A/N: This chapter is a reader insert

"Lucifer, where are we going?" you whined as he helped you out of the Corvette since he had blindfolded you the second you left the precinct, "You know how much I hate surprises."

"Trust me, love," Lucifer assured you, "I promise it's worth it."

"It had better be," you huffed, "The last time someone tried to surprise me it did not end well." After he guided you for a few more minutes you asked, "Are we almost there?"

"We're nearly there," Lucifer promised, "Just a few more feet until we reach the elevator, and after a short ride up, we'll be there." True to his word, a few seconds later, you were ushered into an elevator and embarked upon what felt like the longest elevator ride of your life. When the elevator stopped and Lucifer helped you out, you recognized the familiar smell of your surprise destination.

"Lucifer, are we in the penthouse?" You asked as you sensed him walk around behind you.

"Why don't you find out for yourself," Lucifer said before he peeled off your blindfold, and you could just hear the smirk in his voice.

After blinking a few times to let your eyes adjust to the light, you let out a small gasp as you took in the scene in front of you. A spread of your favorite snacks and drinks was laid out on a table buffet style. The large glass windows facing the balcony had been covered with black blankets and the couch was piled with blankets and pillows. You also noticed the tv had a list of all your favorite movies queued up.

"What's all this?" you asked as surprise washed over you.

"Happy Valentine's Day, my love," Lucifer said and when you turned to face him, you saw he was holding out a bouquet of your favorite flowers.

"I don't know what to say," you said gently caressing the petals of the flowers Lucifer still held, "I thought-"

"That, I'd forgotten that it was our first Valentine's Day together?" Lucifer finished your thought and you nodded guiltily. He smiled and tipped your chin up so that he could look you in your eyes, "I would never. I just needed time to get everything right. I knew how much you didn't want an elaborate night out, so I set up a slightly less elaborate night in. I got all of your favorite movie marathon snacks and created a list of your favorite movies. All we need to do is change into something more comfortable, grab our snacks, cozy into the pile of blankets waiting on the couch, and press play on the first movie."
He paused, trying to gauge your reaction, "Do you like it?" He asked hesitantly, unsure of what you were thinking.

"It's perfect," you grinned before pulling his face down to yours for a kiss, "Thank you, Lucifer."

"It was my pleasure," Lucifer said with a broad smile after you pulled apart, "Anything for my girl."