I love you, Mr. Winchester and Mr. Winchester

This is a story about a love triangle of Sam Winchester, his girlfriend Erin Jacobs, and Dean Winchester. Sam and Erin are in love, and Dean… well he feels more for his brother's girl than he should. Multiple POVs, chapter name equal who's POV is being used. Sorry it's been a little bit of a wait from chapter 1 to 2, I've been really busy.

Chapter 2: Dean

I finish up the cherry pie I ordered, and give a nod to the waitress for my bill. She walks toward me, and yeah of course I look her over. She looks maybe twenty, she has a great body and long red hair. I can tell she is checking me out too; she smiles at me as she puts my bill down on the table. I move the piece of paper over so that I can see it and underneath the total, is 'Kelly 555-5555'. Well Dean Winchester you have not lost your touch. I chuckle at myself, then take a five dollar bill out of my wallet and place it with the bill. I get up out of the booth and walk toward the door, out to baby. "Hello baby, daddy's back." I say to my Impala and as I get in. I start her up, listening to hear glorious engine come to life then and drive over to the motel where Sam and Erin are staying across the street. Once I arrive I get out of my car and walk over to the door. I press my ear to door to make sure nothing is going on in there that I don't want to see, never know with those two, but it seems ok. I open the door to see Sam sitting on the bed with his laptop in lap and Erin is I'm assuming in the bathroom or something, because I don't see her.

"Hey Dean," says Sam looking up from his computer at me. "Can I talk to you outside?" He says quickly placing his laptop to the side, standing up.

"Uh, sure Sam." I say holding open the door, as he walks through. We walk over to the Impala, and we sit on the hood. "So what's up?" I say to him.

"Ok I uh, I know this is gonna sound crazy but," Says Sam sounding nervous. "I'm gonna ask Erin to marry me." I look at Sam for moment.

"Well that uh, that's great Sammy." I say with a fake smile. "That really great." I say giving him a half hug.

"Thanks hey, I really wanted your support on this and I really appreciate it." Says Sam with a smile.

"So what are you boys doing out here?" Says Erin walking outside, drying her hair with a towel, wearing a big t-shirt and black sweatpants, she looks so beautiful with her hair all in a mess, in her pajamas.

"Oh uh, just talking about plans for the new case. Right Dean?" says Sam scratching his head and looking at me.

"Ah, yes um, there have been multiple shape shifters that have been allegedly impersonating politicians. Garth called me and told me about the case. Said he was going to do it himself but some family business came up."

"Politicians aye?" She says chuckling. "Well that's not conspicuous. Oh I noticed that redhead was checking you out. Did you get her number?"

"Yes, but when I think about it, eh better not." I say smiling at her. She smiles back me.

"Well I'm beat." Says Sammy, "Babe you ready to go to bed?" he asks Erin.

"Sure." She says as Sam stands up taking her hand.

"I'm gonna stay up a while." I say to them as they walk toward the door.

"Ok, well good night." Says Sam as he opens the door. As they walk into the room, I sit there on the Impala with my hands in my pockets. I lie back on my back and look up at the stars. Sammy and Erin, married? I mean yeah I'm happy for my brother, why wouldn't I be but, it's just… I am jealous, and I know why. I've tried to block it out, I've tried sleeping with other women, distracting myself with cases, I've done everything. Everything I can do to not have to face the inevitable. I shouldn't feel this way towards her, for gosh sakes she is in love with my brother. What else can I do, erase my emotions? I'm human. I don't know what else I can do to try to block out the fact that I have fallen in love with her. The way she smiles, the way she laughs, how quickly she can get my mind off of things that make me sad. After the whole ordeal with Lisa I had decided I would never let myself feel that close to someone like that again. I know how she feels about Sam. I know she loves him very much; it's obvious the way she looks at him. Sammy and I swore we would never let a girl come between us. As I lay there with my thoughts I slowly begin to drift into the dream world.

"Dean, Dean, Dean where are you?" I hear a small voice say faintly. "Dean, Dean, Dean." The voice continues on. I run through the woods, squinting my eyes. It's so foggy and misty, I can hardly see anything. I keep running in the direction the voice is coming from, when I see her on the ground covered in blood. With what looks like black angel wing shadows surrounding her. I bend down and touch her face and realize that she isn't breathing. Then I look up and see Cas, looking down at me.

"Dean there is something you should know." Says Cas. Before I can say anything I wake up shaking, my hands cold to the bone. I sit up, rubbing my eyes and face and look at my phone, to check the time, 12am. I hop off of the hood and go inside. I see Sam and Erin sleeping in the bed farthest away from the door, they look close and happy together. Sam has Erin under his arm, she'll never know how much I wish that was me with my arm around her. I lay down on my bed and try to sleep, thinking how I wish things could be different.

"Dean? Dean?" I hear her voice say, I open my eyes to see her looking down at me.

"Good morning sunshine." Says Sam from a distance.

"Gosh," I say, "What time is it?" I ask rubbing my eyes and head.

"Almost eleven," she says handing me a cup of coffee. I take the coffee and take a sip of it and let out a yawn. "Everything's packed and ready to go." She says, standing up. She walks over to Sam and hugs him, giving him a kiss. I look down when I see them like that. "I love you." She whispers.

"Not as much as I love you." Says Sam grinning at her, followed by a kiss, she chuckles and kisses him back. I make a sarcastic cough to break up all the mushy-mushy. "Dean you should take a shower and get dressed, and there is a bagel for you on the table over there. We're gonna go put the bags in the Impala." Says Sam to me, letting go of Erin, grabbing her hand. I rub my eyes one more time to adjust to the light, and stand up.

"Yeah ok," I say yawning again. I walk over to my duffel bag of clothes and grab a pair of jeans, undershirt, a black t-shirt, my green flannel shirt, tooth brush and paste, then walk into the bathroom. I strip out of the clothes I was wearing the day before then hop into the shower. I set the water temperature to warm, not hot don't want to scold my skin and let the warm water wash over my body. I use the little travel size bottled shampoo the motel provided on the counter to wash my hair, then wash my body. I dry myself off and grab my clothes. Dammit, looks like I forgot my underwear, I wrap the towel around my waist and open the bathroom door. Before walk out of the bathroom I stop and look at myself in the mirror. Huh, I wonder what she would say if she saw me like this. I raise my arms and flex my muscles. Damn I look good. I know it's conceited to say but I know I am a handsome son of a bitch. I poke my head out of the door to make sure she isn't out there to see me nearly naked. I know Sammy would never forgive me if his girlfriend, well soon to be fiancé, saw me naked. I don't see anyone so I walk out of the bathroom over to my bed where my bag is. I hear the door open and I freeze.

"Oh gosh Dean, I'm so," she says then stops looking at me for a moment. I look at her, and then she looks down saying, "yeah I'll just," she quickly rushes out of the room, in embarrassment. Oh yeah she was so checking me out, I can tell just based on those bright red cheeks of her's. That's one thing I really like about her is how she blushes. I chuckle and then walk back into the bathroom and dress. I look up at the mirror and am startled.

"Geez Cas you don't just pop up out of nowhere like that!" I say alarmed.

"I'm sorry Dean, I just needed to talk to while you were alone. I tried to contact you last night while you were asleep. There is something you need to know."

To be continued… In Chapter 3: Erin