Set after my first story Jonas Sister Meets Glee, Kaitlin has grown up and well, this chapter is basically about what happened after the last story but the rest of the chapters will be kind of like the movie, Definitely Maybe.


Definitely Maybe

In Kaitlin's junior year, the glee club won Nationals which led to all of them getting scholarships to various colleges.

Rachel, Kurt, Blaine, Sam, Quinn, Tina, Puck, and Artie were all accepted to different colleges in New York where Rachel, Kurt, Blaine, Sam and Quinn went to Julliard. While Tina, Artie, and Puck got to start their freshman year at Manhattan School of Music, another great school.

Lauren went to some school in Florida on a Wrestling Scholarship. Santana, Brittany, Mercedes, and Mike were accepted into schools in California. Santana, Brittany, and Mercedes all went to Colburn School of Performing Arts while Mike started his freshman year at Chapman University to further his performance in dance.

I was so proud of each and every one of them, there was only one who didn't get out, Finn decided it would be best to go to the University of Northwestern Ohio, staying in Lima. I never understood why because out of everyone, he was accepted into the most colleges with the most opportunity.

He and Rachel were the big item all through out their senior year and I thought they were going to marry right after graduation. But just like everyone else, Rachel left and every weekend I got to see Finn, he looked miserable. I just never understood his reasoning.

The worst part was when ever I heard from Rachel, Kurt, Quinn, or any of them up there, they sounded happy.

My senior year was amazing. I was head of glee club and Mr. Shue kept us in line all the way up to winning Sectionals, then Regionals, and then finally Nationals. It felt amazing to win. I got accepted into Julliard and I was so excited to be seeing all my friends again.

I remember the night before I left, me and Finn went out for a Congratulations/Good Bye dinner. It was sad to be leave Finn and I didn't know what would happen to him.

College was amazing too, almost every night me, Quinn, Sam, Kurt, Blaine, and Rachel would go out and party! College changed all of them, especially Rachel. She was still determined but more laid back and chill. Blaine and Kurt were still the cutest couple ever all through out their college years, they gave hope for everyone else in being able to find the one.

At the beginning of their senior year, my junior year, Tina and Artie had transferred over to Julliard just adding people to our crazy party family.

Throughout my college years, besides the glee kids I went to school with, I kept really good tabs with Mercedes, Mike, Brittany, Santana, Lauren, and Finn. For about three years, my freshman to junior year, me and Puck were on very good terms and then after, the talking ended.

I made a really big mistake mid way through my freshman year in College, I got pregnant. You would think that would be life changing, and it was but I still continued my next three years of college. I had my beautiful baby girl right before sophomore year started and since my parents were living in New York themselves, they watched her during the day for the next three years while I was at school.

I told all the glee kids and they were happy, some not so much when they found out who the father was but it passed over and the happy family never ended.

Once everyone graduated college they all went their separate ways. Right after school, Rachel got straight into Broadway, starting out with her all time favorite musical, West Side Story. Kurt also got on Broadway while Blaine started teaching at a high school with an excellent musical department.

After 5 years of it being legal for gays to marry in New York, Kurt and Blaine thought it was their turn for the big wedding. Everyone was there, it was like the event of the year. I finally got to introduce my little three year old to Finn, Mike, Mercedes, Lauren, Santana, Brittany, and Puck. I guess it was after that that me and Puck lost contact.

Anyways, Quinn was now living with me in our amazing three room apartment right near my school. My daughter would still be with my parents during the day so Quinn didn't have to worry while she was out getting singing gigs. She was also getting back into ballet, she was amazing at it.

Artie and Tina moved in together, not 'together' though and started this band thing together, singing at various places through out New York and such.

Sam lived in a building next to ours and was doing various commercials and on the side working at the same school Blaine was at, teaching people how to play guitar, Sam was actually earning a lot of doe.

Lauren apparently married her biggest wrestling competition in college and is now happily living in South Carolina. Santana and Brittany are living together in LA, Quinn told me they started their own company.

Mercedes finally moved over here with the rest of us and is sharing an apartment with Rachel, she's a diva like always and doing shows most every night.

Mike was now choreographing dance musicals and such after joining us all in New York which was awesome. His dancing abilities are just astonishing and he's doing great for himself

Finn told me he took over Kurt's dad's shop and is doing fine just there, after all this time, I just realized he wasn't ready to leave home, he doesn't want to leave home.

Finally we get to Puck, since we're not talking anymore, I get all my information from Quinn. She says he owns his own night club, sounds just like him too. He'll play their some nights and from what Quinn says, he sounds happy.


once I finally graduated college, well, I got married! And not to just any body, but to the father of our child. She turned 4 and I really wanted to move back to Lima, after 4 years of living there, it really was my home. Besides, my brother Nick was still living there, in fact, he took over for Mr. Shue once he married Ms. Pilsbury and they moved down to Florida to start a family.

So i thought it would be a nice thing to do, we could start over as a family. It was nice for the first 2 years, when ever me and my husband wanted to go out we could just drop the little girl at Nick's or Finn's. She loved her uncle Nick and loved her uncle Finn twice as much.

For our daughter's sixth birthday, Mercedes, Kurt and Blaine, Quinn, Mike, and Tina and Artie came back to Lima to help celebrate. I remember her reaction when she saw the big play house Finn had been working on for over a week, she never left that thing after.

A few days later was when my husband, the father of our child asked for a divorce and I couldn't help but agree. Behind all the laughing and everything, it was a dysfunctional marriage, we both wanted out so that's just what we did. Sure our little daughter didn't like the idea at all, she cried for days, but she calmed down at one point.

Now my ex husband moved to the town over to work as the music teacher at the high school there. We settled for sharing our daughter in which I had her for two weeks and then he'd get her the week that followed and so on. She got to attend the elementary school in between from where we lived.

I started working at the same high school I attended, McKinley High School, the place really hadn't changed except for the missing of Mr. Shue and Coach Sylvester, the place was calmer. I became the 10th grade math teacher, it was nice, not only teaching my favorite subject but also working at a place with my brother Nick.

I had a great job, a beautiful six year old daughter, great successful friends, and even a friendship from my ex husband, I couldn't complain. I was happy, that's what I kept telling myself.


So what'd we think? It's kind of like an introduction to what the story will turn into and how we got to the next part. I'm going to try and not go crazy with a million chapters. Hopefully just ten and it will be a timeline of two weeks and many flashbacks!