Hi everyone! I'm aware I haven't finished my 'The One Where Rachel Gets Pregnant Story' (however, I do promise I'll finish writing it soon, or at least attempt to write another chapter before the week is over!) But this idea plopped into my head as I was watching the movie 'No Strings Attached' and I just HAD to write it. I have no idea whether its a good plot, or if its been done before, but reviews would be lovely! So without further or do, ... Here's No Strings Attached: Finchel Edition.
Chapter 1: 'Emotion vs. Sex'
"God, Rachel.." Finn moaned through the sheets as he gripped onto Rachel's bare back, digging his fingers deep into her skin. He quickly flipped them over, causing Rachel to slightly whimper as he thrusted himself beneath her, she grabbed onto his silky black hair and began to pull, hard.
"Finn, faster.. harder, please- oh!" Rachel screamed as Finn pressed himself on top of her chest, his fingers tenderly stroking her center as he moved himself back and forth, causing a speeding rhythmic sensation between the two. Rachel's eyes rolled to the back of her head as Finn quickened his motions, her screams transitioning louder, and Finn's smirk becoming quite noticeable when he witnessed Rachel reaching her climax.
"Finn!" She screamed his name, letting her head slam against her pillow. Finn proceeded, as he too climaxed into her. Moaning loudly, as his body roughly compressed against hers. He let his head fall onto her chest, closing his eyes for a brief moment, as he tried to catch his breath. Rachel smiled, her finger tips gracefully tangling in his sweaty hair.
A few days earlier...
Finn and Rachel had known each other since, well since junior high school. And they've always been 'good friends.' Now heading towards their senior year in high school, the two students have grown together, attending Glee club, going to movies together, getting lunch, studying with one another, and if their friends didn't know any better, they'd assume they were 'dating.' Sadly, this wasn't the case. Every time one of their fellow Glee club friends mentioned, or even questioned their friendship, the same answer was given every. single. time:
"We're just friends." Followed by an 'Ew!' from Rachel, and a laugh from Finn.
And as hard as it was to believe this statement, it was true. There was absolutely nothing 'romantic' in their relationship. And they thought of another as just friends, it was all they could ever picture themselves to be. Until a moment crossed between the two a few days ago that questioned just how far they were willing to go in their friendship...
"Rach, can I ask you something?" Finn asked, as he dropped his pencil and notebook onto the coffee table.
Rachel looked up to him, slightly confused as to why Finn would suddenly pause in the middle of their study session. "Sure, you can ask me anything." She slowly settled down her pen, and made herself comfortable on the couch, pressing her legs close to her body, looking over to Finn intensely.
Finn stopped for a moment, he wasn't exactly sure how to ask this. But he and Rachel were best friends, he trusted her. Biting his lip nervously, he proceeded with his question, "Does it ever bother you that you're like... still a virgin?"
Rachel eyes widened slightly, she gripped onto her two legs tighter, loosely fiddling with the cotton of her sweatpants, as she took one strand of her and placed it behind her ear, continuously looking down, unsure of how to approach Finn's question. "Sometimes, I suppose." She shrugged, "Does it bother you?"
Finn sighed, "I don't know. I mean it does, it's just-" Finn paused, shaking his head. "I just want to get it over with, man."
Rachel lifted her eyebrow, moving closer to Finn, clearly confused. "And why is that?"
Finn looked at Rachel with one of his, 'are you serious?' faces and slightly chuckled sarcastically, "You know just as well as I do, that everyone had lost their virginity at one point or another." Finn threw his hands in the air a bit, "Artie isn't even a virgin!"
He slowly stood up, grabbing a hold of his belongings and stuffing them inside his his bag. "Everyone knows you are I are pretty much the last two virgins in our entire grade." He zipped his bag and lifted it to dump it around his shoulder. "It's humiliating to hear one of the guys mention sex... and I'm sitting on my ass like the awkward virgin I am." He didn't understand why it bothered him so much, it just did. The only guy in his entire grade, never mind, his entire school, as he hasn't even gone past 1st base with a girl.
Rachel looked at Finn in pity, trying to find the right words to comfort him, but nothing came out. She wanted to tell Finn that he'd find the right girl, and when they were both ready, they would lose their virginity to one another, that it would be something special between the two lovers.
But It was then Rachel considered sometimes completely out of her nature to even think about, something that went out of her beliefs. A small sinister smirk cursed her lips as stood up, following Finn as he was just about to head towards the front door, stopping him in his path.
"Rachel, I gotta go. My mom's expecting me for dinner in a few minutes." Finn said annoyed, trying to push past Rachel.
Rachel shoved him back, as she blocked the front door. "What if I told you, that I had a proposition for you?" She slightly raised an eyebrow, her hands laying on her hips.
Finn looked at her confused, "What kind of proposition?"
"You said you wanted to lose your virginity-..."
"Please don't set me up with some cheerio, Rach. You know me, I'm not a dog-"
"Sleep with me." Rachel blurted out, her face completely serious.
Finn looked at her for a few seconds, slightly frozen at what she just said, but his facial expression soon transitioned to a loud uncontrollable laugh.
Rachel sighed sadly, "What's so funny?"
"Are you freaking insane? I'm not having sex with you." Finn said, his laughter slowly dying, as he shook his head.
"And why not? I'm a very attractive woman!" Rachel proceeded.
"I'm not saying you're not Rach. It's just- don't you get it? It's too weird. Plus, what if we do end up having sex, what if I like it? what if I start to like you and-"
Rachel made a disgusting look, "Ew. Never. Listen, we're best friends." Rachel walked closer to Finn, "And as your best friend, I want to do this for you. Besides, we know each other. And if we're being completely honest here, I want to lose it just as much as you do. But I can't with just anyone, I trust you, and at least if I do it with you, I'll feel comfortable and safe."
"You can't be serious."
Rachel nodded, "Oh, but I am." "And listen, if you're so scared, we'll establish a few ground rules." Rachel got up and grabbed the nearest pen and paper and sat back down.
"Rule #1: No falling in love." Rachel said aloud as she began writing. "I mean, it's just sex right?"
Finn began to smile, "I guess, I mean, there is such thing as emotionless sex right?"
Rachel grew excited, "Yes!"
Her eyes narrowed the paper, "Any more rules we should consider?"
"Rule #2: Can't tell anyone." Finn said. "Nobody can know about this, Rach."
"Agreed," Rachel stated, continuing to write.
"I think that's it..." Finn said, "So I guess we're sort of like sex buddies, right?" Finn chuckled, his shoulder bumping against Rachel's.
Rachel shook her head, completely serious, "No...no.. I prefer the term 'Friends with Benefits' thank you." She slowly made her way to the door, opening it for Finn.
"You think this is going to work out?" Finn asked.
"Of course. You don't have feelings for me, and I definitely do not have feelings for you. It'll be fine."
Finn nodded, "Right. Okay, so I guess I'll see you tomorrow, for the uh, ... I'll just see you tomorrow."
"You're awkward-ness amuses me, Hudson." Rachel laughed, "Now go home before your mom kills you."
Finn chuckled, "Bye, Rach." "Thanks, for the... sex?"
"You'll thank me after we do it, now go!" Rachel continued to laugh as she practically shoved him out the door.
And that's how it began boys and girls...
The next day Finn practically ran over to Rachel's house where he found the brunette in nothing but white lingerie, her room completely transformed, rose petals spread across the bed, and scented candles roamed the room in a sweet aroma.
Finn's jaw practically dropped when he witnessed just how beautiful Rachel was.
"Might as well make our first time special, right?" Rachel said in a slightly sexy, yet tender tone of voice.
All Finn could do was nod in agreement and wrap his arms around Rachel tight as he threw them onto her bed, soon finding himself kissing her eagerly, as he slowly started to shed his clothes, and drop them onto the floor.
Considering Finn and Rachel were the best of friends, Rachel predicted themselves having sex for the first time would be... awkward? But to her surprise, it was the exact opposite. Finn was so gentle with her, carefully making sure he wasn't hurting her. He was a bit hesitant at first, after all, they weren't dating, he didn't know what Rachel liked, of if what Finn was doing was making Rachel uncomfortable, but as soon as Rachel said 'go for it, touch me.' And guided his hand towards her breast, that was all the reassurance he needed to make Rachel's first, one she'll remember.
And it was. So good in fact, ... they decided to continue with their little 'friends with benefits' parade. All night long.
"So.. where does this leave us?" Finn said as he tried to gather his thoughts from the amazing sex they both experienced, he stared at Rachel across the bed awkwardly, the sheets covering their naked bodies.
Rachel shrugged, "I have no idea." Rachel knew what she was getting herself into the moment she pitched the idea of becoming what Finn insisted on calling 'sex buddies' ... She just didn't know he'd be so good at it. Since agreeing to this, they've had sex at least 3 times this week, if not more. And it's only been a little over a week since they've decided to begin their friendship as ... sex buddies.
"What do you mean you have no idea? We can't keep doing this, Rach... sooner or later one of us is going to end up having feelings for the other person!" Finn protested. He wasn't completely against having sex with Rachel, and to be honest, he actually loved having sex with her.. over and over again. But at the end of the day, she was still his best friend. And the last thing he wants to do is hurt her.
"Well its not going to be me," Rachel crossed her arms.
"It's not going to be me either."
"Then I don't get why we just can't have sex!" "You like it, I like it. What's the big deal?" Rachel said.
Finn's eyes widened in surprise, "I've never seen you act so... not.. Rachel." Finn smirked, "It's kind of hot."
Rachel simply laughed, "Listen, I don't want to be in a relationship." "My Broadway career depends on my full devotion if I ever want to achieve stardom."
Finn rolled his eyes, "Yeah, yeah, win Tony's and all that crap."
Rachel glared at him, and threw a pillow to his face. "As I was saying, we don't need to have emotional ties towards one another to have sex, we'll be in a healthy loveless sexual relationship." Rachel smiled, "I do like having sex with you, Finn." "And we don't have to continue it like we do now, we can do it whenever one of us is stressed, or we need to loosen up a bit."
Rachel stared over to Finn, who eyed her slightly hesitantly.
"Oh c'mon, it's every guys dream to practically have a friendship with no strings attached."
After a moment of silence, Finn finally caved in to Rachel, "Alright." A smirk escaping his lips as he shook Rachel's hand.
Rachel nodded, shaking his hand in return. "Then its settled."
Both Finn and Rachel looked around the bedroom awkwardly, wondering what to do next.
"Wanna go for Round 2?" Finn smiled over to Rachel.
"Please." Rachel said excitedly as she plopped herself on top of Finn, kissing him passionately.
So yeah, maybe having a sex buddy isn't so bad after all.
That's it for now guys! Sorry if its sort of short, I kind of wanna get a feel of it and ask what people think before I go full on ride with the next few chapters.
So I guess the real question is: How long will being 'Friends with Benefits' last before Finn and/or Rachel begin to develop feelings for the other one? ... I have a slight twist on how this might look.
Comments/Reviews are always greatly appreciated! Thanks everyone! I wanna know what you guys think so far! Should I keep going?
I'm like Tinkerbell, I need reviews to live!