Santana opened the box and gaped at the beauty of the necklace within it.

"Noah, I don't know what to say," she smiled whole-heartedly. They were sharing a cold park bench, admiring the stars. Who knew he would have remembered their old anniversary?

Puck reached inside the box, pulled out the diamonds and wrapped it around Santana's neck, securing it. "Say…I love you."

Santana rolled her eyes playfully. "I love you."

"I love you too, babe." He leaned in to kiss her, but Santana covered her lips with her hand.

"What about Rachel?"

Puck laughed, "I said, I love you."