The sun rises in Jingletown, and everyone starts to slink out of bed- except Johnny, who had a late night. He spent most of his night trying to guess Will and Heather's surprise. Meanwhile, in the center of the town, a bus stops by and drops off two people, who seem foreign to the city.
Will is waiting for the people to get off the bus. He seems eager to meet and welcome his guests into town. "So great you two could come. Johnny and Tunny are gonna be so surprised," Will says, as he takes their bags and walks them to the house. Upon entering, they're greeted by Heather.
"Oh, it's so nice to finally meet you. We've heard so much about you," Heather says, shaking the visitors' hands.
Just then, Tunny walks out of his room and sees his surprise. "Oh my God! Extraordinary Girl?" Tunny exclaims as he runs into her arms. "Wow, I can't believe you're back from the military so early. I thought you weren't gonna be back for another six months."
Extraordinary Girl starts to tear as she hugs him and says, "They released me early. I wanted to come back to surprise you…and look who I brought with me."
Tunny looks to the side and sees a girl standing by Extraordinary Girl with a purple streak in her hair, whom he can't recall the name.
"I thought I'd give Johnny another chance," says Whatsername.
Will cuts in, "He's gonna be so surprised when he sees you. His room's down the hall to the left."
The rest of the group catches up in the living room while Whatsername walks down the hall to Johnny's room. Suddenly, they hear Whatsername scream from Johnny's room. They run in to the other room to find her freaking out. She screams, "What is that guy doing in Johnny's bed?"
Johnny and Jimmy finally wake up from all the screaming. They see everyone has surprised looks on their faces. "Hey guys, what's everyone doing in my room?" Johnny asks groggily.
Whatsername seems the most shocked out of everyone. She walks over to his bed, sits down, and asks, "What's this guy doing in your bed?"
"Oh my God, I can't believe you're here!" He jumps up to give Whatsername a hug, while she's frozen in disbelief. "You remember St. Jimmy, right? Wait, you can see him? Finally!"
The group stares in awe as Johnny hugs St. Jimmy. Whatsername is so beside herself she has to step outside. Heather goes to comfort her, mumbling, "I guess he really wasn't crazy…"
Will walks over and demands to know what's going on.
"It's just as I explained when we first got home," Johnny says. "When I went away on that road trip, I met St. Jimmy. He helped me deal with all my problems. I got to meet Whatsername. Some people told me I was crazy and that Jimmy wasn't real. But I didn't believe them. How could an imaginary friend affect me so much?"
Will cuts in, "Enough with the monologue, all that matters is that he's here now and we all know you haven't lost it. I just don't know how we can see him now."
Tunny answers "That doesn't matter, as long as Johnny's happy, right?"
St. Jimmy turns to the side and maniacally laughs to himself.
"Dude, what was that laughing about," Tunny asks to Jimmy.
St. Jimmy jumps up and says, "Let's change the subject. Hi, I'm Jimmy. We haven't gotten a chance to officially meet." He puts out his hand to Tunny and when Tunny goes to take his hand, he gets zapped by one of those hand buzzers that Jimmy happens to be wearing. He laughs along with Johnny, who jumps in and says, "Wow that was funny Jimmy. Hey, let's go out so we can introduce you to everyone else who said I was crazy."
"That's a great idea Johnny, let's get outta here." They hold hands and walk outside past Whatsername and Heather, who walk back inside. Everyone is so confused as to what just happened. Heather finally breaks the silence, "What just happened here?"
