The Forbidden Fruit is the Sweetest

A/N: Enjoy.

Chapter 1:

Auditorium Sex Is The Best Kind

Santana was sitting in class, mindless drawing hearts in the margin of her notebook, when one of those hall monitor nerds walked in. She glared at him, and he walked faster to the teacher, then quickly out of the room. Hearing his shoes slap against the linoleum as he ran, she laughed bitterly. Then the teacher placed a note on her desk. In big black letters, the words "Come to the auditorium now" were printed across the paper, followed by a heart.

Santana grabbed her backpack and ran to the auditorium, her Cheerio skirt flowing around her. She pushed the doors open and saw Shelby sitting at the piano. Santana smirked as she saw the low cut top Shelby was wearing, revealing her sexy boobs. As she strutted up the stage she raised an eyebrow at Shelby, "What's all this?"

Shelby stood up and walked to Santana, wrapping one arm around her waist, the other holding the back of Santana's neck, so she could force Santana to look at her. Smirking, she said, "Well, we had so much fun last time, I figured, why not again?"

Santana smiled, resting her hands on Shelby's hips, "Sounds fun to me." Santana immediately dove into a kiss, opening her lips against Shelby's a little.

She pressed a hand to Shelby's chest and pushed her against the piano. Shelby whimpered a little, and didn't hesitate in darting her tongue into Santana's mouth. Santana played flirtatiously with Shelby's tongue before slipping her hand under Shelby's waistband.

Once again Shelby whimpered as she felt Santana's fingers press on her clit. She thrust her pussy toward Santana's hand. Reaching up Santana's shirt, she unhooked her bra with one hand. Moving her hand to the front of Santana, she grabbed her boob, squeezing lightly. This caused Santana to put more pressure on Shelby, making Shelby lose all control over anything below the waist. They slowly slide against the piano, falling to the floor.

Santana slide two fingers gracefully into Shelby, using her thumb to massage Shelby's clit. Shelby squirmed with anticipation, tightening around Santana's fingers. Santana pulled away, kissing down Shelby's jawline to her neck. From there she tore Shelby's shirt of with her free hand, still working Shelby's pussy with the other, and lightly sucked her nipple.

Shelby had stopped trying to do anything and just held Santana's head. That was until Santana added another finger, then Shelby screamed out Santana's name in pleasure. Shelby's heart rate was insane as Santana's fingers pressed against the inside of Shelby's surprisingly tight pussy.

Santana smirked as her lips moved against Shelby's boob. Shelby's screams only urged her to add one last finger, going deeper and adding more pressure to her clit. She herself was wet through her panties, dying for her turn. Her lips moved off Shelby's boob as she felt Shelby's orgasm take control.

Shelby moaned loudly as Santana's tongue took the place of her fingers, her thumb never moving from Shelby's clit. Her tongue moved fast around Shelby's insides, her lips sucking lightly to catch every drop of cum. Shelby screamed slightly as a second orgasm approached, Santana's tongue and thumb riding her through.

Shelby sighed, catching her breathe as Santana rolled off her, "You're half my age and you're better than anyone I've ever been with."

Santana smirked, "Experience."

"Your turn," Shelby winked at her, pushing her to the floor. Shelby took a different approach, something she knew Santana loved. Aggression. She shoved three fingers into Santana, moving fast and hard. Santana's back arched and she bit her bottom lip to keep from screaming.

Shelby reached a hand up Santana's shirt and cupped Santana's boob before squeezing powerfully. Santana moaned lightly, pushing her pussy towards Shelby's hand, signaling Shelby to add another finger. Shelby obliged.

Santana clawed at Shelby's back as Shelby moved her hand from Santana's boob and put her mouth over her nipple. Sucking hard Santana let lose and screamed. Shelby took this as a sign to use her entire fist, something Santana loved. She shoved her fist in deeper, going faster as she felt Santana's orgasm.

Santana's first orgasm came to end and Shelby's fast tongue and sweet mouth took the place of her hand, cleaning the first orgasm and causing another one to burst out. Santana grabbed Shelby's head and pushed it closer to her pussy. Shelby used her thumb and pressed hard against Santana's clit.

As Santana's second orgasm ended, Shelby laid next to Santana, licking her hand as it was still covered in cum. Santana struggled to rematch her breath before standing up and fixing her clothes. Shelby stood up and did the same, then they fixed each other's hair.

Shelby leaned on the piano, "It's a good thing I know how to turn off the camera's in here." She winked at Santana.

Santana blushed a little, "Sure is. I'd hate to see Sue's expression when she played it to the Cheerios."

Shelby instantly hugged Santana, kissing her forehead. Santana hugged her back, smiling a little. A quick kiss on the lips, and Santana went back to class, Shelby to her office, both pretending these unforgettable moment never happened.

A/N: Review. So this is the first ShelbTana story to be written. Amazing I know. ;)
Thanks for reading. These two ..are my OTP, For fucking ever. Just unf.