His Cheating Heart, My Breaking Heart Part 1

Mitchie's Point of View

My confusion grew as Shane kissed me on the cheek and left, still glaring at the girl he called Lindsey. Nate and Jason's looks of shock changed to anger and they followed Shane out the door. Meghan and Kandi were just as confused as Lindsey bent down and whispered in my ear, "Stay away from Shane, if you know what's good with you." The color drained from my face.

I got up and walked out in a daze, having barely touched my food. I found Shane lying by the docks, his jacket off showing a tank top. He was fingering his pocket knife absentmindedly. I knew Shane wasn't going to do anything with it. I threw myself on top of him and crushed my lips against his. His eyes opened wide and then threw himself into the kiss as hard as he could. Some how he ended up on top of me with his shirt off, we were careful to keep the rest of our clothes on.

Nate's Point of View

I caught Meghan on her way out of the mess hall. Before I could say anything, she was bombarding me with questions.

"Who was that girl? Why did you 3 act so weird?"

"You'll have to ask Shane," I said quietly. I remembered the days after Shane had been hurt. The nights he woke up screaming, the times he would start yelling at us for no reason, and the years of anger. She was the reason he used to be a jerk.

"Why?" Meghan snapped me out of my thoughts.

Instead of talking, I pulled her in for a kiss. It lasted a couple of minutes before we pulled away gasping.

Jason's Point of View

Kandi was helping me make a birdhouse. We finished quickly. Kandi laughed and wiped some glue off my lips, with her mouth. I had never experienced a kiss like this. It was so awesome; it made me forget about birdhouses.

Shane's Point of View

I was extra careful to keep my weight off of Mitchie so I wouldn't hurt her.

"Wow, Shane. How come we never kissed like that?"

Mitchie's Point of View

I felt Shane stiffen against my body. He pulled me closer and ignored her. I could feel the anger in his kiss. I pushed him away. Fury ripped through my body. I wanted to hurt Shane for not telling me the truth. I forced myself out from under him and ran away in tears.

"Mitchie! Wait!" I could hear Shane calling my name. I stopped, out of breath, outside my cabin. Suddenly 2 arms grabbed my arms. "Please, let me explain," he whispered. I pulled free. "She's my ex-girlfriend."

Shane's Point of View

"What?" she gasped. I started from the day I saw Lindsey cheating on me.

Flashback

I couldn't wait to see Lindsey again. I hadn't seen her since I left to go on tour a month ago. I stood outside her room and heard her giggling inside. Something banged. It sounded like she fell off her bed. I rushed in, and gasped. There she was, kissing another boy. She heard the gasp and jumped up.

"Shane, this isn't what it looks like," she said feebly. I tried to respond but I was speechless. I recognized the guy she had been making out with. It was one of my best friends, Joey. We had been like brothers forever. He laughed nervously. I ran as fast as I could to the bus. Nate and Jason watched as I collapsed in tears on the ground.

"She… was… kissing… Joey," I managed to gasp out.

"According to Nate, every night for a month, I would wake up in the middle of the night screaming," I concluded.

"Thank you for finally telling me the truth," she whispered and laid her head on my chest. "I'm still mad."

"Will you ever forgive me?"

"Maybe," she said looking like she was about to laugh.


I don't remember where I got the title, I've heard the name Her Cheating Heart before. Oh yeah, Home Improvement episode. The name Joey has nothing to do with Joe Jonas, I was watching Full House when I came up with the name. (If you haven't seen Full House, one of the main characters is Joey and he's hilarious)