never smoking again?" Spidey asked which made Yuri look at him with look which meant "You're a right one to talk".
"And what happened to you trying to be cheerful, no matter what." Yuri fired back which made the hero shut up. "My men and women out have reported you helping them but noticed you never joked once, not even a single chuckle." Yuri told him, Spider-Man walked over to the railings and held them as he looked at the city he had helped the police protect for the past eight and a half years.
"Sorry," Spidey apologized which surprised Yuri, he sounded serious and it was making her suspect something. "It's just with Black Cat's death, she meant a lot to me." Yuri walked over and stood next to the vigilante, her detective skills sensed something between him and the thief.
"Off the record and I promise this, were you two…?" Yuri asked and Spider-Man nodded which surprised the captain more. "You and her together? For how long?" Yuri could tell that the question hurt Spider-Man but she thought if he talked about her, it could help him.
"Me and Cat were together for a while until I ended it," Spider-Man started, he sat on the floor and Yuri sat with him, she was interested to know what the Black Cat saw in Spider-Man. "I found out when we were fighting crime together that she was stealing and I told her to stop but Cat being her normal, thieving self, kept on stealing so I ended it."
"What happened afterwards?" Yuri asked, Spidey looked at the captain and as far as Yuri could tell, the hero was giving her a confused facial expression. "First I hear you two working together then all of a sudden, there's no sign of anywhere apart from the costume and gear." Spider-Man knew that Yuri deserved to know.
"Still off the record?" Spidey asked, Yuri nodded. "A few days ago, she showed up and asked for help as her so called son was kidnapped by Hammerhead," that part about a son shocked Yuri Watanabe. "Don't worry, she lied about just for me to help her." Yuri give a sigh of relief after that.
"I'm sorry for your loss, partner." Yuri said, that last word surprised Spider-Man as Yuri had never called him her partner before.
"Thanks Yuri, I think that helped a little." Spidey nodded, Yuri shook his hand then the duo got up and looked at the city.
"So, what now?" Asked Yuri, Spidey turned around and pointed towards Greenwich which made Yuri think about what was in that direction that her partner would want to do there.
"I know someone there, I'm going to pay them a visit and see how they're doing." Spider-Man told Yuri and she nodded, she handed him a small piece of paper with a number on it.
"That's my personal number, think of me as your friend, partner and counselor." Yuri told Spidey and he nodded, he was thankful that he had a great friend in Captain Yuri Watanabe. The hero jumped off the edge of the Chinatown precinct and started swinging his way towards Greenwich, towards Mary-Jane's apartment.
MJ's apartment:
Felicia was sleeping in MJ's bed to keep herself hidden from the webhead while Mary-Jane was busy working on a new article about the low crime rates, it was quiet until there was knocking on the window and when Mary-Jane checked the window, she saw Spider-Man in the Iron Spider suit. MJ opened the window and let Pete in.
"Hey Pete, you okay?" Mary-Jane asked, Pete nodded as he sat down on her couch and the article caught his eye. "Oh, Robbie has asked me to write about the drop in crime since people have seen Spider-Man in different suits. They think there's more than one Spider-Man."
"Sounds interesting," Peter said as the helmet of the Iron Spider retacted to reveals Pete's face and Mary-Jane could see that he had been crying and he was also tired. "I'll leave so you can get back to work." Peter said as he got and walked towards the window as the helmet covered his face, Mary-Jane was about to say something but Peter had already jumped out the window and began to swing away. Felicia walked into the living room and saw Mary-Jane standing by the window, it looked like she was about to cry.
"Is everything okay?" Felicia asked, she was concerned about the redhead and MJ nodded as she wiped the tears away. "Why are you crying if nothing is wrong?" Mary-Jane knew that lying to a thief was going to be harder than lying to Peter. "Does it have something to do with Spidey or should I say, Peter?" That last word surprised Mary-Jane as she didn't know that Black Cat knew Spidey's identity.
"You know who he is?" Mary-Jane screamed, she thought that the only ones that knew were herself, Miles and Aunt May but now it appeared that the thief knew Spider-Man true identity.
"Does he know who you are?" Mary-Jane asked and the cat nodded.
"Yeah, we're on a first name bases when we're alone," the thief could tell the the redhead didn't trust her. "I never asked about your name, what was it?" Mary-Jane felt surprised that the thief was asking for her name. "Fine, I'll go first. My name's Felicia, what's yours?"
"Mary-Jane but my friends call me MJ," Mary-Jane sat in the chair opposite Felicia then the two began to talk about how they knew the spider.
That's the starter to see what you lot think of the story so far, I hoped you enjoyed it and the suits I included in this. There will be another page on its way in due time, don't rush me.
Please leave a review as it will help me improve or tell me what you thought of it.
Remember: I'm basing this off the Insomniac Spider-Man game, nothing else.
See you lot later!