Hello Guys and Dolls! I'm writing this fic to follow up my 'All That Glitters Is Not Gold' fic. If you haven't read that yet, I recommend doing that before reading this one. More characters, more drama, more villains, and more SMUT. We have our heros: Dean, Sam, Castiel, Aria, and Spencer. Supernatural, Dollhouse, and Pretty Little Liars characters I do not own but I own the plot. Some scenes were from RPs from Instagram. Please enjoy!

Prologue

Since our last encounter with our heroes, Gadreel was killed by Spencer and sent to purgatory. As for Metatron, no one can track the little creep down. Castiel kept asking angels if they heard from him. Unfortunately, none have heard from him. Aria practiced useful spells just in case Sam or Dean needed leads. Since Sam and Dean had to continue looking for cases in towns, Spencer and Aria would stay behind at the bunker and read about this Mark of Cain. During this time, the leaves changed, the weather was a bit cooler, and the smell of chimney smoke filled the air.

Aria sat at the table with a big book open and a lamp beside her. "Same information I already know." She sighed; closing the ancient book.

Spencer, who sat across from her, looked up from her laptop. "What do you mean?"

Aria shrugged. "Mark of Cain; whoever shall receive the mark shall carry the responsibilities and burden of the mark." She frowned. "I want to help Dean."

Spencer offered a small smile. "We will." Her smiled faded as she looked back at her laptop.

Aria laid her hand on Spencer's cold hand. "Is Gadreel bothering your thoughts, Spencer?"

Spencer blushed. "Aria, no." She moved her hand.

Hannah, one of the loyal angels, appeared next to her. "Aria, there you are."

Aria quickly stood up. "Can I help you, Hannah?" She greeted her with a warm smile.

Hannah smiled. "We need your permission to further build Heaven again. I hope I'm not intruding."

Since Heaven had no one directing them, Aria was chosen to become the leader until Heaven was again restored. Clearly, Metatron and Castiel could not become their leader so Hannah and the others visited Aria and she agreed with confidence.

"Oh, right." Aria looked at Spencer then to Hannah. "What is it?"

Spencer stared at them while they talked.

"It's also about our.." Hannah looked to Spencer.

Spencer quickly looked down at her laptop.

Hannah took Aria's arm and dragged her into the kitchen. "It's our enemy, Aria. I didn't want to tell Castiel but-"

"You should have told Castiel. You know we can trust him. He's helping us." Aria took off her leather jacket and sat it on the stainless steel bar.

"My apologies then, Aria."

"I thought this was about my permission for something."

"It is but about our enemy first." Hannah took out her phone and showed Aria a picture of Metatron in disguise.

Aria's face flushed red. "What is he up to?" She studied the picture.

"Sources tell us that he's planning on summoning someone...maybe something."

Aria looked closely at his plastic bag. "I recognize some of those items. I need to talk to Crowley about this. He could know something if this is evil summoning."

Hannah raised an eyebrow. "I don't mean to be nosy, but since when did you two become close?"

"He helped us in a way. He doesn't hate us. I'll need you with me so you can show him that picture. Now, what about those plans again?"

/

Spencer chewed on the end of her ink pen as she scrolled across the angel fall just to remind herself of Gadreel. Oh how she blamed herself for his downward spiral.

Aria met Spencer back at the big table. "That sneaky bastard."

Spencer shifted her eyes left and right. "I'm sorry?"

"Metatron is planning something and Hannah says it's evil. I'm planning to go to hell and ask Crowley if he knows anything. Want to join me?"

Spencer shook her head. "No thanks. I'm letting you do that solo." She cleared her throat. "Aria, can I ask you something?"

Aria scooted her chair closer to the table and leaned forward. "Sure."

Spencer closed her laptop and looked Aria. "Can you send me to purgatory?"

Aria's eyes widened. "Are you kidding me? Spence, I can't take you to purgatory. Even for an angel like me it's dangerous. Why would..." She leaned away from Spencer. "This is about Gadreel, isn't it?"

Spencer stood up. "Aria, please!"

Aria shook her head. "Of course not! Why would you even want to see Gadreel's face again? Remember what he did?"

"Remember what I did?!" Spencer snapped. "I just need to talk to him one last time. Actually say goodbye."

"Spencer..you don't need to see him again. For your sake..stay here."

Spencer shook her head. "Please Aria. I know you know how to. I've seen you read those powerful spells."

"If Sam finds out that I helped you with this, he'll kick my ass. Why do you want to risk it all again?"

Spencer clasped her hands together and stuck her bottom lip out. "Please? I just want to see if he's okay."

Aria huffed as she stood up and walked towards the book shelf. "This spell will make sure you do your business and get back. You'll have three hours until it will bring you back here. Do you understand?" Aria dumped the plethora of books onto the table.

Spencer hugged the tiny angel. "You're small...but I love you."

Aria nodded. "Yea, yea. Stand near the stairs and I'll send you."

"Oh, hold on." Spencer ran into her room, grabbed her demon blade, and met back near the stairs. "Okay, I'm ready."