Pinocchio was decorating his home with Geppetto and Pinocchia. "It's simply the favorite time of the year," said Pinocchio. "I wonder what I want for this holiday," he continued. "I know what I want," Pinocchia added. "What's that?" Pinocchio asked. "I want a notebook just so I can write my diaries," Pinocchia answered. "By the way, we could just surprise you," she continued. "That's a brilliant idea," Pinocchio commented. "I always surprise you anyway," Geppetto mentioned. "Sometimes however, you don't always need an item to give a gift especially to someone you love," Pinocchia stated as she sings Bob Haymes' That's All. After decorating the walls and the ceiling, it was time to decorate the tree. Pinocchio added the garlands while Geppetto added the lights and Pinocchia hung the ornaments. They then took a break eating pasta. Pinocchio and Pinocchia sang their own lyrical version of Michael Jackson's Got To Be There to each other in order to prove to their father that they can be brave, truthful, and unselfish especially on Christmas whenever they go out. The next day, Pinocchio, Geppetto, and Pinocchia went shopping. Pinocchio bought Pinocchia an extra pair of shoes while Pinocchia bought Pinocchio an extra pair of gloves. Geppetto just bought himself a new knife since his old one got dull. While they were walking around viewing the Christmas decorations of the town, Gideon and Foulfellow came back in their animal form and persuaded Pinocchio and Pinocchia to come to Pleasure Island again for the holiday spectacular. Pinocchio obviously knew that this was an evil trick. If Gideon and Foulfellow are the ones making people go to Pleasure Island, then it is affected with the donkey transformation spell. The two human behaving animals grabbed Pinocchio and Pinocchia and headed straight to Pleasure Island. "Wait! Come back!" Geppetto cried but it was too late. Gideon and Foulfellow already put Pinocchio and Pinocchia in the coachman's carriage which quickly took off. By the time they arrived to Pleasure Island, Pinocchio and Pinocchia followed Gideon and Foulfellow around the site to see Santa Claus. He was strapped and handcuffed to a chair. At that point, Pinocchio and Pinocchia drew their concealed foldable tomahawks and killed Gideon and Foulfellow. Afterwards, they unstrapped and unhand- cuffed Santa Claus. "Thank you so much for saving me! You deserve whatever you want," he said. "I think I want a Frozen theme poster of Anna and Elsa," said Pinocchio. "I want a notebook," said Pinocchia. At that point, Santa opened his bag and gave them what they wanted. Pinocchio and Pinocchia decided to invite him to their home where they had a pasta and fish party and sang Christmas songs. They then started opening presents. Pinocchio whispered "merry christmas" to Pinocchia and kissed her.