A/N: So I've started this new story, this is part 1 of 3. It's completely AU from the show. If you follow Shattered Limits, don't worry I haven't abandoned it. I'll be updating tomorrow or Thursday at the latest. I want to say a special thanks to all my twitter ladies for the help and hand-holding you all did while I was writing this, you girls keep me sane!
Disclaimer: I don't own Glee, if I did I would move it to HBO and there would be a lot more sex and a lot more swearing, and Puck would never wear clothes.
Noah Puckerman loved a good frat party. The free-flowing alcohol and intoxicated girls lacking inhibitions always made for a lucky night. The night was just beginning and Puck had already realized there was no way he wasn't getting any. Let's face it, he was a stud, and in a house packed with mostly drunken college girls, the odds were better than good.
Puck headed for the kitchen looking for some beer and one of the guys. He needed to do some serious scouting, the sets of eyes at work, the better. Filling up a red beer cup at the keg, he spotted Mike and Matt on the back lawn.
Sidestepping the crazy game of beer pong currently going down at the kitchen table, Puck headed out the back doors to catch up with his bro's.
"First party of junior year dude!" Mike shouted at him when he made is way over, clapping Puck on the shoulder, "You ready for an epic night?"
"You know Mike the more you say epic, the less impact it has" Matt piped up, "Hey man" he said, nodding his head at Puck.
Puck was saved from Mike's undoubtedly delayed response to Matt by the music stopping and his boy Finn jumping up on the DJ stand with a microphone.
"Hey everyone, listen up for a sec. Welcome to the first Alpha Tau Omega party of the year here at OSU! Drinks, dancing and a full night of fun ahead. The DJ here will be taking requests all night. Have a great night!" Finn handed the microphone back to the DJ and jumped down trying to avoid the rush of people heading to request songs.
When Finn finally made it over to the group, Puck had already started scoping out the girls. It was like, second nature to him.
"Dude, stop thinking with your dick for a second and talk to us" Finn called to him, hitting him in the back.
"Whatever" was his reply as he kept scanning the crowd while listening with half an ear to Finn, Matt and Mike talking about ATO's baseball team this year. They'd lost a few teammates to graduation last year and how they'd have to make sure the pledges were awesome players. Talk then moved on to the grudge match between themselves and the Phi Psi team; this year they stood no chance, ATO would come out the winner this year.
Puck loved his brothers, but really baseball talk 3 weeks into the semester at the first party, they were nuts.
That's when he spotted Artie wheel his way in through the side gate, followed closely by Tina and a tiny brunette. Holy hell.
The brunette had the longest pair of legs he'd ever seen, and she was showing them off in a ridiculously short black skirt. They were the kind of legs made specifically for wrapping around his waist. And the kind of hair meant to tangle your hands in; long wavy dark brown locks.
Ignoring the complaints of the three stooges as he walked away, Puck headed for Artie. They'd been cool ever since junior year of high school back in Lima, god he was glad to be out of that town. Just before he reached him, the girls broke away, heading for the house with Puck watching them go, his eyes trained to the brunettes slim hips swaying as she walked. No more reason to keep looking Puckerman, you found tonight's girl he thought reaching Artie.
"Hey man! Who's the brunette?"
Rachel headed for the keg in the kitchen of the frat house for the third time that night. She could already feel the effects of the alcohol; she'd never been much of a drinker. Tonight was different though, she was with her friends, and she just wanted to let loose for a while. She'd missed out on a lot of parties through her high school years. At Julliard she'd been more widely accepted, but she still wasn't one for partying on a weekly basis. So when she did go out she made sure she had a good time.
Rachel was glad Tina had convinced her to tag along on her weekend trip to Ohio. They had been friends since they met freshman year at Julliard, put together as roommates. Now they had their own little apartment off campus and were practically inseparable. Tina had grown up in Ohio and been the star of her high school glee club before moving to New York for college. So when Tina had finally gotten together with her high school crush this past summer, Rachel had been ecstatic for her. And when she had suggested a weekend trip to Ohio State University so that her boyfriend and best friend could meet, and she could spend time with Artie, Rachel hadn't been able to say no.
Artie was a cool guy, and Rachel got along well enough with him; it was obvious the he and her best friend were smitten with one another.
When she had finally filled up her beer cup (keg lines were long) Rachel headed back in the direction of the picnic table her Tina and Artie had been occupying in the backyard, the beer (and bodies) making walking just a little harder than usual. When she arrived back at the table Artie and Tina had been joined by four guys, all of whom were laughing along with Artie. In the spot she next to Tina she had vacated a few minutes earlier sat a guy who, even from across the yard, drew Rachel's attention. She could see the definition of his biceps and the expanse of his muscular back underneath the t-shirt he wore. As he turned to listen to something the tall guy beside him was saying, Rachel saw the hard outline of his jaw and the twinkle of green in his eye, and she promptly ran into someone.
"Watch where you're walking girl" a voice said pulling her eyes away from the picnic table to see a stunning blonde glaring at her as she walked past. Mumbling an apology, Rachel continued to the table and stood behind Tina. Artie looked up and saw her standing there before speaking to the man she had been so enthralled with.
"Yo Puck, you're in the girl's seat shuffle down."
He looked up at her with a smirk before sliding down the bench to make just enough room for her to squeeze in between him and Tina, so that when she was seated she was pressed right up against his side.
"Puck huh, that can't be your real name?" she asked him in order to distract herself from the tingling in her skin where she was pressed against him.
Puck had a slightly offended look on his face "Of course it is"
Rachel was taken aback, what kind of parent names their child Puck? "Oh I'm terribly so –"
"Don't listen to him, he's a jackass. And his name is Noah Puckerman" the Asian guy sitting across from her spoke up, a big smile on his face, "I'm Mike Chang" he told her sticking out his hand for Rachel to shake.
"Rachel"
The rest of the introductions were made, and Rachel found out the goofy tall one was Finn Hudson, and the handsome black guy was named Matt Rutherford. All four guys were brothers here at the fraternity, and also good friends with Artie whom Puck had met through their mutual love of the guitar.
3 hours later, Puck was still sitting with Rachel, Tina, and Artie at the picnic table. His boys had just drifted off a few minutes ago. Up until then everyone had been talking and laughing and drinking beer. Rachel was adorable, talking with everyone, laughing along to all the jokes. Her laugh had been getting progressively louder as the hours passed, along with her getting a lot more touchy feely with everyone, and Puck had a suspicion it was very much due to the amount of alcohol she'd had. His brain was totally focused on how she would bite her lower lip, the way her shirt clung to her chest, and the way her skirt rose on her thighs when she moved next to him. He'd been rock hard since she'd squeezed her little body in next to his. He wanted her so bad, but he'd rather her not be so drunk that she passes out on his bed before they even got started, so putting on a gentlemanly front, he asked her if she wanted some water.
"That would be lovely Noah" she answered putting her little hand softly on his forearm. Puck grimaced at the use of his first name, but he figured he could stand it for night so he didn't say anything, instead just standing up and heading for the kitchen of the frat house. After getting Rachel a bottle of water from the fridge Puck turned around only to be cornered by a girl who was practically falling over drunk. She sidled right up to him, grabbing his arms.
"Hey Puck, you have quite the reputation around here" Leaning in closer she whispered in his ear, "I'm Bree, want to head upstairs?"
He almost said yes, before he remembered Rachel sitting outside. This Bree was gorgeous, but he'd seen her around at other parties before, so he knew she would be around again. Rachel on the other hand was here only for the weekend, and beyond all reason Puck was strangely drawn to her, despite the fact that she was not a sure thing.
"Not tonight" he told Bree, shrugging away from a now pouting Bree and heading back outside. When he got back to the picnic table Rachel was giggling at something Mike had just said. Tina and Artie were no longer there. Puck gave Mike a questioning glance, to which Mike replied with a shoulder shrug.
"Dude, Tina and Artie headed back to his apartment thank god, they were getting way to handsy. They left Rachel here the spare key because she said she wasn't ready to leave. They wanted me to stay with her until you got back, Artie says to tell you to not make him regret convincing Tina it was safe for Rachel to stay and that she better be in a cab back to the apartment later" Mike said while half laughing.
"Shut it Chang! Rachel will be fine, right Rach?" He asked handing her the bottle of water.
"I'm doing great Mike, it's sweet of you and Artie to worry, but I'll be fine to get back to his apartment"
Mike looked skeptically at Puck but finally relented, shrugging his shoulders and turning to Rachel "Let me know if you need anything okay?"
Rachel nodded, "Thank you Mike, you're a dear" she said before starting to giggle.
Puck sat back down as Mike headed back towards the house. Rachel was practically inhaling her water.
"Easy there killer, you don't want to choke" he told her laughing.
Rachel stopped drinking, looked at him with her head cocked to one side, before saying "That's what she said!"
Puck felt like his heart had stopped, this girl was amazing! They were both laughing so hard, people were giving them strange looks, but Puck didn't care. If he was into relationships, Rachel just might be a girl after his own heart. But relationships were for suckers, Puck was all about the one night stand. There was less pain that way.
Once they finally stopped laughing, Rachel finished off her water. "How you feeling now?" Puck asked her.
"Much better, although I still have quite the buzz going on, but I don't feel like I'll walk into things anymore" Rachel replied, a huge smile spreading across her face.
Puck let out a laugh, "That's good then" he replied back to a nodding Rachel, "So tell me about New York"
Rachel clapped her hands excitedly and starting talking a mile a minute; Puck only half listened to what she was saying, focusing instead on her lips moving and her boobs bouncing when she got really excited about what she was talking about.
"- fantastic the way I fit in at Julliard. My high school classmates just didn't appreciate my talent. But at Julliard I'm surrounded by other talented people who understand my nature a little better. In high school they didn't understand, but I'm going to be a Broadway star one day. I am talented and driven and I know what I want, and Broadway is it. I will be there one day, and I'll see my name in lights. It'll happen, they just didn't believe me. Tina and I have this amazing little apartment just off campus at Julliard, of course it costs an extraordinarily high amount but we are very fortunate that my fathers' have contributed greatly to our rent so that Tina and I can focus on school instead of making money to pay for the apartment. Sometimes I miss living with my fathers'; I have to gay dads and they're so great to me. They dote on Tina as well, as if she was their own daughter. The only thing I think that disappoints them some is I don't often make it to temple anymore, I'm Jewish, did I tell you that?"
Rachel was still rambling on, and Puck was content to just sit back and soak it all in. The thought that his mother would approve of her popped into his head for a second until he realized that no, she really wouldn't seeing as Puck's every intention was to fuck her and never see her again. Despite the temptation to parade Rachel in front of his crazy mother (she was always rambling on about him finding "a nice Jewish girl") Puck didn't do dates, or relationships, and he'd hate to give his mother false hope she'd end up nagging him more.
"-always had such trouble with guys. They're so childish and crass, not to mention very unappreciative of my voice. I've dated a few guys in New York, but no one even close to as striking as you are. I mean they're all these skinny guys, very unlike you, and there was just never any chemistry"
All of a sudden she started to blush, as if realizing what she had just said. That's when Puck saw his opening, gently cupping her chin he turned Rachel towards him and slowly lowered his lips to hers. After a seconds hesitation Rachel was deepening the kiss. And Puck's mind started to go blank with the pleasure.
Five minutes later Puck was pushing Rachel back onto his bed, both of their clothing having already disappeared since they arrived in his room. Coming down on top of her, Puck pushed her silky hair off of her collarbone and licked a long line up to her ear, causing Rachel to jerk below him. Attacking her lips again, Puck reached down to trail a finger down her side and over her hip and back up again to cup her breast in his hand. The perfect handful, he thought before Rachel bit down on his lower lip and all rational thought flew out the window.
Just when he thought Rachel couldn't surprise him anymore, she pushed him up and away from the bed, trailing hot little kisses down his chest and stomach, playing with his nipple ring. She nipped at his hip bone, licking over to sooth the burn. Gripping him in her tiny hand, Rachel licked along his erection, then promptly took him deep into her sweet little mouth, all the way to the back of her throat. Pulling back off of him she looked up at him with a smile on her face, winked and then said "no gag reflex".
Puck's knees buckled, and Rachel took him back into her mouth, working his cock deep and reaching down to gently squeeze his balls. Jerking, he tried to pull her away, he couldn't take much more, but Rachel continued the sweet torture while he groaned out her name before he finally managed to jerk away from her.
"You little minx, you'll pay for that" he told her as he dragged her back up his body, and started walking her backwards towards the bed. "I hope so" she whispered in his ear just as they reached the bed, tumbling onto it in a mass of limbs. Puck grabbed her hips and dragged her so that her legs were over the edge of the bed and moved down her body, giving her the same slow sweet torture she had been so happily giving to him. Her body was writhing as he trailed his tongue along her hip. A gasp escaped her as he ran his tongue up her folds to her clit, drawing his tongue in a circle but never quite giving her the touch she craved. He teased her mercilessly with his tongue, lapping at her until it drove her mad.
"Noah, please…"
Finally he gave her the contact she was begging for, sucking hard on her clit. Her leg wrapped around his back, while both her hands were gripping the back of his head tightly in place. Her climax ripped through her as the shouted his name and writhed beneath him, and he almost came himself from the sheer pleasure of watching her descend into oblivion.
His patience snapped as he reached into his bedside drawer for a condom, rolling it on before pushing Rachel up onto his bed, her head onto his pillows. Without any warning he pushed into her all the way to the hilt, feeling the aftershocks of her orgasm ripple around his cock.
"God Rachel, so hot and tight…I can't bear it"
He started moving then, pulling his cock almost all the way out before slamming back into her, little shocks ripping through her (or him, he couldn't tell) every time. It wasn't slow, or romantic, it was pure need. Rachel met him thrust for thrust her brown eyes almost black from desire. In that moment she looked so perfect below him that he closed the gap between them and kissed her fiercely, pouring all his need into the joining of their bodies. Rachel began making quiet mewling noises, dragging her mouth away from his to bury it in his shoulder. He felt her tightening around him and without warning her orgasm exploded through her, milking his cock as she screamed his name again, feeling her clenching around him sent Puck right into his own climax.
His climax was so strong he saw nothing but black, his mind slipping into oblivion as Rachel's name crossed his lips. They both lay panting for a minute before Puck had the sense to pull out and dispose of the condom. When he rolled back towards her, Rachel was already asleep. Sliding her to lay next to him, Puck realized sleepily that tonight was the first time he had ever used a girl's actual name during sex. Usually he stuck to babe, or baby, it kept things impersonal.
Well fuck, was his last coherent thought before sleep dragged him under.
Rachel woke with a start when she felt a weight press down on her stomach. Opening her eyes she saw she was in an unfamiliar room; the weight on her stomach coming from the muscular arm of the guy lying next to her. In a blink of an eye, the previous night came rushing back to her. She felt as though she should be embarrassed but in reality she was too tired to think much into it.
Rachel took a moment to take in her surroundings, something she definitely had not done the night before. Noah's room at the fraternity was painted blue and had a nice set of wood furniture including the queen size bed she was currently in. The room was clean, if untidy. There were papers and clothes strewn haphazardly around, her own included.
Realizing she was thirsty, Rachel carefully removed Noah's arm from her waist, before slipping to the edge of the bed. As she stood her thighs burned in protest and a groan escaped from her lips. She heard Noah grumble awake behind her, so Rachel reached for her clothes and began dressing. She heard Noah roll over and turned back to face him.
"Morning, I'm just going to run and grab some water, you want anything" Rachel asked him, pulling her shrug over her shoulders.
"I think maybe you should go now" he said, pushing his hand through his short hair.
Rachel was confused, she in no way expected a relationship, they lived too far away, but some pleasantries or small talk or anything really would have been nice. It seemed so in contrast to the sweet way he had acted last night. Her confusion must have been evident on her face because he got up, pulled on his boxers and stood in front of her.
"Look we both knew what this was, a onetime deal. And I have plans for lunch with the guys, it's a tradition after our parties" He reached over to grab something off his dresser. "Rach you were honestly the best sex I've ever had" he told her placing a burger king crown on her head, "take your walk of shame with pride"
Rachel's mouth opened in shock, she couldn't believe he's just said that, she was mortified. Slowly she walked to the door grabbing the crown off of her head. Once out in the hall she heard Noah say "Goodbye Rach" and close the door behind her.
She tried her best to keep the tears from spilling out as she made her way down the stairs of the frat house. Unfortunately she ran into Mike and Matt on the lower level. Why did the stairs have to be at the back of the house?
"Rachel what are you still doing here" Mike asked looking worried. Rachel didn't want to tell him the truth so she just told him she'd fallen asleep and just woke up "I'm heading back to Artie's now" she said, trying not to show how upset she was. It didn't work.
"Bullshit Rach, you look like you're about to cry, what happened?" Matt said to her, gently grabbing one of her shoulders.
She sighed and gave into the inevitable, telling them the events that had transpired in Noah's room just minutes earlier, "Guys I just want to get out of here now. I'm sorry, it was really nice meeting you two, but I want to get back to Tina and Artie."
Both boys nodded their heads and walked with her to the front door. Matt looked worried for her, and Mike looked angry enough to spit nails. Before she walked out the door, Mike stopped her. "Here Rachel, give me your phone and I'll give you my number. If you need anything before you leave town let me know okay?"
Rachel nodded handing over her cell. Matt and Mike really were sweet, she was almost grateful she had run into them this morning.
When Rachel had arrived back at Artie's apartment that morning, she'd been attacked by a worried Tina. Rachel had apologized profusely for worrying her, but said she really needed to take a shower. She had known Tina could see something was wrong but she had let it slide for a while. Rachel stayed in the shower until the water had run cold before finally getting out and going to face Tina.
The girls had walked to a nearby coffee shop, and over cappuccinos Rachel had told Tina the whole embarrassing story. However, Rachel realized while explaining this morning's exit from the frat house that she was no longer upset, she was furious. How dare he placate her in such a manner. She hadn't been expecting wine and red roses, so where did he get off pulling such a stunt in order to get her to leave.
That was how she found herself walking back down the upstairs hallway of the fraternity followed by Mike who she had called an hour earlier. She'd explained that she couldn't find the keys to her apartment in New York and she felt like she might have left them in Puck's room (yes he was Puck now, Noah was a sweet name, one he was not deserving of). Mike had caught on pretty quick that Rachel really hadn't left anything behind, so he's sent Puck out to grab some beer in order for Rachel to have the time to exact her revenge.
Rachel slipped quickly back into Puck's room while Mike stood guard outside. Walking over to the bed Rachel grabbed a sharpie out of her purse and took a deep breath before signing her name nice and big, vertically on one of the bedposts. Replacing the cap on the sharpie, she placed it back in her purse before grabbing a sheet of gold star stickers and placing one at the end of her signature.
She stepped back to admire her work, a small smile creeping onto her face as she thought of Puck's reaction to this. Just then Mike walked into the room stepping up behind her he burst out laughing. "I can't wait to see his reaction to that!" He said in between laughs.
At the door to the ATO house Mike wrapped Rachel up in a big hug and told her to take care of herself back in New York, and to keep in touch, before sending her off to Tina's waiting car just down the block.
He'll never be rid of her now; she's already under his skin. This should be fun to watch.