Disclaimer: I do not own the Covenant, or any of its characters or places. You know the drill. This is purely fictional and for entertainment purposes only. That being said, Vera and Athena, however, are mine! :) Oh, and the title is after Taylor Swift's song You Belong With Me off her new album Fearless, which is just as good as her last one! :)

A/N: So I've been contemplating doing a sequel for Too Late, Should've Said No, and finally... I have decided to post it. So for those of you who don't remember or didn't read Too Late, shame on you! Just kidding, go read it because you might be confused, you might not be. I don't know. Anywho, here is the sequel, and I hope you enjoy! :) (Pictures of OCs available on my homepage...)

You Belong With Me
Written by SkyyRyder

Chapter 01

Athena Klien hurried down the hall to her dorm room; she had just left her friends' dorm room. Sarah Wenham and Kate Tunney had taken her shopping to get out of the dorms. It was Sunday and she had been blissfully bored out of her skull.

She had tried to rope her roommate, Vera, in to it but she was having lunch with her boyfriend's family. Tyler Simms and her roommate had been going out for several months and going strong. Athena was truly happy for them.

As for her love life; it was non-existent. Though, she wasn't complaining. She was enjoying her freedom and her friendship with her best friend, Reid Garwin.

They hadn't gone back to the way things were. They were just two best friends that confided in each other about everything for the last couple of months. The temptation, however, was still there and sometimes it was harder to fight off than she had thought it would be.

Reid seemed pretty content and he had been behaving himself. Athena had definitely noticed that.

She walked up to her door, key in hand when she heard noises coming from inside of the room. "Tyler… oh God…" A loud moan escaped a young woman's mouth; the sound of a headboard pounding against a wall was all it took for Athena to pull her hand back from the handle.

"Fuck," A man's voice groaned and Athena smirked.

She reached for her purse and pulled out her sticky notes. She took the pen that was hanging from their door and scribbled down a message. Retreating from the hallway she ascended a staircase and let herself in to room 316.

"Fuck, you scared me," A young man's voice snapped.

Athena smiled and grinned at him, "Sorry babe," She closed the door and crossed the room to his desk. "Your best friend is fucking my best friend… again…" She exaggerated.

The blonde smirked tossing his pen down, "We could give them a little competition."

The dark haired girl laughed, "Fuck off,"

"With you, hell yeah…" He gave his leg a pat.

"Stop being a perv for five minutes," Athena leaned over him to see what he had been writing.

Reid's eyes focused on her backside in the tight blue jeans, it was nearly perfect. Nice and plump just how he liked them. He bit his bottom lip, his gaze started going up to her waist, and the jeans were a bit loose there showing her hip bones jutting out.

Her leg brushed against his and Reid's palms began to sweat. He scolded himself mentally; he was seventeen nearly eighteen he couldn't be thinking like this, like some prepubescent teen.

"Reid!" Athena said his name for the third time. He snapped his head upward to look at her.

"Sorry, zoned for a minute," It wasn't a lie. He just would leave out the fact that he was having not-so-innocent thoughts about her.

"I noticed," She gave him a small grin.

Reid laughed, "What were you saying?"

"I asked what you were doing?"

"Homework,"

"I figured that out genius, I meant why?"

Reid smirked at her, "Because I'm a good student,"

"Right and I'm Mary-fucking-Poppins…"

Reid looked up at her and sat back in his chair; he laced his fingers behind his head and she gave him a small pout, "Seriously?"

"Yes,"

"I just felt like it,"

Athena nearly choked on her own saliva. She sat down in his lap and looked over the papers in front of him. The papers were detailed notes from American Literature. She swallowed hard.

"You took notes," She glanced over her shoulder to get a good look at him; his handsome face showed her that he was serious. She could feel the vibration on her back as he chuckled.

"Yeah Thee I took notes." Athena reached behind her and felt his forehead. Reid instinctively swatted her hand away. "What are you doing?"

"Checking for a fever; I think you need to see the nurse." She mused.

Reid snickered, "Oh so, you got jokes now?"

"I've had jokes, darling...."

Reid wrapped his arms around her middle, resting his chin on her shoulder. He was enjoying the closeness of her body to his. He didn't want her to pull away.

"In all seriousness Reid, what's with all this?"

"What are you talking about?" He asked innocently.

"First," She held up a finger. "Reid Garwin stops sleeping around." Reid snorted in reply.

"Yeah, I haven't had sex in like three months," He groaned. "My hand can only do so much,"

Athena wrinkled her nose at him, "You're awful,"

"And before then two months," He coughed, shaking his head. He had let out too much information.

"Wait," Athena turned abruptly in his lap and stared in to those amazingly blue eyes, "Are you telling me you didn't sleep with anyone after I started dating Aaron?"

"For the first couple of weeks I did, but after that, no…" He shook his head.

"Why not?" She questioned him.

"I told you, my standards were set too high after you…" He grinned at her playfully.

Athena stared at him for a second, a little weary, "Whatever," She laughed. "Secondly, you took notes in class," She lifted the papers. "And you're doing homework because you quote 'Felt like it' end quote." She scoffed. "I thought my best friend was Reid Garwin, not Tyler Simms?"

Reid laughed, "I'm still here, just organizing my priorities."

"Now you sound like Caleb,"

Reid smirked, he gave her his infamous 'I'm up to something,' look. Athena grinned and pinched his cheek. "There's my favorite Ipswich Boy,"

The both jumped at the feeling of vigorous vibrating between them. Athena jumped up and pulled out her cell phone. She had stuffed it in her back pocket earlier that day. Reid laughed as she slid the screen up.

1 New Pic Msg

She rolled her eyes wondering what the hell that could be. She selected to view the picture and started laughing at the picture before her. Vera was in an intense lip-lock with her boyfriend and Reid's best friend, Tyler Simms. The caption under it is what made her laugh even harder:

Fuck you, jealous bitch.

I loved Athena, Reid, Vera & Tyler in the first one so I knew I couldn't leave it alone. I hope you guys enjoyed! :) R&R!