A/N: Sorry it took me so long to come up with this, I was trying to decide who were going to be the three girlfriends and my mind was split. Anyway, thanks so much for the reviews on last chapter, you guys are really the best ;)

Also, most of the chapters will be told as if they were flashbacks and so you won't get confused I centered everything that was happening in the 'present'. The time and space can also get confusing so let's just say that Punk's story will take place this year (2011) and that he and his daughter are living ten years from now… weird, I know but I hope it works.

Definetely Maybe: Chapter Two

"Earth to Phil, are you still here with us?"

Shaking his head out of the trance he has been submerged into and tilting it towards the source of the voice that seemed to be talking to him, the Chicago Native known as Phil Brooks blinked a couple of times and mumbled an absent mindedly 'uh?' under his breath.

"Man, you spaced out for a while there. Please don't tell me you are thinking about the Lita girl again?"

Wrinkling his nose and snorting, Phil shook his head in negation. "No… why would I be thinking about her?"

"Well, to start you had that weird expression in your face you only get when you are thinking about her and second, she's the only thing you've been thinking about for the last week or so."

Grunting, Phil slapped his face and then dragged his hand down to his unshaven jaw. Maybe Kofi was right in something, for the last week his ex-girlfriend has been the most recurrent thought on his mind and in more times that he cared to count he has been found thinking about her.

But it was just that he couldn't help it, because as it always happened in cases like that his mind has been invaded with lots of 'why' and 'what did I did wrong' and to that day he still had no answer, only questions and memories.

He especially had a recurrent memory of her and it was about the way she had ended a one year relationship with him by the phone only by saying that she wanted time for herself.

So yeah, it was obvious that he has been thinking a lot about her since that call, after all a few minutes before she so suddenly broke up with him he had thought they were doing perfectly fine… hell, he even got a tattoo of her damn face in his arm a month ago so that spoke volumes of the commitment he had towards her!

But did she care about that? Nooo, she didn't care about shit and like most people had warned him, when he was last expecting it she ended up things.

But that was all in the past so clearing his throat, Phil shrugged again. "Actually, I wasn't thinking about her. I was thinking about this new pet project Vince wants me to take a part of. Didn't you hear?"

Shaking his head no, Kofi folded his arms to his chest and puffed out a breath. "I'm not high enough in Vince's totem pole to know about his new projects."

"Well good for you because listen to this; this is intern so he probably just told the guys he wants to torture but anyway, he's making some shit like adopt a Diva kind of thing and starting tomorrow he'll make me train one of those girls so I can teach her how to really wrestle."

"Really?" The other man laughed out loud and Punk quirked his mouth.

"Don't laugh, this is some serious shit. According to him, the Divas need to step up in their game and we have to teach them everything!"

"Oh man, that sounds awful. Do you at least get to choose your Diva?"

"That's the worst part, I can't choose; not that choosing will help. All these girls are clueless in that ring and you know I don't have the patience to tutor no one."

Grinning, Kofi shrugged. "Maybe you'll get lucky and get Phoenix… oh, talking about her; please explain to me what's the deal between you two?"

"Okay, first things first; Phoenix is not a part of the project and second, what do you mean what's our deal?"

"Oh come on, you've been hanging all around the country with her even before Lita gave you the boot so you know, what's the deal?"

Pushing his lip ring with the tip of his tongue, Phil tilted his head to the left and fixed his eyes on the man sitting in front of him. "The deal is that she is my friend, she's like one of the guys and believe it or not she's the best gym partner I know."

Humming, Kofi leaned forward and arched an eyebrow. "Well, then let me tell you this, I think your gym partner likes you. Who knows, maybe she'll make you forget Lita in a matter of nothing."

Laughing out loud, Phil threw his head back and then rolled his eyes. "You are insane… Phoenix is…"

Moving his head to the side, Phil searched around with his eyes until he caught a glimpse of his female friend. She was talking with one of the girls near the beverage table and she was oblivious to what he and Kofi were talking.

"She's asexual. Okay, not that but like I told you, she's like one of the guys…" Sure, she looked prettier in a dress than any of the guys would but she was still… her!

He has known her for years and hooking up with her would be… weird, almost as dating a sister.

"I think you two would make a great couple; neither of you drinks or smokes, you like the same things and you already like each other enough to go everywhere together."

"Nah… just drop it."

"Okay man, whatever you say. Just remember this conversation in a few months. But anyway, you never told me who is going to be your Diva."

Snorting at the thought of who Vince threw at him to train, Phil shook his head and grunted once again. "This is worse than that NXT crap, trust me. He's making me…"

"Oh look at that." Kofi said interrupting Phil. "I think I know who's going to make you forget about Lita. Guess I'll see you around man."

With the word at the tip of his tongue, Phil turned around and his eyes were immediately greeted with a sight he thought he was never going to see.

"Phil Brooks, blessed are the eyes that see you." The pretty redhead said with a playful chuckle and Phil could do nothing other than stare at the newcomer with a big smile on his face…

"So who was she?"

Arching an eyebrow and looking down at the girl sitting at the chair across from him, Phil blew out a breath and took off his cap to put it on his table. "Are you going to let me finish or what?"

Nodding, the girl took a sip of her Pepsi and then smiled. "Of course I will, daddy; I just want to know so I can decide if she is my mom or not. I don't think Lita is my mom, she doesn't feel like mom. Anyway, what was the name of this new one?"

Clicking his tongue to his cheek, Phil scanned his brain for the first name his mind could grab and once he got it he threw it out there. "MaKi, her name was Maki and she was someone I haven't seen in a very long time…

"MaKi-" Phil said as he stood up from his chair and his right hand automatically went up to scratch behind his ear. The newcomer laughed and without thinking it twice she took two steps towards him and hugged him.

At that, Phil smiled and hugged her back; thinking that even if years have passed since the last time he held the woman so close, she basically still felt the same.

Sure, she was wearing another perfume and her hair was longer, but other than that she still felt the same.

"What are you doing here?" He asked as he pulled away from her so he could take a good look at her head to toe.

"Well, I just came to visit." She said with a playful shrug as her green eyes fixed directly into his.

"Look at you, you look great." He said out loud as he scanned her, his eyes taking everything he could.

"Nah, I'm just same ol' me. But you… God, look at your hair!" She exclaimed happily as she casually lifted a hand to touch it to his hair.

"Yeah, I know." Rolling his eyes, the Chicago native lip's curved into a smile as her hand continued to move through his hair and then slowly crawled down to the nape of his neck.

"I like it; maybe I liked it better when it was a bit shorter but you know, it is a good change." Tilting her head and refusing to tear her eyes from his, MaKi dropped her hand away from him and laughed.

"So what about you? It's been a while, uh?"

"Well…" MaKi said with a big smile as she lifted her left hand up, making him catch a glimpse of the big engagement ring that adorner her finger.

"Ohhh." Punk said and raised both eyebrows. "I see you'll be tying the knot; who's the lucky guy?"

"Someone, you don't know him." She responded with a shrug and Phil sighed out loud.

So yeah, he had a history with that woman and even when it went back to a few years prior he still didn't feel comfortable seeing her beaming about marrying some other dude. Not that he still had feelings for her… but as she stood right in front of him he couldn't help but to think that if things would have gone her way, he would have been the one putting rocks in her finger.

And he would have done it, with time he would have… but destiny conspired against them and they had ended up breaking up things amicably. Now there she was, years after and looking beautiful as ever.

"Well this someone is a lucky bastard."

"Luck is for losers, someone taught me that a long time ago." She said with a wink, showing him with that little act that she still had that lively personality he had liked so much back in their day.

"Someone very smart I bet." Taking a step towards her so he could be a bit nearer, Punk lowered his eyes to her lips and smirked.

"But of course," After she breathed those words out, the two former lovers remained like that, standing in the middle of catering and staring at each other; probably remembering a thing or two about their past. "So…"

"So." Phil repeated as he placed both hands to his hip. "Will you be staying for the show?"

"Oh yeah, I've been hearing about this guy CM Punk stealing the show every night and I definitely want to see that live."

Licking his lips, Punk swallowed down the urge of saying something about how her fiancé had to be a very confident man if he was allowing her to go to the show just so she could see him perform; but instead of saying that he just nodded.

"I was thinking that you know, maybe after the show was over we could go and grab a bite or something… I mean if you are not busy."

"Oh no, I'm not busy at all." He was just going to have a late dinner with Phoenix but since they did that constantly, he didn't think the current Diva was going to mind.

"Good, then I'll go and say hello to the other guys and… I'll see you around."

Smiling, Punk nodded. Oh yeah, she was definitely going to see him around…

"Did you have sex with her that night?"

"Hey, what did I tell you?" Phil asked out loud as he stared down at his daughter. "No sex questions."

"But how will I know which one of your girlfriends was mom if I don't know if you had sex with her or not?"

Phil opened his mouth to respond but before any word could escape pass his lips he closed it back again and then snorted. "How did I let you convince me about telling you this story?"

"Because…" The girl responded rolling her eyes. "Anyway, MaKi was going to get married with another man but still went to that show only to see you? Isn't that cheating?"

"Aaaaand we are so not going to discuss that, let's just say that MaKi and I were really good friends and that we went out that night just to catch up…"

"Hmmm, Cynthia is right. Guys only like women for sex."

Snorting is disbelief at the constant use of the word sex by his kid and most importantly, the context in which she was now using the damn word, Phil dropped the fork down in his plate and send the girl a look that made her look down to her own plate.

"What did I say to you? And who is Cynthia?"

Tilting her head up, the black haired girl sighed. "A neighbor, when mom has to work late she calls her to keep an eye on me."

"Okay, so she's your babysitter. How old is she?"

Rolling her eyes dramatically, the girl giggled. "Babysitters are for babies, she just keeps an eye on me."

"Yeah yeah, how old is she and why does she thinks she knows about guys and sex? But most importantly, why is she talking about it with you?"

Shrugging and dropping her fork down in the same manner her dad did a few minutes ago, the girl tilted her head to the side and quirked her lips.

Phil didn't say anything to that little petulant act only because she didn't talk back to him in the sarcastic little tone she sometimes carried with her. True, the girls probably got that from him but even though his daughter sometimes didn't know how to stay quiet, it was obvious that she recognized the signs of a serious Phil in full daddy mode and in that moment he was in one of those modes.

He really didn't like how his daughter's mind was operating around sex and as soon as he could he was going to have a serious talk with her mother about it.

Making his mind about it, the tattooed man sighed. "You dropped your fork, are you done eating?"

"No."

"Then finish up so you can do your homework."

"But today is Friday!"

"Great, that way you'll have the entire weekend for yourself."

"Will you continue with the story?"

"I don't know, it depends."

Rolling her eyes and picking up her fork, the girl took a bite of her food and chewed in silence.

Phil observed her, shaking his head ever so lightly as he pushed his bottom lip with the tip of his tongue. Maybe it was that she looked exactly like her mother, but if one was to observe the way she talked and a lot of her manners, one would definitely conclude that she took up after him.

"Isabel." He said and the girl looked up, her big olive green eyes locking up with his. "I'm going to tell you something and I want you to engrave it in your mind until you are very old. Men are a bunch of pricks; you can't trust them… unless it's me of course. But because I'm not always going to be around, you really should try to stay away from them until you are I don't know, thirty, that's around the time you will start dating."

"Thirty? But…"

"No buts."

"Was mom thirty when she dated you?"

Snorting, Phil leaned forward and rested his elbows over the table. "Exactly my point," If her mom would have waited until her thirties to date around, she would have had better sense that getting pregnant by him.

Not that he was going to tell Isabel that…

"Now keep eating, and I might continue telling you this story."

TBC

A/N: Okay, in case you were wondering MaKi is Maria (couldn't think of a better name, sorry!), Phoenix is Beth and Lita… well, you know who she is but unfortunately she's not going to be one of the three girlfriends just because she never worked with Punk…

So there's just one woman to be revealed and in case you didn't guess it, it will be the Diva he has to train :)