I really think of you
More often than I should
And I hope you think this through
I know that you could
Because you were forever
More dependable that way
Than I was, and never
Did you think, Oh May
I didn't really know
Exactly how to feel
I didn't really show
That I thought this might be real
I watch you across the firelight
And smile when you smile
I know that you were right
And it might be a little while
Till I tell you how much I care
And that I always wanna be there
Oh May, I think I love you
Oh May, I think it's true
Oh May, should I let it slide
Oh May, in you I confide
Oh May, I love you