It was Unique the whole time. Ryder couldn't believe he was that stupid. He got played by a dude. If it helped in the slightest, she felt terrible. Ryder didn't know how to face her the next day in glee club. He got there and sat down in the very back. Everyone managed to make it on time. Unique stood in front of everyone. Finn spoke aloud "Ok guy's Unique has something she wants to say and something she wants to sing." She was left standing there, tears already in her eyes. She whispered "Ryder I'm sorry. I don't know what else to say, so I'll just sing." She gave a quick nod to Blaine who was already sitting at the piano.

I can take the rain on the roof of this empty house. That doesn't bother me. I can take a few tears now and then and just let them out." Ryder's sweet, subtle voice sang the next few lines; "I'm not afraid to cry every once in a while, even though going on with you though still upsets me. There are days every now and again I pretend I'm ok, but that's not what gets me." Their voices sang simultaneously "What hurts the most was being so close." Unique changed pitch "Having so much to say, and watching you walk away, and never knowing what could have been, as seeing that loving you was what I was trying to do." The rest of the song went through the two swapping lines and eye contact. By the end, her mascara was running and tears were pooling down his face. She asked in a hushed whisper "Do you forgive me Ryder?" He responded "I-I'll try.."