i believe the heatherpaw being evil theory and hollypaw too (but i don't like it)
so here's a story of both of them.
_____________________________________________________________________________
"So where's Hawkfrost?" Heatherpaw asked impatiently. Tigerstar stared at her calmly. "patience Heatherpaw, Patience. When you are leader of Windclan remember that."
*meanwhile in a far away area in the dark forest*
''Where is Tigerstar?'' Hollypaw asked. Hawkfrost stared at her. She has Brambleclaw's patience he thought. "hello?" * Hollypaw hit him with a rock* "hey!" Hawkfrost hissed playfully. Hollypaw sighed. "For the last time, where's Tigerstar?""Let's go find out" Hawkfrost meowed. As they walked along the path of the dark forest Hollypaw asked "In the waking world, is it sunhigh?" "No it's not even sunrise" Hawkfrost meowed. "How do you know?" Hollypaw asked. "I don't." Hawkfrost meowed.
They walked in silence for a while and finally Hollypaw broke the silence. "Is Tigerstar with Brokenstar or Clawface?" Hollypaw asked. "No, he's with another apprentice." Hawkfrost replied.
"Another apprentice..." Hollypaw meowed cooly. "One you've met before" He mewed equally cool.
They soon arrived in another big and dark clearing. Hollypaw saw two cats fighting. one big tabby ,probably Tigerstar, another smaller and much lighter tabby,probably the apprentice, underneath him. as Tigerstar noticed Hawkfrost and Hollypaw waiting patiently at the edge of the clearing he got of the small tabby and went to join them.
As the small tabby came to join them Hollypaw realized who it was.
"Heatherpaw?" Hollypaw meowed in disbelief.