Quinn loved Noah but not nearly as much as she did Will. Sure Noah was the safer choice because she had basically grown up with him and Will was at least 16 years older than the both of them. Will secretly hoped that Quinn would be the one student that came back and became Mrs. Schuester but he knew the odds were stacked against him and that there was a good possibility that Quinn didn't feel the same. When they finally had sex, they both felt a sense of home in each other's company which only made the sex even more natural for them. Something Quinn only wishes that she could feel with Noah.

As morning broke, Quinn awoke in the arms of Will Schuester, her teacher from high school that she secretly had a crush on but never thought that it would lead to this. She smiled at the adorable way his eyelashes gleamed in the sunlight. Will soon woke up to Quinn's gorgeous hazel eyes. Unbeknownst to him, he was in for a rude awakening, as he was about to speak, he realizes that he has morning wood. Quinn just snickered at the situation and asked him what happened last night. "Well, you called asking for a ride home, but was so hammered that you didn't know where home was. So I brought you here so that you could sober up but instead of sobering up you flirted with me and we had sex." Quinn's eyes got wide as she looked down at her and Will's naked bodies, "What?! Why did you think that was okay?!" She wraps herself up in one of his sheets before getting out of bed, frantically looking for her clothes. "I'm engaged..to Noah! Oh my Gosh! Noah! What am I gonna tell Noah?" Will quickly puts on a pair of boxers, "Quinn, I'm truly sorry, I never meant for this to happen. I just can't resist beautiful women in my bed." She quickly dresses herself in his bathroom, "Why was I in your bed? Is that the first place you put belligerently drunk girls when you bring them home?" "No! You begged me to let you sleep in the bed with me because you hate sleeping alone. I wanted you to feel safe." Quinn resurfaced from his bathroom, "Not a word of this to ANYONE, you hear me? If this gets back to Noah or my mom, they will gut you like a fish." Will just nodded, he understood the consequences of sleeping with Quinn Fabray.